Fixed.forbiddanlight wrote:That was rather impressive in it's fail. I do have a girlfriend you know. Are you amasochist of some sort that enjoys being shot downguy?
Nah. She tried some last minute confusion tactic, failed, and has admitted to being scum. She is today's lynch. Once she flips scum, you can get a shot in tonight hopefully hitting the final scum (assuming three scum), and we can live happily ever after watchingFaerieLord wrote:Why don't I just shoot her just to stay safe?
Or FL is the SK and is hoping to cause a mislynch to win for herself.Incognito wrote:Nah. She tried some last minute confusion tactic, failed, and has admitted to being scum. She is today's lynch. Once she flips scum, you can get a shot in tonight hopefully hitting the final scum (assuming three scum), and we can live happily ever after watchingFaerieLord wrote:Why don't I just shoot her just to stay safe?Sex and the Citywhile eating bonbons.
Because I was activeduring that list and saw it happen. This last lynch I had some problems getting on line to check on things. Also DBE lynch took the full autodeadline time, where as admiral lynch was much quicker and seemingly came from no where. The DBE lynch some poeple had been suspecting her for quite some time and then she became the deadline lynch.nonny, why did you not bother to do or even suggest to do a wagon analysis type of thing after DBE's lynch? Also, why did you not give farside22 the same level of flak that you gave me for pursuing suspects? farside22 came down pretty hard on DBE and then followed up her DBE attack the day after with more attacks this time on Lord Gurgi, but you didn't really have much to say about that. Compare that to your reaction to me where I attacked ThAdmiral on Day 2 and then followed up my ThAdmiral attacks today with an attack on farside22 where you pretty much told me that I should "consider that I may be wrong and blindly pursuing another townie".
I have never seen a jester win condition including not revealing themselves.Incognito wrote:Also Vivian: I'm pretty sure that if farside22 really was a Jester, she'd pretty much lose already anyway for admitting to being a Jester. A Jester win condition is usually not only dependent on them getting lynched but also on them never revealing that they really are a Jester before they get lynched.
I suspect that farside22 will self-hammer before nonny gets a chance to respond so on the off-chance that I don't make it through the night, I still believe that one of nonny or Vivian is scum (leaning nonny). I'm still liking forbiddanlight as town, and I still feel like Lord Gurgi stands a strong chance of being town especially if farside22 flips scum. I also think FaerieLord is town as well. Though, if farside22 flips scum and if FaerieLord hits scum tonight and the game doesn't end, I'd recommend lynching him tomorrow pronto as he's likely to be an SK.
Here's the problem. We can either spend the short twilight cobbling together a "lynch" through vig kill, when we don't even know for sure if FL is town, or we could have him not kill, end up with 5 players, giving us the luxury of 2 lynches unless I'm really mistaken about this set up. I'd rather have a full days discussion rather than twilight vig directing. Do you see where I'm going?forbiddanlight, if FL is who he says he is and he kills tonight, the worst case scenario is he hits town. Scum will likely NK him leaving us at 3:1. In that case, we'd likely have to No Lynch bringing us down to endgame.
I really do think he should kill tonight. Maybe we should come to a consensus as to whom he should kill in the limited amount of time we have?
To be fair, the merits of a vig kill are mostly the fact it's a town directed extra lynch. It gets into a theory argument where even though cop/doc directing is scummy, vig directing isn't because the target dies anyway. But it's only good if the vig directing is done by a majority of the living players. Or something like that.No. He should decide on his own who he wants to kill.
That's fair enough. We can try to come up with something in the short time we have. Though I likely won't be indulging in that tonight. I go to bed soon. Off the cuff I'd say nonny or LG. But that's just without any full analysis and off the top of my head. LG because I'm iffy about a miller claimant at lylo and after D1 his pro townness started slipping IMO, and nonny because she's felt very...neutral all game. Not actively pro town.Well if FL is an SK, I doubt he'll be listening to us anyway about whether or not he should kill so that's really out of the picture.
elvis_knits isn't usually on during this hour; I don't even know if she's a weekend poster, period. I think, if we have time, we should read through the thread and try to decide on a vig kill ASAP. It will simply be a guidance... FL obviously doesn't have to use our choice if he doesn't want to.
Meh. I'm iffy on the miller claim as well. Bleh... Going off the top of my head, the one point he does have in his favor though is he did attack farside at various points through Day 1, and he seemed to follow up with his attacks into Day 2 as well. I specifically remember him repeating that "farside is the play today", which gives me somewhat of a good vibe from him despite his Miller claim.forbiddanlight wrote:That's fair enough. We can try to come up with something in the short time we have. Though I likely won't be indulging in that tonight. I go to bed soon. Off the cuff I'd say nonny or LG. But that's just without any full analysis and off the top of my head. LG because I'm iffy about a miller claimant at lylo and after D1 his pro townness started slipping IMO, and nonny because she's felt very...neutral all game. Not actively pro town.