Mini 889 - Shopping Frenzy (Over)

[muh316]

First post baby!

[muh316]

vote :eleven knives in a throat

seems like a scum and probably IS a scum.

[muh316]

vote: Torqez

You know why.

the rest of us dont know why scum

vote julienvonwolfe

[/b]

[muh316]

Vote muh

Only scum would dare think that a superior anime is equatable to an awful one.

I understand that naruto is not as good as DBZ. but this pic looks cool so I dont care

[muh316]

so i wonder how the discussion will start. How about i do something like

unvote

V0te torqez

lets get someone at l-4
lol

[muh316]

SO i have a question for all of you. What are your experiences with mafiascum. Have you played in other sites? or are you still a newbie.

[muh316]

vote: Torqez

Bandwagon!

GASP at L-3 already. All aboard the lynch train. CHOO CHOO!

[muh316]

@Debonair Danny DiPietro: I shouldn't read your posts in the library. They don't appreciate loud noises such as laughter.

@muh316: I've only finished one game on the site, so I'm relatively new. I'm in 3 others currently.
Weirdly enough, when you put Torqez on L-4 because you wanted a bandwagon, you left the bandwagon on JVW that was at L-4.

I didnt notice that, But people seem to have a hate toward torqez.
I smell something. I smell that smelly smell that smells........ smelly....

anchovies

[muh316]

and DDD that wasnt neccessary

[muh316]

I didnt notice that, But people seem to have a hate toward torqez.

Meaning?

To ride the wagon. Thats the meaning of it.

Currently Im having town reads on all of you. not one scum tell. Seems a bit too suspicious. Maybe we have only 2 town and 10 scum. Thats why I smell that smelly smell that smells smelly.

[muh316]

So how is this discussion going to possibly start.

[muh316]

how about we try a no lynch. It might be beneficial and It will give the cop some time to investigate. The doc/Jk will try his best to keep everyone safe and we could possibly get some information by Day 3.

[muh316]

BUt imagine this.
We get two people out of the story. Ten people remaining.
Then we get info from the cop.
8 people we know of. If cop is lucky then only one scum remanining and it will be easy enough to find the remaining one.

Or we can just play cop. everyone states that they are cop and says who they have investigates last night. There will be only one right answer and it will be beneficial to us.

[muh316]

SO

vote no lynch[/b[

[muh316]

im bad at this bolding thing.

vote no lynch

[muh316]

Or we could talk things out a bit, make an educated decision, perhaps still be wrong, and then get information from the cop...because according to the rules, there may be sanity issues. So we could get inaccurate information from the cop.

Man why do i always forget that. Guess Im used to newbie games

[muh316]

here you go

New postPosted: Tue Dec 01, 2009 9:09 pm Post subject: 58 Reply with quote
Torqez wrote:
Chinaman wrote:

As far as getting this game going, I could go for a no lynch or a lynching of Torqez. Doesn't matter to me much either way. If Torqez is town, chances are that we would lynch a townie D1 anyway, if he's scum, then all the better. If we no-lynch and scum don't get lucky and kill the Cop if there is one, then we have more info for D2.


Very nice. On the one hand you say you could go for a no lynch. Yet on the other hand, you agree with DDD that I should be lynched for agreeing to the same thing you said you'd agree to inherently, since a townie could be lynched anyway. I like the logic.

Chinaman wrote:

On the other hand, I will say this reasoning given by Josh for lynching Torqez sucks ballsack. "Three posts, no content." It's page 2 man, your posts aren't exactly the epitome of quality and content. I'm not blaming you for that as it's page 2, but to call someone else out on it is pretty contradictory. What say you sir?!

But wait, there's more! You say Josh is being contradictory, but yet again, you say you don't like his reasoning and then don't say anything about DDDs lame reason either? How's that for contradictory?

Unvote. Vote: Chinaman


Well, first off, let me go on the record for saying I hate D1 as it's usually a cluster-f***. That being said, I don't agree with or disagree with Triple-D. You said you were bored with the game, so either you come back and explain, like you did, or you really didn't care I and wouldn't care about losing you. Notice though, I did not vote you as I wanted to see your response.

I explained why I didn't mention Triple-D's reasoning. When I read his statement, it struck more as "if you don't care, then goodbye" rather than actually trying to come up with something that could be construed as scummy. JL's post on the other hand, did strike me that way. It wasn't that he didn't care one way or the other, but more so that he was trying to justify his vote on you which is why I called it out. Speaking of which, I would like you to respond when you return JL.

JVW wrote:
1. Has there been discussion of a no-lynch in any other games you've played on this site?

2. What benefit to the town is there of lynching a hypothetically-townie Torqez if we just blindly lynch him? Or of lynching a hypothetically-scum Torqez, for that matter?


