Mini 291: Clue Mafia.....Game Over!

[BabyJesus]

several, why do you ask?

unvote

OMGUS

vote: TSAGod

holy crap, overreact much?

vote kops

[BabyJesus]

unvote, vote flay

[BabyJesus]

let's just finish off flay....

[BabyJesus]

is Flay dead yet....

[BabyJesus]

just to clarify, the random thing meant that i spun my spinner to see who i was gonna vote and thats who it came up on... but ok sure
in seriousness though... admittedly i've never been in a game with him b4... but whats up with BJ, is this really normal? i mean "let's just finish off flay" sounds a little OTT and he seems to really want the day over quickly, im pretty close to voting him but i'll hold off for now and wait for someone to tell me if he's always like that

I'm pretty sure we're going to need the vig to deal with out kops problem tonight....

[BabyJesus]

ok... just checking... thats kind of stupid if hes town but w/e ill leave him alone for now i guess (and btw @BJ wtf does that even mean... it makes so little gramatical sense i cant even understand it)

last words?

[BabyJesus]

ok... just checking... thats kind of stupid if hes town but w/e ill leave him alone for now i guess (and btw @BJ wtf does that even mean... it makes so little gramatical sense i cant even understand it)

well, it should say

I'm pretty sure we're going to need the vig to deal with

our

kops problem tonight

sorry.

[BabyJesus]

Here's a list of players with twelve players...

• [*]Col. Mustard
  [*]Miss Scarlet
  [*]Prof. Plum
  [*]Mrs. Peacock
  [*]Mr. Lyman Green
  [*]Mrs. White
  [*]Monsieur Brunette
  [*]Madam Rose
  [*]Sgt. Gray
  [*]Miss Melba Peach
• Didit
• Inspector Pry

It's from a VCR game, and it gives an obvious doc and butler...though I'm not sure if this is right...

:thumbup:

my role is on the list....

[BabyJesus]

eh? what do you call this?

let's just finish off flay....

id say thats pretty bandwagon pushingish...
honestly though guys.. can we please pick up the conversation a bit... this is really starting to drag a bit.. BJ is the biggest offender, not having posted in 3 days

sorry

[BabyJesus]

BJ is NOT playing the way he usually does. I'm pretty sure he is scum. .

Because I didn;t post in this game for a bit I'm scum?

unvote, vote Tamuz

Talk about a reach. Seriously.

[BabyJesus]

Unvote: elvis_knits, Revote: BabyJesus

- elvis and I can "talk" tonight. Bj doesn't talk at night, he kills.

what do you mean you talk at night....did I miss a claim somewhere?

[BabyJesus]

You missed the point where you were claimed to be a mafia or SK.

If that's what he's claiming, and he's willing to be lynched when I come up innocent, that's fine. I'm pretty sure it was a tongue-in-cheek comment however.

[BabyJesus]

You missed the point where you were claimed to be a mafia or SK.

wait a sec, did we even have a night phase yet? I thought we started with day...

confirm vote: Tamuz

for using false pretenses to bandwagon hop...

[BabyJesus]

tamuz in full spin mode I see....

[BabyJesus]

unvote, vote kops

\\pretty sure he's scum.

[BabyJesus]

unvote, vote kops

pretty sure he's scum

fixed

[BabyJesus]

What?

BJ, why did you just jump off Tamuz?

because I think kops is scum...

I'm still in favor of Tamuz claiming though, or I may hop on back

[BabyJesus]

So...what's shakin'?

waiting for everyone to vote kops so we can move on to night...

[BabyJesus]

I'm here but don't really have anything new to contribute.

BJ, why is kops scum?

because kops kills people at night...

[BabyJesus]

Kops, I question your statement to not being worried about BJ. I believe that paranoia should be on 24/7, and at the moment that includes BJ as a person. We should worry about BJ, he is rather random.

I have to say, I'll sit with my vote for now, I'm unsure how it would be moved in case of a deadline... but at the moment I'm happy voting jesus el nino

nah, dpn;t worry, I am pro-town.

[BabyJesus]

Al a Stoofer, I refuse to claim anything beyond Mrs. White,

unvote, vote Tamuz

[BabyJesus]

Looking back, kops doesn't look THAT bad to me. His random on MeMe was really trying to make sure we all understood it was random, which made me suspicious and still does. The thing that makes me think he's not scum is that as I read through his posts they sound like a stream of consciousness, not like an evilly-crafted attempt at manipulation and deception.

Anyway,Fuldu, please tell me why you want kops dead...

well, duh, I've already said kops is scum...

[BabyJesus]

today we

vote scum kops

sorry I did't check in in time to get it done before the deadline....

[BabyJesus]

not sure what it means, but I forgot we had to submit a move to a room....I don't know where my character spent the night...

[BabyJesus]

Rules say if you don't pick a room, the mod will randomly assign.

I wonder if she'd tell you which room you got picked for you.

I haven' been told, but I hadn't asked. I sent a pm to see.

