Mini 889 - Shopping Frenzy (Over)

[muh316]

I didnt like it because he was never asked to claim but he claimed anyway as town. And then about him abandoning this game. I have two theories.

1: He's scum and wants everyone to think hes town
2: He desperately wants out of the game.

Hes mentioned about him getting NK. And hes also voted to abandon during twilight. So he might want out of this game. But I think the its #1 because he could have easily replaced out.

[don_johnson]

^^ not only is he using logic, but he's a claimed power role. i have no issue with an ABR lynch. as far as i'm concerned, both he and Adel are prime candidates and neither is helping change my view of them.

[muh316]

he claimed a power role???which one

[Adel]

But I think the its #1 because he could have easily replaced out.

this.

I won't be shocked if he replaces out now though.

[muh316]

So ABR if your a Macho Cop tell us who you investigated

[Albert B. Rampage]

VT here.

[muh316]

but you said you were cop.

[Albert B. Rampage]

2 posts later I said I was VT.

[muh316]

so why did you claim cop in the first place

[Albert B. Rampage]

Because I wanted to get NK'd

[Adel]

vote:ABR

[julienvonwolfe]

Sorry I haven't been around. Busy times in RL with family visiting. I'll make a more substantial post tomorrow.

ABR, for somebody who doesn't want to play, why are you playing?

[CallMeLiam]

ABR: either you're being a dick by not replacing out and desperately trying to hurt the town or you're running an awful gambit or you're scum.
All I can do is echo everyone else in asking why not get yourself replaced out?

[Albert B. Rampage]

uh ok. I thought you wanted to lynch me without asking any questions. So I rather get lynched then ask a replacement in that situation. Anyway, I'm town. I think the scum is DDD. Good luck guyz.

mod: I need replacement

[Albert B. Rampage]

Also - it made sense for me to try to draw the NK, but Adel f'd that up probably because she's scum too.

[Adel]

come on ABR, why don't you want to play with me? You used to be so eager to replace into games I was in, and were always so quick to conclude that I was scum in those games, and in those games you worked so hard to get me lynched.

In this game you apparently just want to get out.

Have we ever played together when you were scum?

[nhammen]

Vote Count

Albert B. Rampage (3): Debonair Danny DiPietro, don_johnson, muh316

Debonair Danny DiPietro (1): Albert B. Rampage
don_johnson (1): Adel

Not voting (3): CallMeLiam, julienvonwolfe, semioldguy

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch

And I guess I'll be searching for a replacement for Albert B. Rampage

[julienvonwolfe]

So, some thoughts and ramblings on the Josh lynch and ramifications, considering that it's probable that scum were on the wagon. I should've done this yesterday, I guess. Here's the final list of people on the wagon, with dead folks removed:

julienvonwolfe, don_johnson, Debonair Danny DiPietro, muh316, CallMeLiam

- Liam's posts are notable for how he seemed to prefer lynching me over Josh, despite his case on me being pretty sloppy really. This is probably notable only because he switched quite late in the Josh wagon, which makes it look like a late bus.

I might be trying to read too much into this, but you could take this post as an attempt to cause a no-lynch by trying to coerce a scumbuddy into claiming a power role. There's nothing in particular about his post that makes me think this, other than the fact that it is in a prime position for bussing, and that it's what I would want were I Josh's scumbuddy in that position:

I'll catch up with the game on Day 2, for now we need to lynch

unvote, vote: josh lyman

Josh, if you're a power role claim now, it might not be too late.

- I'm okay with muh's and DJ's positions on the wagon, given Josh's interactions with the pair. I have no problems with either of their claims at this point, so...

- PE's dead and was town. 3D was fourth on the wagon. His iso 10 is a defense of Josh. His iso 19 is kind of a defense combined with a distancing post. Perhaps it's confirmation bias, but I can easily read his iso 21 as coming from a frustrated scumbuddy.


I am incredibly unconvinced by the ABR wagon, especially as he is replacing out. Therefore,

vote: Debonair Danny DiPietro

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Vote: ABR

I didn't like el simo, ABR replaced el simo. el simo wasn't on the day one correct wagon, that's not good. ABR was on the day two mislynch, that wasn't good either. ABR's other target is/was a VI with a claim that no VI would make. ABR has also categorically refused to help the town with actual content. Conclusion, the player slot is scummy as all get out, lynch 'em.

uh ok. I thought you wanted to lynch me without asking any questions.

So I rather get lynched then ask a replacement in that situation.

Really, there's a reason why we're not lynching this player slot?

[Adel]

this is interesting

And I guess I'll be searching for a replacement for Albert B. Rampage

vote:ABR

lynch-1

[don_johnson]

^^ this is terrible. Adel's next.

someone hammer this home.

[CallMeLiam]

^^ this is terrible. Adel's next.

someone hammer this home.

What do you mean by these two things? You seem to think Adel's vote is scummy, but you also want someone to hammer?

[don_johnson]

^^ this is terrible. Adel's next.

someone hammer this home.

What do you mean by these two things? You seem to think Adel's vote is scummy, but you also want someone to hammer?

the logic is terrible. using a mod post to determine your vote is heinous.

also: Adel is scummy regardless of the flip. ABR wants out, a replacement is more work for the mod regardless of alignment. grant the wish. if he's scum, great, if he's not then Adel is 100%.

[Adel]

the logic is terrible. using a mod post to determine your vote is heinous.

Play To Win.

I'm confident that ABR was being a PITA and the mod disapproves, and ABR is being tactical about his use of a threat of replacement as well as his decision to replace out.
I play "out guess the mod" to get insight into setups, and win games. My best guess on the setup is two similar theories:
1- ABR is scum on a team with an investigative ability (role cop or gunsmith) but no ability to kill. ABR hates duel-scum games, and he is convinced that the nk proves that there is a second scum team in the game.
2- ABR is on a scum team that is not {Mafia} like Josh was revealed to be. He hates duel scum games, and is replacing out.

Anyhow, ABR is scum. Hammer please.

[CallMeLiam]

I think we're massclaiming tomorrow

vote: ABR