reinoe wrote:mafiascum ate my post. tl/dr when I ISO'd you I could not figure out where you stand with most people in the game. In several instances you make comments that are contradictory.
Please answer the question I posed to you in post 1056.
I think you kept going back to that originally to change the topic when I was pressing you. Now you are just going back to it because you have limited arguments for me being scum.
Please quote where I was contradictory. Also, I am still waiting for where Alchemist was contradictory when he joined the random midget wagon.
Reads lists.
Reino: Everything in my mind is saying he is scum. My gut isn't as confident.
Reasons: He was acting in a way that would very likely get him lynched rather quickly. I lean towards thinking he bussed his partners, and then played in a way so he could get lynched relatively early, thereby making his partners look town. However, when Matsumi made the huge mess-up, they sort of changed roles in who would be the sacrifice. Reino is acting a lot more pleasant today then the other days and isn't asking to be lynched with his behaviour anymore. It's the most satisfying way to explain his actions.
Other reasons: Shooting down discussion day 2. Insane tunneling. Scum reads on me and Majiffy were because we were pressing him.
Krystal: Starting to lean more scum. Voting for someone she thinks is town with this few players left is head-scratching. Especially with wildcards Doublade and Gaiden still unvoted. I re-read Majiffy's case on Krystal and still don't find it that strong, so it's not a strong read, but not ruling it out. I will laugh very hard though if at the end of the game, I learn Krystal did scumslip at the very beginning.
Alchemist: Still quite sure he is town. He has been scum hunting rather convincingly and honest seeming.
Aphix: Still lean town. I asked Aphix a lot of questions D1 because he did a lot of things that seemed scummy. He answered them satisfactory enough though, and he has been very consistent in what I remember. I think he would be a little more cautious and engaged as scum, but he has been very laid back. Part of this being based off meta since I played with him before.
Gaiden: Lean slightly town. He still needs to post more.
Doublade: I'm getting annoyed with how little he/she posts. Null. Leaning scum.
What are other people's thoughts on a Reino Krystal scumpair? It wouldn't be impossible, but would Krystal be defending Reino?
If they aren't the pair, I would lean towards thinking the partner to one of them would be Doublade.
)