Mini 635: WOMAFIA - Forbiddanlight + Vagina-Haters win!

[FaerieLord]

ITT, we discuss girl stuff! Boys should totally keep out! Amirite?

Also,

Vote: Gurgi

for being a boy in disguise!

[FaerieLord]

So how many males are actually in this game? (I also see that FL got a sex change.)

And people are already falling for it!

Those hormone treatments do work after all...

[FaerieLord]

XD @ Mirth.

Also, that's a good move. And I believe Gurgi.

[FaerieLord]

You believe him and yet won't unvote him?

Good point. Forgot my random vote.

Unvote

[FaerieLord]

Why listen to me, FL, what was your vote hurting?

Because we are out of the random voting stage with that claim. A vote there is a bad vote now.

Breast singular? Now that's moderately disturbing.

Why isn't your symbol female yet?

Darla, if you were a miller, what would you do?

Just like

him

her

claim doctor or something to get myself NKed or vigged.

This is assuming the other doctor is not an idiot and counterclaims.

[FaerieLord]

With all the WIFOM on LG, It would seem somewhat logical that unless someone comes round even more scummy, that he would be the safest lynch for D1.

Wow, that was pretty awful

All I am saying is that after we've exhausted d1, if no one is REALLY scummy, that LG would be the best lynch, because its win win either way.

Have you been in games like this? In every game I've been in, I've always seen someone scummy in day one.

[FaerieLord]

No, treating him as a confirmed townie is not good

But lynching LG, who has looked townie thus far, because the claim is dubious, is even worse.

[FaerieLord]

My thoughts on meta is that it is overrated. I can't say this person was scum because during this game they acted just like they did here. Usually I see people use meta as a desperate means to justify a vote

Funny, when I have a meta on someone, I always use that to justify my vote.

That said, Falcone is stretching really hard to find something scummy about farside.

[FaerieLord]

Same as farside here. This weekend was crazy, I'll catch up on Monday

[FaerieLord]

Sorry, I haven't been keeping up with this game, which is awful.

My word, I'll read tomorrow morning. Now it's late though

[FaerieLord]

Ok I reread, and this game is rather empty which is kind of sad

My 3p scum and 3p list, as gurgi suggested, in no particular order

scummy-ish

Spacecase (hasn't really been contibuting, but that's not all. I don't like his "glad I'm not miller" comment and the fact that he comments that he would lynch LG only after LG expresses suspicion on her.)
Mirth (something strikes me as off)
Mariyta (her vote on me as soon as Vivian voted me looked really bad, especially since she said herself that she's guilty of the same thing)

Town-ish

Lord Gurgi
ThAdmiral
Farside

So, for now

Vote: Spacecase

I'd have that over a darla lynch.

[FaerieLord]

Why did you include a town list? Also what strikes you as off about me exactly? Are you only voting Spacecase because you think he's an alternative to Darla?

Because Gurgi did too? I have no idea. It's gut. Nothing more, nothing less. Yes. I'd rather vote Mariyta, but that lynch isn't going to happen. And I'd rather have spacecase over DBE.

[FaerieLord]

That would be why, I wasn't aware of it, and I guess that means you aren't either, but it would also mean you aren't reading very closely.

I missed a line in my reread, screw me. Besides, I don't really agree

Soooo instead of putting forth a case for Mariyta, who you'd rather vote but ranked less scummy than me, off of gut feeling, you're just going to follow along with whatever is going on?

Those aren't in order. In order they'd be Mariyta, Spacecase then you. But yes, that's what I'm going to do when the deadline is 5 days away. I'd rather push a Mariyta case tomorrow.

[FaerieLord]

Why would you rather push a Mariyta case tomorrow if you think she's the most suspicious today?

1) Because we're under a 4 day deadline
2) Because she says her playstyle changes after day one, and I'd like to test that

@FL: Would you mind explaining your prefrence for Mariyta over Spacecase? Your original scumlist was in "no particular order". I'm reading more OMGUS than anything else.

If it was OMGUS, why wouldn't I be voting you?

I'm keeping my vote where it is until I see something more solid from Faerielord. The more she posts, the more I feel I made the right move. She still comes across as scum trying to post enough to seem useful while staying under the radar.

You're saying I'm staying under the radar? Hypocritical, much?

[FaerieLord]

That is true, but at least I'm trying to post more, unlike some who make promises they don't keep.

I am keeping my promise since I am posting more

I am unsure about procedure here, should the partner confirm them, or what?

Not yet

Also,

unvote

[FaerieLord]

It sure counts as posting more then her though. Besides, there isn't really much to say that others did not say.

[FaerieLord]

where I've found most people go FL for Faerie and fl for me.

Yeah, this should work

Also, as for your comments. The reason I find Mirth scummy is gut, which is why I didn't stress on it. Also, I honestly cannot see the wagon behind Darla. Also, I don't talk a lot in most games, so I guess it's a playstyle.

[FaerieLord]

How about Condorcet voting since we seem to be getting nowhere?

Weren't you against listing town? A condorcet serves the exact purpose...

EDIT BEFORE POST: Never mind this.

Also, my condorcet

Condorcet: Mariyta, spacecase (until she full claims), mirth, dbe (unless she starts participating).

[FaerieLord]

Remove me from the spacecase list as well. I believe it

Also

Unvote, Vote Darla

L-1.

[FaerieLord]

Yes admiral, you are.

[FaerieLord]

I really don't see the farside case either right now.

What I do agree though, is that it's definitely not pro-town for a player to ask to be killed.

