Mini 326- Buffy Mafia-Game Over

[TBuG]

Vote: Lostprophet[/] I don't

[TBuG]

Vote: lostprophet

DAMN CODING. I'M NOT YOUR BITCH, BITCH. (I've always wanted to say that...)

[TBuG]

Bump over locked stuff.

[TBuG]

Unvote, vote Stevie

[TBuG]

Ooh, vote stays on Stevie...

[TBuG]

Unvote

[TBuG]

Erm, Faith still had powers.

[TBuG]

We could be in a Lynch or Lose situation, people. We need to do something. I hate to say it, but we may need to *cowers* mass claim.

[TBuG]

Besides, shouldn't a Day 2 LyLo be impossible in a well-constructed mini?

Not if we got unlucky with our scum. Although, now that I think about it, we probably have a 2-person mafia and an SK.

[TBuG]

I'm considering a vote for Spamwise. He voted Pug, who is away at the moment, and post 116 really confuses me.

[TBuG]

Vote: Spamwise

We have four "active" players atm, and of those four, he sticks out as scum.

[TBuG]

Mod, mass proddage please?

We only have the conversation of four people to go off of. That's not enough to make a lynch, let alone get a read on everyone.

[TBuG]

I think I'll keep my vote for now.

[TBuG]

I don't see anyone else as being scummy right now, so I'm keeping my vote. I'll reread the thread to see if anyone else triggers my scumdar.

[TBuG]

So, my analysis, person by person:

Adele: Seems pretty much protown, but was slightly convinced that Stevie and Twito were mafia together.

Aelyn: Hasn't posted for two weeks. His posts so far seem to agree with Adele.

Lostprophet: Isn't coming off as town, in my opinion.

Unvote, Vote: lostprophet

notguilty: His last post was the day after Aelyn's. Eight posts, tsk tsk. Not satisfied. If lostprophet can convince me he's town, I'm going to vote notguilty.

Pug:

Six

posts. Lurk much? Not very much content.

Spamwise: Meh, I'll trust you for now.

[TBuG]

If lostprophet can convince me that he himself is town, I'll change my vote.

[TBuG]

I think he means this, not his.

[TBuG]

People always analyze better than me That's a very thorough analysis, and I think I'll trust it. You brought up some very interesting points (especially Adele saying he's likely to be protown and then voting him). I'll agree with it for now.

Unvote, Vote: Adele

[TBuG]

Well, I hope your full defense addresses everything, because most of that stuff makes you very scummy.

[TBuG]

I'm satisfied.

Unvote; Vote: lostprophet

[TBuG]

I still think lp is the scummiest for the reasons I've stated.

[TBuG]

2nd one of those is my reasoning, that's after I read over the entire thread. I don't remember when the first one was, but the fourth one was a re-vote after I switched to Adele.

[TBuG]

OK - Why isn't he coming off as town in your opinion?

I reread the entire thread and I thought the scummiest person was lostprophet because of certain things he did and said.

My vote on Stevie was justified by how scummy he was acting throughout the first day. I honestly did not believe that Faith could be a vanilla townie. I honestly can't remember how I acted towards Twito, but that's what I get for playing about 10 games at once.

My extended absence isn't as bad as others. At least I've been posting. I honestly don't see what makes me so scummy, but then, I never do. Maybe I'm just acting my age.

[TBuG]

I analyzed, and I decided not to quote posts. I'll try and find them.

[TBuG]

I honestly haven't had the chance to find the posts. I'm a busy high school with some summer homework and on top of that I have Burning Man to prepare for. I will Friday. I can't tomorrow because it's my birthday.

[TBuG]

Overly aggressive? Honestly, that's bullshit. I've done some lurking (my bad) and some bandwagoning (again, my bad) but I have not been aggressive. I can't find the posts because I don't have the time. My grandmother is in the hospital having a pancreas surgery and I'm going to visit her today. I can post an adequate reply tomorrow. And, Adele, the second two times I voted LP were revoting for the same reasons as the first vote.

[TBuG]

Hmm, I must have gotten the order of my votes wrong.

PS: Raise your hand if you don't like Pug89's Post 25.

Whoa, passive-aggressive much? If you suspect someone, suspect them. If not, then don't try this tactic, which literally reeks of scum. You're trying to garner support for a cause without supporting it, which makes you both A). Wishy-washy, and B). Willing to go with more popular opinion. Both ring heavily of bad things.

Unvote, Vote: SpamWise

.

I thought Lostprophet overreacted to this. Spamwise was just trying to say that he didn't like that post.

unvote

Vote:Pug89

Oooh, oooh, me too me too.

Vote: SpamWise

.

This is a fun game!

Reasoning much?

Those are the two scummiest posts. He also doesn't post very often, only now and then to stir the pot. And he even forgot who he was voting at one point.