[BabyJesus]

hear from the mod, it seems I ended up in the library...

I think there is benefit to everyone outing where they were.

[BabyJesus]

overall, I'd rather not say where I went.

vote Bamboomancer

[BabyJesus]

I'm wondering if scum can only kill people in the same room as them?

[BabyJesus]

Wow, paranoid much flay? nice kneejerk reaction to a simple statement. I expected it from BJ but I thought you at least had some sense.

still waiting for your room choice, guy.

[BabyJesus]

1) Kill in the same room--that means they

probably

pick one person to get a list of who is in the room w/ them or something of the sort, so they would already know who was responsible for blocking them (assuming of course there is a same-room block as well)

It seems that this would be impossible; the scum would first have to wait for all the other night choices in before making any kind of decision, and BJ didn't send a night choice so it's probably not likely.

Wait, why do you categorically believe BabyJesus when he says he didn't make a night choice?

why on earth would I lie about that?

[BabyJesus]

I agree it is very unlike BabyJesus to forget to make a night choice. Also to forget to check in around deadline and help us lynch someone. He just let his vote sit.

vote babyjesus

trying for the easy lynch, huh? pretty sure elvis is scum here.

[BabyJesus]

I agree it is very unlike BabyJesus to forget to make a night choice. Also to forget to check in around deadline and help us lynch someone. He just let his vote sit.

vote babyjesus

trying for the easy lynch, huh? pretty sure elvis is scum here.

Just because I put one vote on you? That seems like scum overreaction to me.

Oh please.

vote elvisknits

[BabyJesus]

And knowing BJ, it does seem odd that he would not vote.

vote: BabyJesus

feel free to lynch me and find out. Just a townie here, hence I totally forgot I had to send in a room choice....

[BabyJesus]

Did you just claim vanilla BJ?

yes...thought it was pretty obvious when I forgot to send in a night choice.

If we're doing "safe" lynches of townies, feel free to vote me...

[BabyJesus]

pretty sure Fuldu is scum here....

[BabyJesus]

Note that is four out of five needed (forgot how small this game was for a second). If someone drops the hammer right now and he happens to turn up town, there's gonna be questions need answering...

you're not very good at hunting scum, are you?

[BabyJesus]

Any thoughts from anyone else?

you COULD try and lynch scum today instead of killing the obvious townie...

[BabyJesus]

Any thoughts from anyone else?

you COULD try and lynch scum today instead of killing the obvious townie...

You are one from lynch. Try claiming your name.

does it matter? Miss Peach if you must know.

[BabyJesus]

Any thoughts from anyone else?

you COULD try and lynch scum today instead of killing the obvious townie...

You could try and give us a reason not to vote you today.
.

If trying to actually to actually kill scum isn;t reason enough to look elsewhere, I can't help you....

As for elvis, I didn't like the fact Bamboo refuses to disclose his room. I have a hunch if we all know what room people went to, we may be able to isolate and trap scum later on, so refusal to give us a history is very suspicious to me.

[BabyJesus]

I have a hunch if we all know what room people went to, we may be able to isolate and trap scum later on,

BJ -- could you elaborate on what you mean by this?

just a hunch. It seems to me a lot of the role choices and outcomes are based on who is where. Why else would we need to be in a room? I'm thinking if we have a record of who was in what room, it may be possible to narrow things down later, even if it's as little as narrowing down people who could NOT be scum at endgame based on room choices.

We don;t know right now, which is why I think NOW is why it is essential that we get the info for yesterday out there. Plus, scum may be afraid, and lie about the room they were in, and we may have a way of determining later on who was where.

I really don;t see a downside to revealing,m and DO see an upside. Again, it is all speculation - but why else do we need to submit room choices?

[BabyJesus]

Yeah.. I don't see how BJ claiming matters.... Clearly no one character in this game is any more likely to be scum than any other (assuming everyone's character is a color character), so I'm more for lynching BJ right now than possibly outing a power role... BJ hasn't done much to convince me of his towniness even if he has claimed...

lynching townies simply to avoid outing a power role is not really a winning strategy in a 12 player game...typically we at least TRY and hit scum. You've reminded me why I thought you were so scummy before now.

[BabyJesus]

That's not what I meant... you're misunderstanding me

I said I'd rather lynch

you

, who I think is scum, than start an entirely new bandwagon on somebody else, who I don't even find quite as suspicious (Elvis_Knits at this point, although even if that changes, I still find you somewhat more suspicious than anyone else, though not enough to warrant a vote yet)

why do you think I am scum, let's start with that misconception.

[BabyJesus]

I'm quite confused at this point. I guess if I had to choose, I would lynch BJ..

Just so we're clear, you want to lynch me because I didn't help you lynch a townie last night? That was the reasoning you used when you "picked" me, although personally I think you were just bandwagoning along.

That may be the weakest reasoning for a vote EVAH.

[BabyJesus]

Let's just lynch kops like I wanted to yesterday.

I agree with the sentiment, although I am a little apprehensive about it coming from you. either a kops or elvisknits lynch I could get behind....

