Ugh OK but it'll be Bert's gut, not Bert, because Bert is home for the holidays and isn't doing anything other than sit on the couch and watch sports mostlyIn post 3665, KoreanBBQ wrote:Thor mentioned in his readlist that you said that regarding me.
Also I kinda want bert to list his full readlist.
Arthur Dayne (his defending SSK wagon tonight after being listed as a scumspect if SSK lynch does not go through - town motivated IMHO)
Nacho - although I'm toying with him still, he is kinda townie since he joined the hurrah last night - however, his choices for targets are all super easy lynches and it's really lame, but he did this lame thing in Chosen Mafia too and is also coming off a terrible performance in 534, where he pushed Mario4 for days and a few other lurkers...why are we following him, again? Oh right, he has proven himself. Thor is freakin sarcastic and I Didn't realize that about him until yesterday night, so my read may have been way off as I just assumed the posts were mostly Nacho, hence that big ol scumread.
Sakura - after the AtE which I expect her to be decent enough to not to do as scum.
GIF is hard to read and is a sleeper.
SC - is too out-there and then lurks, which annoys me, and the attitude of Varsoon annoys me, and it's hard to read someone so annoying in tone (sorry it's true).
Falcon - I want to call him town, but I'm holding back after seeing his scumgame in 247. I want to wait in case his scum-true-colors show up and he goes after me crazily or shows some serious doubt at ANY point of the game. If he ever does that to someone he reads so well, then that's a scumclaim for him pretty much.
Bro annoys me, so does
Muffin. Partly their reputation as scum, and then Muffin's play has been sketchy. Bro's has to at points where he released reads. I rely on what they think of me as well, their progressions, and Bro's made no sense. Muffin just pings. They are in the null-scum category because I am not familiar with either player. They don't expand broadly enough for me to ever feel comfortable with them.
DOMO - cutesy way of interacting with me rubs me the wrong way. Terrible logically, but also has that tinge of perennial-lynchbait.
Maraca - Mara shot down my townread of Cabd tonight, and her absolutely terrible read on me and explanation why. Was giving her the benefit of the doubt after the mason claim, and how I've seen them lynched easily, but man oh man that is bad tonight. This wreaks of the terrible scum-logic Mara had in 534. And then the claims remind me of 1489 Wingate, OH IM CLEARED LOVER, except its Mason this time. This is on par with how she wanted me dead and had an antagonist (me) with Nacho around in Wingate.
Geists - listed three friggin large BIG reasons why Sakura could easily flip town, yet went after her as a primary suspect. C'mon. That, and gut feelings from 1436, but I don't think I've ever read her as town ever since that game and probably won't ever recover from it anyway. But still gut screams scum, and this is Bert's gut y'all! Maybe they'll lead a wagon and show some guts sometime, but until then I'm unconvinced.
Desperado - interactions with DOMO seem off gut-wise (Desperado, if you want to say this is dumb, please just save it and assume it has already been said <3)
I'll finish this in 20 minutes after I get off the phone.
Tammy hasn't been here enough since I came into the game for her to go super town on me (only a drunkposting extravaganza and a showing last night, that's it, so it's TBD).
SSK - don't know anything about him/her, vote on him/her is totally a sheep the herd
GM - is apparently a mason with Maraca, and weirdly I don't remember anything about him/her. I don't read stuff that happens before I got here, well skim ISO's maybe once or twice but nothing more will happen
Not everyone who's scummy can be scum, so it comes down to who is MOST scummy.