In post 2349, Cheery Dog wrote:In post 2348, Xisiqomelir wrote:
In post 2347, Cheery Dog wrote:@Xis, just to claify something else, when did me being open about the light green card become a town tell to you?
When I got my own. It's clear you were telling the truth about a ridiculous non-ability, which is pro-town to reveal since it would invite suspicion.
So you still had me a suspect when you investigated Jal?
I'd say you were a tie for 3rd with SafetyDance.
In post 1979, Xisiqomelir wrote:
@Jake:
In post 1891, Jake from State Farm wrote:@ Xis - why investigate Baby night 1 instead of SC who you were more suspicious of?
Investigating Jal makes no sense either when mehndi or guile were better options.
I said earlier I saw a lurker/xis connection and this claim really sucks. You definitely made it seem like you caught someone when you started the day. Also your comment about nobody slipping makes no sense because you didn't have a guilty.
The only thing keeping me from voting you right now is because if you were scum, why make this claim like that?
My head hurts now
Mafia Theory, but I think it's better to clarify a more ambiguous read than go for a stronger one. I have adopted this consistently for the four investigations I've done on-site.
Discworld Mafia N1, I had Shamrock as top scumspect, but investigated Thor (who was NKed). I then voted Shamrock off the bat D2 and got him lynched (he was town)
Discworld Mafia N2, I had Cherry Nog as top scumspect, but investigated Calcifer and got a guilty.
N1 here, I suspected SC/Cheery most, but investigated Baby because of awkwardness over her "notebook". I voted SC to start the day, but then Monkey's defences unravelled.
Last night, in the end I decided that TBG leaving himself out of his own plan was scummier than Jal wanting to vig her co-wagoners, so I investigated Jal, planning on pushing TBG today.
The NK and investigation make this fairly straightforward for me. We still have the unresolved doc/did-not-doc 1v1 from Mehdi and SafetyDance, and then one of the neighbours is likely scum.
Currently, I'm stuck between you and Mhork. StrangerCoug's performance is weighing down heavily on you here, which I know you can't do anything about, but I consider the actions of former slotholders telling, as in the case of NumberQ/guille.