Mini 425 Generic Western Mafia- Game over!

[John]

/confirm

how yall doin?

[John]

How many Mafia/Outlaws are in this game?

[John]

Where does it say? I don't see. Are we not allowed to know?
Stop picking on me.

*hides in corner*

[John]

Did I really get FoS for having a short name? I can understand a random vote, but an FoS? lol.

I don't think anything on the last 2 pages have any relevance in my opinion. Page one is all confirmations, page 2 is random votes.

Vote: Guardian

just cause it may quiet him down a bit.

How many to lynch day 1?

[John]

Ehh, a third vote isn't anything to get into a fuss over, especially for the first bandwagon. besides, it's 7 to lynch I think. I think it's kinda routine in mafia games. Thats just my opinion.

[John]

You don't need to unFoS.

I think guardian is town. He gives off that vibe to me. Just new and exited townie trying to win the game in less than 5 pages.

[John]

Guardian, you are so night1 killed. lol. You are the most pro town player I've seen.

[John]

Bah humbug.
I am analyze what is being said, but not much has been said. when something concrete comes up I'll become useful.

And WTF IS THIS TIGER SHIT?

[John]

its pissing me off now.

[John]

I ment the night kill post as more of a joke, not serious. Honestly, I only said that cause his posts seem so pro town, but with other posts saying too town is scum, it makes me look dumb.

And regarding the post about me sitting back, it's only been about 24 hours, calm down, i have shit to do in RL.

[John]

Huh. The recent posts confuse me, I have no idea who is acusing who and why.

We should call out some lurkers like DLMF, Ichigo, Vel-rahn koon

[John]

Sorry, Vel-Rhan Koon, my bad.

DLMF, the gut vote thing doesn't cut it in my opinion. Not Page 5.

Vote: DLMF

This vote will probly cahnge fast, this vote was mostly to get your attention.

[John]

How do you veiw posts like that?

[John]

COOL!!! Thanx much!

[John]

I'm not seeing a good reason for Vryklan's 4 votes, would someone elaborate?

[John]

VaL, I got your shotgun post. I dont get why it's relevent to be honest.

[John]

Unvote, Vote: Avinyl

A total of 4 post. 7 pages. Lurker.

One post was a random vote, the second explained the random vote. So 2 posts that count.

[John]

My vote will remain on Avinyl untill he provides some good info to make up for his long absence.

[John]

I play with short posts, please don't read it as a scumtell, it's the way I am.

I'm not giving posts with substance because I'm finding very little to go off of.

I'm keeping my vote on Avinyl, because of guardians comment on how he is distancing himself from Ichigo and Vrkylan. I agree, it seems suspicous.

[John]

Okay, here are some solid reason why I voted for Avinyl

1. Voting for a guy, puting 3rd vote on him. Not too scummy, considering it takes 7 to lynch, but it's ever so slightly suspicous to me.

2. He voted for me. Wait thats a bad reason.

3. In his 3rd post, he dismissed an accusation by saying he was tired, and didn't read (THEN WHY POST).

4. He also said it's better to vote than not to vote at all, which I don't agree with, not without proper information.

5. He THEN FoSed Guardian, which looked like a tatic to get the attention off him.

6. I belive the fact that he had log on problems, but still only 8 posts. He could post a little more.

7. You Vote for me, even though you stated that you didn't know what to think of me. So why me and not someone else?

8. You Unvote Ichigo then vote me after he posts and votes me. Seems kinda scum buddyish to me.

[John]

EBWOP

If not scumbuddyish, its definately the start to a bandwagon with no reasoning behind it besides my short posts, and considering my lat post, the band wagon should get off at the next stop.

[John]

I'm posting to show im not lurking, but have no information at this time to contribute. Everyone is bringing up logical points, and I am unable to tell who I should trust. I'll try to come up with something by tonite.

[John]

Its been a while since I posted. i swear i've posted earlyer, but apparently not. anywho,

I still want to know why AVI voted for me.

Guradian seems very town.

Peter seems like very good scum to me, he is appearing very pro town and asking just the right questions. he's almost being too perfect of a townie, and it rasies my suspicions, but its mostly a gut feeling.

Raffels, i know it seems im lurking. but there are so little scumtells to me, i can't comment with any kind of content. the downtime kicked the shit outta my attention span as well, if it wasn't bad enough.

gorkrat, thanks for defending me indirectly, i dont know what to make of it. you could have ment nothing by it, or you may be trying to gain me as an allie very subtly (<is that a word?). maybe im reading too much into it.

