I seem to be 13 pages behind, so this will be more of a catch up post than I suspected...
@House
You didn't answer this:
In post 565, VictorDeAngelo wrote: In post 348, House wrote:Also also... you haven't even interacted with CCC... Meeeehhhhhhh
Not a good look.
Why are you so concerned about Huntress interactions at this point?
In fact I don't think you responded to anything in
565, which is odd.
In post 575, House wrote: In post 572, gerryoat wrote:Okay so
@House
Yes, I like your case on CCC. But, I have to admit CCC has had great responses to your points, do you not think he might be town at all? Or at least rethinking your fos a bit?
I'm still happy with my vote, hence where it remains.
He's acting the same way he did in Arctic Mafia, buy the thing is, he SHOULD have improved since Arctic Mafia on some level if he had actually taken the advice he received.
Absolute crap. This is just a poor excuse for ignoring meta.
In post 600, eagerSnake wrote:
Manuel is throwing suspicion on Square, but not voting or FOS'ing. That makes me suspect a Manuel/Square scum team is a possibility.
VOTE: Square World
If your square read relies on Manuel being his buddy, why vote Square here, ahead of Manuel?
In post 614, eagerSnake wrote:VOTE: Manuel87
I'm lynching in Manuel and Square today. One or both are scum.
This vote is also OMGUS and the confidence here one Square seems completely unfounded.
I like CCC's
638. Snakes response in
642 doesn't fly with me at all.
In post 676, eagerSnake wrote:I have been leaning slightly scum on Gamma also, but I don't think he's the right lynch for today. He is, at the very least, responsive. I can't say that about everyone here.
Hmmm... If eager flips scum I would look closer at Gamma.
In post 679, gerryoat wrote:Why do you guys always post so much when I'm gone, and when I'm here, nothing gets posted. Alright I'm gonna do a reads list from towniest to scummiest
Town
Grendel
eagersnake
House
GammaEmerald
Manuel
The_Jester
CCC
VictorDeAngelo
Huntress
SquareWorld
VOTE: SquareWorld
I would prefer to lynch in my bottom 3, that's my prefrence. Nothing Square has said has really stood out to me. He tried to make a werid case on me that didn't make sense, and it seemed he backed off a bit when no one would follow.
Grendel, despite fosing me, I think is town for the reasons I stated earlier, he seems like he's actually scumhunting, and trying to find mafia. He also casted doubt on me when I first gave my TR on him, which imo is a TR. I wish he'd just see that I was town too. Eager has had good posts since the beginning and has been consistent the whole time, which I really like. House has really shot up my townread since subbing in. I don't think CCC is the best vote today, but I do like his case on him. But, I also like CCC's responses, so I would prefer not to vote him.
I don't like this A lot of talk about why people are townreads and yet next to nothing on his scumreads. He's happy to lynch either me or Huntress but doesn't want to say why. Feels like someone trying not get people on side and not rock the boat.
In post 680, gerryoat wrote:
(filler, trying to cast more doubt on me the 2nd time after it didn't work the first time.)
Asking if your an alt is doubtcasting now.
In post 421, Square World wrote:don't want to lynch Grendel, House, CCC, eagerSnake and VictorDeAngelo
anyone else just call me and i'll join
(I'm thinking there is at least 1 maf in there. It might be Victor or CCC, but I'm not really sure.)
Betting that there's 1 scum in a group of 5 players in an 11 person game is hardly a long shot. You have gone in my estimations.
I have no idea what Gamma's doing here or why.
In post 721, Gamma Emerald wrote: In post 720, House wrote: In post 716, Gamma Emerald wrote:I'd like to add more to points 3 and 6.
@3: There's this role on EpicMafia called Oracle that reveals a persons role if the Oracle is killed. I've seen an Oracle get lynched intentionally Day 1, although since it was Daystart forum mafia, the role had to be modified to work Day 1.
@6: So the "changing claims" thing can only really happen in a closed setup. Okay.
This is not EM.
Advice for EM is not relevant here.
It was a proof of concept post.
Scumnotch +1 for House for that rather tasteless and pointless nitpick.
You can't give scumpoints to players for discussing theory, when your actively seeking advice. I would say that if House becomes conf!town I would listen to House as he knows what he's doing. Alas, I'm still confident he's drawn red in this game.
In fact, forget everything else. Square World catch up is bull. If he/she is that disinterested then why not replace out. And why only periods of activity when the pressure is on. Square is now my preferred lynch.
1) It doesn't.
2) You didn't think that at the time.
In post 849, House wrote:
When he flips town, you and Gamma need to be lynched for being the scum on the wagon.
Then Victor needs to be lynched for being scum off the wagon.
Victor has more experience with my town game than CCV and he's voting me although EVEN CCC recognizes my town play? That's hysterically obvious.
VOTE:
More nonsense. You're more than capable of doing townie things as scum. In fact I'd go further and say that your town/scum meta is not easily distinguishable IIRC.
Though the funny thing is, I agree with you that Manuel is a bad lynch.
=============================================================================
I find the number of townreads I have left in this game is diminishing. However, for the sake of coming to a conclusion I'm going to split you all into will vote won't vote piles:
Won't vote: Grendel, CCC, Manuel, The_Jester, Gamma, Gerry, Huntress
Would vote: House, EagerSnake, Square World
Square is preferred lynch but that's not happening. Neither is House. So eager it is:
UNVOTE:
VOTE: EagerSnake