1. No, not really.

2. None really, unless he was going to be a burden to town because he is "bored with MS" right now. He came back and was actively participatory, so I don't believe that is anymore the case right now. I don't mind getting rid of dead weight. If dead weight continues to be dead weight, it gives scum a nice chance to mislynch them later when they are closer to winning. Same reason I don't mind policy lynches on active or non-active lurkers early on. They don't contribute so they don't help town. They are an easy target for scum to go after as they hardly defend themselves. Plus, sometimes you get lucky as they are trying to hide in the shadows and we lynch scum by lynching lurkers. Anyway, hope that answered your questions.

[muh316]

DDD i think your just pushing torqez for no reason.
unvote

vote DDD

[muh316]

There is a ton of lurking in this game. I don't 100% agree with the LAL philosophy, but in my experience especially lately, I have been finding that a lot of lurkers are scum. I don't like a lurker lynch D1 as there are not enough interactions to go on and there is less information if the lurker flips town.

Theres not much to discuss about in a slow game like this, thats why everybody is lurking. And DDD you have no reasons for torqez then why would you bother to bring the discussion forward

[muh316]

What do you mean there is not much to discuss? How is this different from other games?

In my other games, a strong discussion usually began with one person talking about no lynch(which i did) after in one human day we would put in about 4 pages a day.

[muh316]

Oh sorry I didnt notice this game *starts watching this topic* there. now im going to read.

[muh316]

I had problems with my firefox and had to download it over again. So then I lost this out of my bookmarks. Now that its on my watched list along with my other games ill be more active.

[muh316]

Josh, doent your case on me seem a bit...... desperate. It seems like your looking for small reasons to get a lynch started.

[muh316]

Im just going to join the wagon because of the deadline. it seemed to pass by so fast. So we should probably just get on a good wagon for now.

Vote Josh Lyman

[muh316]

Wow great lynch guys. One scum down. And welcome Albert and i really liked that old avatar DDD this one makes me want to punch it in the face. And I guess were back at RVS.

[muh316]

Hmm, waiting on a reaction from muh to my vote.

What do you want me to say.

[muh316]

Why didnt you like this post I made

Wow great lynch guys. One scum down. And welcome Albert and i really liked that old avatar DDD this one makes me want to punch it in the face. And I guess were back at RVS.

and what over deliberate explanation did i ever make

[muh316]

Why didnt you like this post I made

Wow great lynch guys. One scum down. And welcome Albert and i really liked that old avatar DDD this one makes me want to punch it in the face. And I guess were back at RVS.

and what over deliberate explanation did i ever make

"Wow great lynch guys?" - Why did you need to post that? Was it to show the town that we'd lynched scum and that you approved? Is that not taken for granted already?


"Welcome Albert, etc..." - Why do you need to post this? It's spam - or worse, buddying.


"were back at RVS" - that would be great for scum, wouldn't it?

Im just going to join the wagon because of the deadline. it seemed to pass by so fast. So we should probably just get on a good wagon for now.

Vote Josh Lyman

This is an over deliberate deadline wagoning if I ever saw one. You explain your vote three different ways in three sentences despite having the same basic reasoning in each.

Great lynch was just a mere statement and so is the second one.
And were back at RVS was just for because we were back at RVS atleast I thought.
Yeah I have the same reasoning on all three of them. I just said that I was getting on a good wagon.

[muh316]

if you think my defense was poor what would you have done in my place. What would you have said that would have made your defense a sack of gold.

[muh316]

if you think my defense was poor what would you have done in my place. What would you have said that would have made your defense a sack of gold.

And did you read my post or not?

To answer your question, I wouldn't have said those things in the first place, hence no need to defend.

Then why did you ask for a defense in the first place

[muh316]

Muh, at this point, opinions on others would be good.

Im not really having any town or scum reads on anybody at this point right on. I agree with the Chinaman case was made. Thats pretty much all I have to say

[muh316]

Prodding Scott Brosius, Torqez, Chinaman

Maybe it's time for a replacement for Scott then, ja?

Also Mod, Prod: ABR

Muh, try to stop being so pathetic and do something.

The same should go for more than half of the people here. And what should I do anyways. The same everybody else is doing

[muh316]

Prodding Scott Brosius, Torqez, Chinaman

Maybe it's time for a replacement for Scott then, ja?

Also Mod, Prod: ABR

Muh, try to stop being so pathetic and do something.

The same should go for more than half of the people here. And what should I do anyways. The same everybody else is doing

So you have no interest in finding scum, your sole concern is doing what everyone else is doing? Is that what you're saying?

I already read and the only good case thats going on right now is Chinamans. What else do you expect. I cant hunt for scum theres nothing to hunt on.