Adele, that first vote was on the first page. That was random. It was my second Lp vote that was the serious vote, and from then on it was revoting. My prolonged vote on Spamwise was because at the moment I saw him as scummy, and even though he claimed mason, there were many other possibilities that, although unlikely, tend to be thought about by a paranoid player like me.

[TBuG]

I'll claim if you need me too, but I doubt you'll believe it because of my action on the first night, unless there's a roleblocker who targetted me.

[TBuG]

...Why would you claim with one vote on you?

I said if wanted to, I don't feel like I need to.

FoS: Pug

You haven't been posting, but you feel the need to tell us you can't post for the next few days?

[TBuG]

Chainclaim? Please explain.

[TBuG]

I'll just go ahead and claim first.

I'm Season 5 Spike. I'm a bodyguard role, so I protect someone, but if that person is targetted to be killed I die instead. However, I protected someone who died Night 1, so I believe I was roleblocked. I am also not allowed to cast the lynching vote because of the chip in my head.

[TBuG]

I decided to since I was two from lynch.

And note that, as a bodyguard, I did not protect someone, I died in their stead.

[TBuG]

I watch Buffy, and although I'm not sure why Spike is of all things a bodyguard, I understand the not being able to vote the lynching vote.

[TBuG]

Okay. But for your second point, after the chip was put in Spike's head, he was prevented from doing evil. So, no, I don't follow.

[TBuG]

Cogito Ergo Sum. The next night I protected pug because I was thinking of the possibility that maybe I wasn't really a bodyguard, but in hindsight that was a silly idea XD

[TBuG]

Ah. (I didn't watch Buffy religiously.)

[TBuG]

but can not understand why Pbug dodges questions.

Where do you get that from? I haven't dodged any questions.

[TBuG]

I'm okay with my vote.

[TBuG]

Lostprophet's actions made me think he was scum, and das's actions have re-affirmed that. I think das is the play.

[TBuG]

After reading why Pbug voted for my predecessor and looking at my role I have no real choice but to

VOTE PBUG

I would have been FAR more aggressive I assure you.

Pbug you picked a player who turns up dead?
How did this person Die?

PBuG - Who did you protect on night one?

I have a very good reason for thinking Spike is good but can not understand why Pbug dodges questions.

I got thrown when sotty asked who you protected on sat...
I am a bit lost what to do now. I thought I would be well in my element ..

Those posts all trigger my scumdar. Granted, I have a low-quality scumdar and the pointer tends to get stuck on "Scum", but they still trigger it. Also, granted, three of them are anti-PBuG, but two of those seem like posts meant to indirectly convince people I'm scum.

[TBuG]

Person 2 would be notguilty from lack of posting.

[TBuG]

Person 2 would be notguilty from lack of posting.

Well, BrizzyBoi now. But third is probably Pug for lurking.

[TBuG]

Besides, shouldn't a Day 2 LyLo be impossible in a well-constructed mini?

Not if we got unlucky with our scum. Although, now that I think about it, we probably have a 2-person mafia and an SK.

That is me responding to Adele, who was responding to me thinking it might be lynch-or-lose. That's not scummy.

I'm considering a vote for Spamwise. He voted Pug, who is away at the moment, and post 116 really confuses me.

I'm scummy b/c I was confused? WTF?

[TBuG]

So why did you vote me if you didn't think it was scummy?!?

[TBuG]

Bump'd.

[TBuG]

Aha, I get it!

Anyway,

unvote, vote: BrizzyBoi

.

[TBuG]

Yes, pointing out the masons to the scum is a very big no-no.

I don't see Adele or Spamwise as scum atm so...

Claims/Outed by BrizzyBoi

Adele

- Mason (outed)

Spamwise

- Mason (claimed and outed)

PBuG

- Spike, Bodyguard + can't cast lynching vote (claimed)

Sotty (Aelyn)

- Unclaimed

Pug

- Unclaimed

das (lostprophet)

- Unclaimed

BrizzyBoi

- Unclaimed

I'm not saying everyone should claim, I'm just posting this for reference (I don't take notes on games). If I forgot anything, inform me.

[TBuG]

*cough*BRIZZYBOI*cough*

[TBuG]

Yes, let's wait for a third person to say you should claim before you actually do so.

Confirm Vote: BrizzyBoi

Confirm Vote: BrizzyBoi

Confirm Vote: BrizzyBoi

Confirm Vote: BrizzyBoi

Confirm Vote: BrizzyBoi

Confirm Vote: BrizzyBoi

Confirm Vote: BrizzyBoi

Confirm Vote: BrizzyBoi

[TBuG]

So, I want either Pug89 or Brizzi to claim first, and I defer to spam to make the call as to which.

