elvis_knits wrote:I'm doing a catalogue of people's reactions to DN's plan... and the more I read I am starting to think that Messiah is not a DN buddy. He WAS one of the people who kept mentioning that DN was scummy even when others look like they were purposely avoiding.
Feeling better about Messiah.
Great stuff. Let me start this by saying that if all scum did was ignore their scum buddy the hunting scum would be really easy.
Lets do the list of what scum can do:
buss their buddy
ignore their buddy
defend their buddy
messiah:
Far too much of it seems to be that you think she is "obsessed with" and "defends" DN, but I don't see the huge scumtell there. The only way that her defense of DN could be scummy in my eyes is if DN was scum, but you say that you only think DN is scum in the first place because starbuck defended him.
So you're saying starbuck is scum because she mentions DN a lot but has a neutral read on him? I don't get the scumtell here at all.
follows someone else logic
I looked at DN and his one of the reason's was the above.Messiah wrote:I didn't realize it at the time, but this is a very good point. He presents a false dilemma, leaving out the option that is best for the town. This coupled with his push to proceed with a plan that would most likely be harmful to the town is a good reason toPug89 wrote:I really don't like this post. It seems like he is trying to force the town to choose either empowering everyone or no one and ignores the third option of imprinting only a few people (which is what Elvis actually suggested).vote: DeathNote
unvote, vote: DeathNote for the reasons stated in these posts, and the "Just policy lynch me and get it over with Crying or Very sad" thing.
Red alert! Red Alert
Really? Really? No not really I just have the quote her to prove in fact you called it not a scum tell at all.Messiah wrote:I'm down for a Starbuck lynch. I believe I said that I would find her defense of DN scummy if he flipped scum, and I stand by that. I'm going to allow her the opportunity to post before hammering since she hasn't gotten a chance to respond to anything yet.
vote: Messiah
fos: EK