I think I like the Chosen set-up as it is now. The issue with having only one Chosen was that if the single Chosen ended up looking particularly town-ish for one reason or another, the scum were basically fried and likely wouldn't have any chance at winning the game. The issue with having multiple veto votes was that it made it easy for towns to just lynch the people who were most likely vetoed, which would likely be damaging for scum as well. Basically, the game was very strongly town-favored all around in the old set-up. This is something that Zorblag exploited fairly well in hohum's game, and I think Albert B. Rampage tried to exploit this a bit in my first Chosen game also.
I think hohum mentioned something about adding another goon and keeping it at one Chosen -- I'm really not too crazy about that since you'd probably also need to add extra townies anyway for two reasons:
1)
to make the game more balanced by normal Mafia standards and
2)
to still give the scum a shot at winning due to the mechanic itself (needing to lynch a Chosen while Vanillas are still alive). 5 townies, 1 Chosen, and 3 scum would... just not work. So yeah, if anyone runs a Chosen again, I'd definitely recommend that he or she uses the layout that we had here (and yes, this includes giving the scum the single veto vote still).
I was initially a bit worried that the game would be a cakewalk for Town when Cojin was lynched Day 1 because it seemed like MiteyMouse was going to be next in line; the cross-bussing thing actually worked really nicely for the scum though. I think the Town largely ignored MiteyMouse for the remainder of the game under the assumption that she was "just a Chosen", and she did a good job of exploiting that. I wonder what would have happened if the wagon swung towards MiteyMouse instead of Cojin though...
I, too, am looking forward to MiteyMouse's thoughts about the game -- I thought the Sajin-kill was decent because he really was obvtown at that point due to his early game mix-up, but I thought for sure that Zorblag was gonna be her NK choice at some point since he was the veto vote in the first place and because it seemed like a good portion of people thought Sajin was a Chosen One, which might have made lynching a real Chosen One much easier as end-game approached. I was pretty positive that Zorblag would push a him-lynch at end-game since his thoughts seemed to line up for that since Day 1 (I think he might have thought twice about it after Night 1 happened but still).
Nikanor wrote:Although, I do believe my death was a bit lacking in its originality.
Sorry, I get really really lazy with the flavor as the game progresses whenever I mod. I only gave the end-game as much flavor as I did because Zorblag inspired me with a PM for his own song requests.
@Scien:
What made you change your mind about this:
Post 714, Scien wrote:We hit you as vanillia, townie, I think we have our victory in my lynch.
I thought for sure you might have ended up pushing for your own lynch right from the start of Day 4. I think that would have made for an interesting situation haha.
Thanks, everyone else, for all of the other comments! I hope you all enjoyed and congrats to the Town for winning!
Oh and for the record, I'm a "strapping 25" going on 26 next month. Is 26 less strapping?