D1
- Early vote on MoS for saying he won't vote people. I agree with this
- Follow FoS on pabs for licking in towards Glork.
- Vote for Phoebus, preferation above pabs, bird and CDB. Saying he doesn't have strong scumfeelings towards anyone right now.
- There's no word heard about Rosso from Yos. I don't know if he just missed it or he just lurked there, but I'm going to assume he was not around at that point.
So far: Neutral. It's the usual D1 play
D2
- The first part of D2 is lost and since I was not around, I don't know what happened back then.
- Vote for Twomz
- Discussion with Glork after Glork attacked him. Reasons were mainly about giving preferations about the LoE yesterday, where Yos prefered phoebus, but not eleborated a little more on this. Although it is a little odd not do eleborate more on it, it does not strike me as a scumtell immediatly.
- Vote for Pabs for Glork licking.
- FoS for Phoebus for bandwagonning. This is the second time he states his suspicions towards Phoebus, but it doesn't turn anything near a vote. Scumbuddy?
- Discussion with Pabs and Bird. The problem is I can't reread about the part that has been deleted during the early D2, but he's continuely stating his defense for Bird. I'm buying it because I think enough people would knew if he would lie.
- Says he thinks Pabs is likely town, after he previously find him scummy. Scummy
- guesses he thinks PJ is town. Reasons seem a bit odd. Read below
After that, it gets harder. If I had to guess, I'd guess PJ was town based on his actions and the style of his posts; it doesn’t seem to me that scum would act the way he did at the end of the day on day one, but that's a very WIFOM argument and I'm not putting a lot of faith in it, especially as he did end up killing a townie and giving us next to no information from day 1 in the process.
- This post is very confusing to me:
Yosarian2 wrote:..boy, this is rather embarassing. I had forgotten most of the details about this game in the 10 days the site was down, and when I did a re-read to answer Glork's question, I seem to have come to a completly different opinion then what I had thought before the crash, and I didn't re-read my own posts so I didn't even notice. I just went back to see who I was voting for, and it turns out I'm voting for one of the people I just said I thought was innocent.
unvote:pablito
I'm most suspicious of Twomz and Phoebus at this point.
- Defense against Zindaras. Doesn't ring a scumbell.
- States his suspicions towards Glork for not doing his homework assignment.
- Discussion with Phoebus. I think his posts here were actually quite good.
- States Pooky as neutral.
So Far: He had to catch alot of flack today, and I must admit that i've picked up several scumvibes from him, but also some good ones. Currently leaning towards slightly scummy, especially since he stated Pooky neutral.
D3
- Vote for Phoebus and Samus
- Says he could believe Glork bussing Pooky. This sounds odd, especially since it would be noted if Glork lived long after he would've bussed a partner. I don't think that people wouldn't suspect him if he lived until this day.
- Defense against Glork for his votes on Phoebus and Twomz. He stick to stone to it, which seems normal to me if you vote someone. Nothing alarming here.
- Vote for MoS for defending Pooky.
- Eleboration on his votes, on request. Phoebus: contentless lurkerscum. Twomz: birdwagon. MoS: Defense Pooky
- Pushing for Phoebus hammer.
- Defense against RafK.
- States he prefers a LL execution above SV.
- Supports DoS execution
So far: My sense of scum towards his increased dramaticly. His vote against MoS while not being a fan of a Pooky execution himself at that point, suspicions towards Glork bussing, prefering LL (town) above SV (scum) all don't strike me as positive. My guts say he's scum now, but I'll see where it ends up after I totally readed the thread.
D4: Kingship of Yos
- LoE: Mos, Vitty, SV, Smashy
- Asks everyone for comments on people on list above
- Adds Mnowax to list
- Eleboration on LoE: MoS (not so scummy anymore), SV (because other people...), Vitty (rep. Phoebus), Smashy (because Rikku was a bad king yesterday), Mnowax (defense Pooky). Seriously, I find this post alarmingly scummy.
- says he's leaning towards Mnowax lynch, although he states before that he always finds Mnowax scummy.
- says he's sharing thoughts with PJ.
- Hammer Mnowax
so far: still leaning towards scum. His Kingship didn't really give me any good vibes. He was trying to go with the flow of the rest of the town is the impression I got, but this could be good or bad either way.
D5
- Defense against RafK. Nothing suspicious IMO
- Lowell follows Rafk, so Yos rereads Lowell and then votes him. OMGUS?
- Supports both Fritz and Vitty execution.
So far: not so much more alarming on D5. My suspicions has decreased a little, but not much. My guts still think he is scum.
Overall: Leaning towards scum
I'll do PJ later.