I'll go and
Voting for someone that seems to have an investigative role is not in the town's interest.
Wow, just let me get this straight. First Fishbulb says that PopsicleStix votes me because I voted for PopsicleStix. Now you explain this as 'Ah, pops is dropping hints that his vote is not random, maybe he's a cop'.JereIC wrote:Fish, if PopsicleStix is dropping hints that his post isn't random, maybe it's becuase he's a cop?
FOS: Thothunless I'm misreading Stix.
<---- was fooledMeMe wrote:Why's he trying to unvote in his very first entry? Did he think we'd be fooled if he pretended he'd posted already?
So you did not see the posts of the frequent posters up till now.IS wrote: Im happy to start seeing posts from the less infrequent posters.
Then please tell me why I'm suspicious? Because I have no night action? Yoko clearly took most if not all of his roles from the role section on this site. And because I'm the unlucky one with not night action I should be lynched? That's just complete bullshit.I think both viking and Thoth are rather suspicious atm.
Not really, just another townie and another day in which we don't lynch scum, plus another night in which we lose another townie.SO wrote: We don't really lose anything beyond a person if he's telling the truth
I think the main problem with a no lynch to get more info is that if we have a GF there is a good chance that we won't be able to get more info (unless we have a GF plus a regular Mafia left). Also in that case we don't want to miss a lynch as there are still a lot of players that could be a GF.BananaBob wrote: Hmmm, thinking about it now, maybe a no lynch for today would prove to be a good option. At least that way we'll have more time to compile information.
We can easily test for sure when we decide upon a lynch. Just let me cast the 6th vote again. I would expect Yoko to count self votes though as he made no mention of not doing it and the standard option is to count them.SO wrote: I think it's between vikingfan and Thoth still, for me at least... True, Thoth did vote himself. But. Is Yoko counting self-votes? I recall reading a game where the mod didn't like people voting for themself. Also, who's to say the vote was counted, considering he unvoted in the same post? I'd feel more comfortable if the vote and the unvote were in two seperate posts, and a lot more comfortable still if Yoko posted in between them.
Why was SO confirmed Peacebringer? It's probably somewhere, but I'm a bit too lazy now to look for it. Just from the claims it looks to me that PeaceBringer, Nanook and myself are innocent.List of Claims:
Otaku376 (replacing Dourgrim) - Ghost (universal back up) taking over for Otaku376 the first
Thoth - Priest (unable to cast the lynching vote)
PeaceBringer (replacing Morpheus) - Searching Townie
NanooktheWolf - Gunsmith
SinisterOverlord - Burglar
Fuldu - Doctor
Massive - Forensic Scientist
Did you not read my posts or are you intentionally trying to mislead? I cannot cast the lynching vote. I can cast any other vote and have it count. so as long as I vote first we can still lynch.massive wrote: SO, the problem here is this: If Thoth can't lynch either of us, exactly how are either of us supposed to win if the other is scum?
That's not that strange. It's quite common for a GF to be told in his role how he will appear in investigations. Last DP game I played I (as a SK, not a GF) was even given the choice by DP as which historical figure I would appear to an investigator. Of course I build my whole game around behaving like that character and even tried to look suspicious enough that cops would investigate me so they could later clear me. This is just an example of which there are many more to be found around the site. What I try to say is that it is not so strange for an investigation to match an earlier roleclaim.massive wrote: That's certainly possible. Were I the godfather, in fact, I'd expect to have any investigation against me fail. What I would not expect is that I would be given the ability to match the erratic results some investigator would get (chemicals and a crime-processing lab) with the proper role claim. Which I did, in thread, before SO's results were revealed.