mith wrote:Also, I am considering having two sets of judges, with the awards split between them, to avoid the judges-being-nominated problem entirely.)
I expect with the size of the site these days, you'd have very little trouble picking judges after January 15th (or whatever the cut-off is for noms) that weren't seconded for anything. Unless you have some sort of Secret Squirrel algorithm for picking judges...
Max: It sounds like what you're talking about is the new "Don Corleone" Award (Most Cunning Manipulator). I thought you were talking about "insulting" logic in the sense of incoherent rambling, laughable strategies/ploys, etc...
Guardian: I could see someone who replaces in repeatedly (and well) being nominated for either Best Replacement or Behind the Scenes. BTS has a fairly small pool of candidates, as things stand right now (mostly List Mods, mith, JEEP, and maybe some wikifanatics). I look forward to mith's finalized list of awards, though...