[BabyJesus]

unvote, vote bigAl

pretty sure he's scum.

[BabyJesus]

This may be slightly OMGUS'y in a roundabout way. Mainly I still think BJ is scummy because, of course he acts scummy, but he is acting scummy in a scummier way than he usually acts scummy.

this is good schtick here.

[BabyJesus]

tempted to vote Bamboo here again, for the simple lack of participation.

[BabyJesus]

. As for the EK lynch, it started as a BJ suspicion and I don't buy any argument relating to anything BJ did EVER.

and yet your last vote was for EK....

[BabyJesus]

BJ... his last vote was his only vote, a random vote. So don't pretend like he's going back on his word.

Yet that does bring to my attention that Bamboomancer hasn't voted anyone except for a random vote. That's lame. He might need to be lynched for that.

we're on D2 with a good bit of discussion and 14 pages and he's cast a single random vote. Seriously.

unvote, vote bamboomancer

He needs to contribute. If he is scum, we're not going to be able to tell jack shit if he never votes. Let's run his ass up.

[BabyJesus]

I'm betting EK and Bamboomancer are scum buddies. I'd be happy to lynch either one.

[BabyJesus]

So we've decided to accept the unhelpful, no comment vote happy style that BJ plays but mine is just completely worthless to everyone, despite still trying to make clear and concise opinions?

sounds like bitter scum to me....

[BabyJesus]

bigAl and kops on elvisknits, not sure I like that company. think I'll stay off for now.

[BabyJesus]

why is Bamboo so hard to lynch?

I guess bigAl is still re-reading....

[BabyJesus]

unvote, vote elvis_knits

this day has gone on long enough. SOmone please hammah!

[BabyJesus]

Hmmm, why the unvote, elvis?

Because my vote on bigAl isn't doing anything if nobody will join me.

unvote, vote elvis_knits

this day has gone on long enough. SOmone please hammah!

I think Bamboomancer is a better lynch, if just for the fact that he hasn't contributed anything and likely won't in the future.

vote bamboomancer

I agree, but we've been stuck here long enough. If we can get a bamboo train going, I will happily join it.

[BabyJesus]

unvote, vote bamboo

[BabyJesus]

so he claimed doc...
guess we have to lynch him now. RIP Bamboo.

[BabyJesus]

Unvote: elvis_knits, Vote: Baby Jesus

- there's no reason to auto-lynch a claimed doc in a mini game. If he survives the night, then we can start asking more questions.

Bamboo, are you saying that your action prevents damage by anyone who is in your same room, or to those in the same room? That'll affect what I want to do next... and you STILL haven't said what room you were in.

pretty sure I'm confirmed townie, guy. Not sure why you're voting a townie. And I will always vote for claimed docs. It's my new policy. Vote me off for it if you like, it's not gonna change a damn thing.

[BabyJesus]

Who confirmed you, BJ? I don't remember anything like that, and I'm fairly sure I'd have removed my vote if I'd seen it.

I just double checked my OM and confirmed it. I'm a townie.

[BabyJesus]

Who confirmed you, BJ? I don't remember anything like that, and I'm fairly sure I'd have removed my vote if I'd seen it.

I just double checked my OM and confirmed it. I'm a townie.

OM=PM

[BabyJesus]

There is absolutely

no reason

to lynch a claimed doc over a claimed townie

in a game where docs can be confirmed

. Anyone who is still on the Bamboowagon is suspect.

And if you think this makes Bamboo and I co-conspirators, think about what a foolish idea it would be to create a false alliance like this on Day Two. We'd be signing our own death warrants.

Hoe exactly can the doc be confirmed? Unless the mod os planning on announcing it before the end of the day, vote stays. There's more at stake here. I'd say there is a good chance Bambii is telling the truth. But I have the overall picture of removing doc as a claim scum can use.

[BabyJesus]

Perhaps because my role can see what people do???

and that's supposed to mean something to me? not to mention a) would not catch a scum doctor, and b) would tend to limit a doc's ability anyway if he has to hang around you.

[BabyJesus]

My vote stays on Bamboo. Good luck with the lynch.

[BabyJesus]

What do you mean "he can't be targetted by mafia"?

good question....

does Tamuz know more then he's letting on....

[BabyJesus]

why is bamboo not dead yet....

[BabyJesus]

Well then. Less than a day and a half to go; are you all comfortable defaulting to lynching a claimed doc? I've already said who I'd prefer, and my vote's there, but without discussion, nothing will change...

I've already said I will vote for a claimed doc. Not much else I can say here. If you feel like lynching a townie instead, go ahead and kill me....although lynching scum BigAl would be a nice step too.

[BabyJesus]

I thought I unvoted

unvote: Bamboomancer vote: BJ

pretty sure Tamuz is scum here. I'd suggest our vig deal with him tonight...

[BabyJesus]

lol. deadline approaches and no one tries to find scum anymore...

tamuz and bigal are top two scum prospects tomorrow