[FaerieLord]

What did you consider to be a stretch? Did you think the points Falcone raised against farside22 were not good points that could be used to be indicative of someone being scum? What do you think of farside22 now?

The post in general. While the points may be indicative to show scum, I feel that in that case they were only there to help him create a case rather than be the case (if that makes sense). For me she's neutral.

As far as I can tell the only case you're pushing on me is that I don't throw votes around day one.

This is a very bad post

[FaerieLord]

That defense was god horrible, ThAdmiral. I am really tempted to vote you for it

[FaerieLord]

Warning: you will look worse when I tear the attack on me to shreds.

Aha...just like you ripped incognitos. Shredded wheaties

Also, I'm not happy with a farside lynch, but damn

Vote: ThAdmiral

I'm sure happy with this

[FaerieLord]

I wonder if any of you actually read incognito's post or just saw that it was long and assumed it was correct.

Yeah, we have fetishes for long posts. Sorry about that

Did I ever actually do either of those things?

No, because you did nothing

Furthermore it seems incognito is suggesting that every single post that one makes in a mafia game must either attack someone or defend them, and if it doesn't do either it is scummy!

Show me where he said this

but everything I don't do is scummy as well.

Pretty much. (PS: Stop overreacting)

Wait a second - didn't you say you were suspicious of me when I wasn't scumhunting? And now you're suspicious when I am?

And you're saying we're not reading the posts?

and do you think it might be possible that I was thinking things about certain people that I didn't immediately write down in the game?

Should we care about what you think outside the game?

as well as others that you actually included earlier on in your own post in which I express my suspicion of darla.

Bottom line is you never said why

I don't really know what incognito is trying to do here. Perhaps she doesn't either, and just decided to question yet another innocuous post to flesh her case out a little bit more.

Saying you have suspicions != having suspicions

I wonder what would happen if the farside wagon took off again...

Really? Me too!

Pre post edit: Ok, forbiddan light owned me to the ripping, but I'm still going to post my version

[FaerieLord]

I killed Mariyta.

1)I killed this night so that we'll have better percentage of hitting scum (and because if I missed we'd be at lylo either way 8v3 or 7v3 = 7v3 is the best option)

2) Also, people can guess why I killed mariyta.

(Also, for those why didnt notice. I claim vig.)

VOTE COUNT

Farside - 1 - incognito

Not voting:
farside22
forbiddanlight replaces xyzzy
FaerieLord
Lord Gurgi
nonny
Vivian Darkblaam

With 7 alive, 4 to lynch!

[FaerieLord]

Why did you choose to claim now though without any pressure placed on you?

Why not?

Which leads me to a new question. If we don't hit scum today, should I kill? Me killing wrongly = we lose the game (2v2), but if you'd rather have two town kills rather than hope for another die (one lynch, one vig), I guess that could work too

[FaerieLord]

I'm just always somewhat leery of unprovoked role claims. I mean in this case, your role is more or less confirmed with Mariyta's death but nevertheless, I think it's usually better to keep a vig claim to yourself unless of course we were mass claiming. By claiming now, you've revealed yourself as the second killer, the scum now know who you are, and may try and NK you tonight which causes us to lose a powerful town role.

After now, I'm useless since I won't be able to kill.

Also, I support MC too.

Flavor and picture from FL

I'm a vibrator. I kill people by giving them the best orgasm ever in thier life. Elvis' flavour is a bit off though, since she describes it as a happy death in the role pm (And I consider bitch slaps not stuff that makes you happy)

Also, http://img99.imageshack.us/my.php?image ... umbye9.jpg

[FaerieLord]

Explain, plz. How so? Also, if we MC, do you wanna decide the order?

Because if I kill incorrectly we lose, so it's a very risky situation for me to kill. Also, I guess who ever is here should just claim rather than stalling the game waiting

Further, what does a girl holding an AK-47 in a wedding dress have to do with a vibrator? lol.

I bet she uses it quite a bit

(On a serious note, I have no idea. Just like the flavour of the kill didn't make any sense)

Didn't you say earlier that you wanted guidance on who to kill tonight if we didn't hit scum?

No, I asked town if I should kill, there's a difference

I know I don't deserve an answer to anything right now,

Appeal for Emotion

but if FL has only one shot, why shot Mariy instead of the person most everyone is suspicious of?

Who said I'm one shot?

Don't you think that putting the town at LyLO is risky?

8 people and 7 people are both lylo if I didnt kill.

You were not FaerieLord's prime suspect clearly.

*Ting Ting* Weeeeeeee have a winner!

@Farside. People found Gurgi suspicious for wanting the vig to kill him, yet you jumped for the hammer to be rid of by what you thought was an SS just for having suspicion on you?

[FaerieLord]

Hmmm... the flavor of FL's claim is putting me ill at ease. The idea of a killing vibrator works to an extent, but it doesn't match the evidence of the death scene or the picture in the slightest. Wild guess: Bridezilla-style SK who either chose not to kill or was blocked by Mirth N1. That's not the way it has to be, but given the coherence of previous claims, I'm just not seeing this one.

I didn't like the flavour either but meh. If I'm lying, you'll all know soon enough

Also, as wifomy as it sounds, why would I claim vig, when I know that my claim doesn't fit with flavour and that I could have gotten away with it as SK?

[FaerieLord]

Why don't I just shoot her just to stay safe?

[FaerieLord]

I know what I'm going to do tonight

GJ all. It was fun playing with you

[FaerieLord]

On the plus side. I'm male again :p

Twas a good game. GJ scum