Thats all for now, i just got off work, and wrestling practice kicked my ass.

[John]

It was nothing more than a gut feeling. I said you sholdnt VOTE on a gut feeling. i didn't even FoS. i just simply interjected my opinon. I have no proof. my only proof is that he is playing the game too well, and thats basicly anti-proof. hence no vote, no fos.

Gut feelings are fine. voting on them are not.

As far as me posting in conjuction with peter, i don't think anythng of it. its been by chance. ill be posting i this thread alot more because we now have a livly disscusion on which can comment now, unlike before.

[John]

@ Peter> The way you have been playing is what my concern is. To me, you have been on the outside, interjecting your opinion, not lurking, but in my opinion, not saying anything that may shed light on you. There is no specific post i can relate this to, hence you are not scum to me at this moment, i think we should just keep you in our periferals.
I've seen clever scum post in the same style you have, that's all.

Also, i get what yoour saying about how a townie lynch is okay, but it should always be a priority to stay alive, because you being alive ALWAYS helps your side, town or mafia. Death information isn't always reliable, mostly because good scum can twist the info into the way they like.

My feelings to guardian are the same. I don't think he is scum. He is being very careful, asking hard, dirct questions, and trusting nobody. That is very town behavior to me. To be honest, he is new, so the possiblity of him being extremly clever scum are slim to none in my opinion.

[John]

@ peter> I agree that if all people tried to survive just for themselfs, it would not be good for town. all im saying is that if you just give up and die, the town loses a vote, which is the towns greatest, and basicly only, power. I'm not saying vanilla townies have equal power, but they still have power, and are the backbone to any(well, most any) mafia game.

An no, im not fishing, and you can't do anything for me. i simply stated an observation, one that far from merits a vote or FoS in my opinion, which is why i placed neither on you.

[John]

EBWOP: My reasons for voting Guardian are

no

different from any of yours'.

well, could you please name them? i personaly dont have a suspicion of guardian, so the statement confuses me.

[John]

I think lynching scum helps town a heck of a lot more than lynching town.

I'll keep that in mind.

Haha. funny.

anyway.

@peter> Im not defending guardian. i just wanted to know why other were voting for him, is that too much to ask for? Am I wrong for wanting an explination? Maybe you could convince me that he is scum, but you choose to attack me instead of explaining anything which calls for a

FoS: Peter

. Unlike you, i think we should try much harder to lynch a mafia member at this point than just to give up now and say "fuck it, lets see what happens when we kill the most frequent poster", which looks like to me what you want at this point. we need to try harder than we are. If you give me a list of scummy things Guardian has done, he can rebuttle and if he gives unsatifactory answers, we will lynch him. But the way you have been posting about me and guardian, it seems you woud rather skip the rebuttle and go right for the kill.

I also acknolage the fact that if Guardian lynched and he turns up mafia, im public enemy #1 on d2.

[John]

Avi is either really bad town or really bad mafia, but his content sucks so bad that he blurs the line between the two.

[John]

To me, the most likely scumpair to me are Peter/Avi.

[John]

John can you eleborate on the connection between the two?
Because I really don't see it.

they are my top 2 suspects, thats all. I have given my reasons for there suspicions already.

[John]

BTW, peter never /confirmed, he /conformed.

[John]

and the significance of that is...?

It was funny to me.

Raffles, concering your last post, this is why lurkers are so dangerous.

My vote is on avi, as it has been, and i have stated my reasons many times.

[John]

I think There should be a mod kill of all who dont post in this thread by a certain date.

[John]

What can i say to thesp?
well, here, i'll try.
Im not the SK, if one even exits in a game this small.

I also hate Thesp's playstyle of pointing fingers, with no proof of anthing.
since avi will almost undoubtably replaced in my opinion, ill

Unvote, Vote: Thesp

untill he tells us why im an SK, and not just cause a 5 year old said so.

[John]

Thesp, Yes i voted for you on playstyle, but you now have explaned yourself much more since. i will, however, not remove my vpte from you, due to the fact that you wrongly said a quote was by me, which seems to me, your trying to dicredit me, feuadian slip or not. and i wont pretend that your instant and quite radical assumtion that i am a SK does not bother me. the 2 put together, plus the fact its all at me, add up in my head.

[John]

Here goes another playstyle post against thesp. sorry.

your aware that you are trying to conrtol the game and you admit it as well. unforutuantly, i wont allow someone to control a game. that is about the most dangerous thing you can do in a mafia game in my opinion.

[John]

No, imnot onna take it. ill post within 24 hours. RL is killing me.