[muh316]

I also think a scott lynch would be better because he almost cost us a no lynch. And I think he might be activley lurking to find a way out of this slip. So that people forget about him.

[muh316]

I also think a scott lynch would be better because he almost cost us a no lynch. And I think he might be activley lurking to find a way out of this slip. So that people forget about him.

Scott hasn't posted on this site in nine days and it appears he's flaked from two or three other games as well that he was in, that's some real hardcore "active lurking".

Unvote; Vote: muh316

Sorry i didnt do my research on him before saying that. I should be more careful.

[muh316]

And what makes that a good reason for voting me

[muh316]

And what makes that a good reason for voting me

You're not paying attention and you have no interest in actually scumhunting. Town would be paying attention and has a huge interest in scumhunting.

I also believe your not of any use to us either so is ABR and so is Chinaman. Why not vote all of them. Why not lynch them? If it was that simple nobody would ever sign up. There is no slips I've yet seen except for chinamans

[muh316]

So are you sure you want a claim from me?

[muh316]

So my role is a Macho Doctor. I know its the same as wulfys but i am

[muh316]

^^ most poorly timed claim ever. lol!

What?

[muh316]

ok i will
unvote

vote chinaman

[muh316]

So, things are shifting from a muh wagon to a chinaman wagon, which is fair enough.

Then Muh claims Macho Doc, which sounds pretty stupid to me since having two docs in the same game is pretty unusual. Is this just a play on the 'too scummy to be scummy' fallacy, or is it us trying to out-guess the mod? Bah.

I can go with a Chinaman lynch for today. I'll wait for a votecount. By my own count, it would put Chinaman at L-1, but I would like to be sure.

he made some of us macho so we cant be protected. Even though Why would you think im scum even after my power claim.

[muh316]

EBWOP: Replace power with role not power claim role claim

[muh316]

And I was forced to claim because I was on L-1 and if I didnt claim I would then be asked why I didnt claim earlier.

[muh316]

So why do u want me dead so badly

[muh316]

I protected adel this night

[muh316]

care to explain adel

[muh316]

vote ABR

I think that his claiming yesterday was scummy in my opinion

[muh316]

I didnt like it because he was never asked to claim but he claimed anyway as town. And then about him abandoning this game. I have two theories.

1: He's scum and wants everyone to think hes town
2: He desperately wants out of the game.

Hes mentioned about him getting NK. And hes also voted to abandon during twilight. So he might want out of this game. But I think the its #1 because he could have easily replaced out.

[muh316]

he claimed a power role???which one

[muh316]

So ABR if your a Macho Cop tell us who you investigated

[muh316]

but you said you were cop.

[muh316]

so why did you claim cop in the first place

[muh316]

but what happened. Who killed him. And Liam probably blocked me because I protected him. That fool.

[muh316]

And im talking about Liam

[muh316]

hey muh, who did you protect n1?

I protected DJ
Night 2 Was Adel
Night 3 was Liam(who roleblocked me, no wonder I was NK'ed)

[muh316]

He seemed the least scummiest at that time during day 1 to me.

[muh316]

Wait you claimed bulletproof.
doh!
aww man the stupidity
but wulfy was macho so i wasnt able to do anything

[muh316]

I support it to
So
and ive already claimed so adel u should go

[muh316]

Im sorry guys i wont be posting much because i broke my right arm and i have cast and a sling on so i cant type allot. if u want me replaced u could but if u dont mimd ill be a little less active.

i protected liam because i didnt have any case on him nor did i find him suspicious.. Adel because i didnt find him as suspicious as others. thats all ii can wrie ask me any questions and ill try to answer

[muh316]

Im sorry guys i wont be posting much because i broke my right arm and i have cast and a sling on so i cant type allot. if u want me replaced u could but if u dont mimd ill be a little less active.

I don't have a problem with you being inactive so long as you do one thing for us. Please have someone write "muh316" on your cast, take a picture of it, and post that picture in this thread. That way we will know that you aren't lying.

Thanks!

here u can see the sling but not my cast
http://i45.tinypic.com/2vcf3o4.jpg

[muh316]

ok DDD why would u vote for an obvious town person anyways. DJ seems to not be mafia and thats what we are all looking for. Now DDD is voting for DJ even though most of us think DJ is town. I guess the best thing for me to do now is vote

vote DDD

[muh316]

im not taking my vote off you

[muh316]

I assumed he roleblocked me because i wasnt NK'd. Scum team probably though that Liam should RB and kill more of the people we wonnt suspect. Im probably ddying tonight if we mislynch

[muh316]

Adel if DJ didnt kill liam then who did. Try thinkin logically

[muh316]

Sorry guys about my suckish play. I guess this will be my last game at Mafiascum for about 2 months.

[muh316]

Who asked u to quit