Also, we either have a very stupid townie, or mafia playing very clever with their pick.
And while I'm at it...
Because you failed your initiative roll.manho wrote:i think i have a brain, and i think you are implying a stupid townie or a clever scum above you, which are the top 5 in the list, has picked neighborizer. but why did you pick neighborizer if you think only a stupid townie or clever scum will do it? are you a stupid townie or a clever scum? i think you are the later one.PranaDevil wrote:Incidentally, for the record, in case people want to know why I said we either have a stupid townie, or clever scum, is I went for Neighborizor.
If you have a brain you'll work it out, if you haven't, the town is doomed anyway.
I was meaning they're more likely to not use it, not that they wont.Pomegranate wrote:This sentence confuses me. Do you mean that if a townie is a vig, then he won't kill unless he's sure? Because that's not the case.PranaDevil wrote:Well yeah, but I still strongly suggest giving it a day or two to get the most out of the other roles, after all, scum using vig kills any nights prior to a claim are guarenteed to be caught out with it when they're made to claim anyway.Town would be more inclined to hold back to use it when needed most.
I think that if we wait until tomorrow to massclaim, then we should either direct the vig, or we should instruct him not to kill at all.
It's only dubious if you can't work it out. Thus far in that list we have dram and manho, I'm saying scum for both.dramonic wrote:Oh please, like you're an exemple of hunting.
Prana is saying particularly dubious thing, so is CMAR. I could surely establish a reason for scum to pick every single role on your "Town-role" list.
I'll reread to see if CMAR has done anything. If not the vote is going in that direction soon.
Actually, a vig could be directed still tonight whether we claim or not.Sando wrote:Ok, this seems way too obvious not to have been thought of, but after the signup thread, I'm no longer convinced that everyone would be able to tie their own shoe-laces...
How on earth does claiming on D2 compared to D1 change things for vig? How are they less locked in after having had 1 night to kill?
Basically, a D1 massclaim doesn't really seem to gain us anything over a D2, and gives scum an extra night to plan and kill the PRs.
Pardon me if I don't take your word stating he is based on a single post that doesn't tell anyone he's town.DrippingGoofball wrote:He's town.Super Awesome Mega Pimp! wrote:that you haven't posted anything meaningfulsorasgoof wrote:@SAMP- what exactly are your accusations that I'm supposed to be addressing?
Parama is town because I says he is.manho wrote:actually, my reason for suggestion the massclaim is to help me make my decision. i really don't want to redirect the vig to themselves.
but why is parama town? i can only see a scum who can't get the janitor and a scum quickhammering to give her team advantages.
I'll take my word over yours thanks. He may need a slap upside the head for not participating more, but he's town.DrippingGoofball wrote:Nope, he's scum.PranaDevil wrote:And Zoaium is town. It would be a bad move to lynch him.
I've been doing that since before you were born. Last time I was questioned on this was in PacMan mafia back in 1983.[/quote]PranaDevil wrote:DGB is trying to up her towniness by even including herself in the "town" list of players. Rare is it I see a town player do that unless they're confirmed. DGB isn't confirmed at all.
Role based. Saying no more until tomorrow when I propose a mass claim to get info from cop/doc as well, and have (one would hope) plenty of confirmed townies thanks to that.Fate wrote:Also Prana, tell me more about this Zoiaum town read.
Read post 911Parama wrote:You're the more wrong one.PranaDevil wrote:You're wrong, you're town, but you're wrong.Parama wrote:NEWSFLASH:
Sando is town.
Zoiaum is scum.
Okay, look at it this way: There is almost certainly one scum between DGB and Zoiaum. Who is more likely scum between the two? Definitely Zoiaum.
Exceptionally unlikely.Faraday wrote:didn't pom catch porkens da scum vig?