No offense PBuG but as Adele and Spamwise are the most trustworthy atm, I will listen to Adele and wait for her partner's opinion and neither hell nor high water (let alone your multiple Confirm Votes) will move me from that stance.

My point is, you're postponing your claim for stupid reasons.

[TBuG]

At this point, I'm thinking BrizzyBoi is scum because A) That's a decent claim for scum to make, not vanilla townie but not straight up power role. B) Safe to say Buffy is in the game... C) I think if there was a potential slayer in the game, it would be Kennedy. D) Back-up vig? Hell no.

[TBuG]

Now I'm trying to decide between Brizzy and das *thinks*

[TBuG]

I personally would request the following: We lynch Pug, Sotty vigs Brizzy, and I guard a person of my choosing, hopefully picking whomever the mafia targets.

P.S. OMG, Sotty, you're from Minnesota? *points to own location*

[TBuG]

By the way, let it be known that at least one out of Pug, Brizzy, and myself has to be scum. Probably two. Probably not me. Without all three of us, there would be das, Sotty (after tonight will be confirmed), Adele (confirmed), and SpamWise (confirmed). das is probably scum as well, by that logic.

Wow, I just realized that this means we will almost surely win

Unvote, Vote: Pug

Sorry if this is the hammer, but I think it's the right play.

[TBuG]

At this point, I'm thinking BrizzyBoi is scum because A) That's a decent claim for scum to make, not vanilla townie but not straight up power role. B) Safe to say Buffy is in the game... C) I think if there was a potential slayer in the game, it would be Kennedy. D) Back-up vig? Hell no.

I will

UnVote: Pug89

and

Vote: PBuG

.
Why is back-up vig that implausible if you are willing to consider a potential slayer in the game?

I'm talking about

which

potential slayer, and I don't think there would be a back-up vig JUST to give a role to a potential slayer. I think a back-up vig would really overpower the town, which going as if all claims are true, already has/had a doctor, bodyguard, two masons, cop, and a roleblocker. I'm having a hard time believing that on top of that there is a back-up vig.

Unvote

Sorry about that, it was looking like the general town concensus was Pug or Brizzy, so I thought it was okay to vote. That being said,

Vote: Brizzy

based on points I made previously as well as in this post.

[TBuG]

To be honest I could be SK or Mafia, but then my claim of vig would have been a little risky, how would I have know that this game didn't have one? That said I did claim next to last but still, it's something to consider.

I'm all for lynching Brizzy today as I don't like his recent attempts to latch himself onto me. He knows he's going down so forming a link between the two of us will land me in hot water tomorrow, if I'm not night killed that is.

It will be a hard choice for me between Pug and PBuG, I'd have to re-read. They both have points against them. I'd happily take out one of them though

I just think vigging a potential townie is a better idea than vigging a potential power role XP

[TBuG]

By the way, let it be known that at least one out of Pug, Brizzy, and myself has to be scum. Probably two. Probably not me. Without all three of us, there would be das, Sotty (after tonight will be confirmed), Adele (confirmed), and SpamWise (confirmed). das is probably scum as well, by that logic.

Wow, I just realized that this means we will almost surely win

Unvote, Vote: Pug

Sorry if this is the hammer, but I think it's the right play.

Whee, I fail. I just realized that it couldn't be the hammer because I can't cast the lynching vote.

[TBuG]

Pug... XD

[TBuG]

Sotty, just know that whoever you vig, you'll know who to lynch tomorrow. I'm going to entertain all of the possibilities with my and Pug's alignments.

You vig me, I turn up town. Pug is probably scum, you lynch him.
You vig me, I turn up scum. Pug is probably town, you lynch das.
You vig Pug, he turns up town. I am probably scum, you lynch me.
You vig Pug, he turns up scum. I am probably town, we lynch das.

Now, here's why you should vig Pug: With the logic aboue, whomever you vig, we have an idea of the others alignment. If you vig Pug and he's town, I will vote for myself. You should vig Pug because he is a claimeds townie, and I am a claimed power role.

[TBuG]

Pug is working off of the assumtion that nobody is lying about their role. That post convinces me he is the vig target because He's making it look like I have to be scum because I'm the only vampire, when chances are he's lying about his role.

[TBuG]

How you worded things, that's what it looked like.

[TBuG]

I already voted for him, Adele. See post 302.

[TBuG]

Unvote then and we'll sort it so you can cast the lynching vote. Great idea by Adele to test your claim.

Brizzy is lynched now, because Brizzy has four votes.

[TBuG]

I'll be away from August 25th to September 5th.

[TBuG]

Whoa, I did

not

expect that. At ALL.

[TBuG]

Oh, and I totally called Sotty as the SK in my head, I planned on suggesting that the next day XD

[TBuG]

Meh, Buffy makes sense under those circumstances. Warren probly should have been Johnathan instead.