Mini 583! BAMPEG!!!....IS THIS THE END???

[roffman]

/confirm

[roffman]

vote ergo

for leaving so soon

[roffman]

wait...didn't you replace into

my

game?

[roffman]

or he could have information that Scopey is scum

[roffman]

mmm, limpet stew

[roffman]

i'm still unfamiliar with some concepts. what's bastardized?

[roffman]

and also, since there is essentially only 2 pages of more or less random votes from day 1 to go on, i think most votes and reasoning at the moment are completely meaningless and superficial.

[roffman]

hooray for bandwagons. BTW, could people please post whether or not their votes are meaningless or actually post the reasons and thought behind them

[roffman]

vote kaleidoscop

i'm around 90% certain that ergo isn't scum.

[roffman]

it doesn't make kscope scum, i just wanted to stop people voting ergo.

[roffman]

um...question, does anyone have any case against either me or whome?

[roffman]

@scot: my vote kscope was more or less meaningless, i just wanted to vote someone. As for ergo being town, i'm not 100% sure, but i'm relatively certain that he does not have a nightkill ability, therefore i'm pretty sure he is not scum.

[roffman]

yes, softclaims are fun

[roffman]

we're getting close to deadline and i for one would rather see dahill die than whome. therefore:

unvote vote Dahill1

to tie them up again.

[roffman]

atm, i'm happy with lynching dahill. Personally, i don't really mind lynching a vanilla, and if he is not what he claims, then we got ourselves a scum. I also don't think anyone could build a case against anyone else in the time remaining.

[roffman]

may i ask why?

[roffman]

personally, i'm more doubtful that there are 2 cops in this setup. We know Ergo was cop, but WhoMe? has only claimed it. That, and the fact a claimed cop survived the night makes me very suspicious

[roffman]

i understand your reasoning, though i think we should wait for all of WhoMe?'s supposed results before we start the accusation train

[roffman]

vote: chaotic_diablo

[roffman]

i'm relatively certain that WhoMe?'s two investigations are legitimate, though he could quite easily be insane. Just wondering if it is a night ability, did anyone get motivated N1?

[roffman]

i'm willing to accept he is quite possibly insane. However, as of now we have a guilty and innocent result. I propose we lynch the guilty one now, and if that comes up innocent, we know WhoMe? is insane. The fact that

your

pretty sure that the vote isn't reliable is obvious. However, as far as i'm concerned we have have a claimed cop, who got motivated and now has results proving they are not naive. I'm am going to try to lynch the person they claim is guilty.

The only other avenue of exploration i see is that WhoMe? is scum, got motivated, elected

not

to use their second night kill, and is playing a highly elaborate game to get 2 non-scum lynched. Also, they are probably hoping to get motivated again, netting another night kill, and probably making town lose right then and there.

[roffman]

fine, i'm a motivator

[roffman]

ergo and whome

[roffman]

what WhoMe? said is pretty much what i deduced. I wasn't sure ergo wasn't scum, but like i said, i was pretty sure he didn't have a NK that night

[roffman]

As to my having survived the night being suspicious - why? I am a claimed cop, that is likely to attract the attention of a town doc. Even if it turns out we don't have a town doc, scum may have decidied I was likely protected and gone for another target.

I'll bite, why isn't roffman dead then?

You know, i never thought of that. I really can't think of any reason why they went after Ergo instead of a claimed cop and a soft-claimed power role. However, if WhoMe? is scum, got motivated before he decided to kill, then decided that instead of taking out the motivator (which wasn't hard to figure out after you got motivated) he would hit a random using one NK. This way, he can force a mislynch, then hope for another motivation for 2 NK's.

This has also made me suspicous of Tamuz, as WhoMe?, even if he is a legitimate cop, could very well be insane. Other wise he could be trying to broker innocence for his scum buddy.

Until someone else comes up with an idea

unote

[roffman]

i mean

unvote

[roffman]

two things: First, i was 90% sure ergo had no nightkill as we had already had a vig been modkilled. The chance of there being scum, vig and an SK is very, very low.

Secondly, why is the dahill wagon? I cannot recall where dahill's role was revealed, and being the only person still hidden, i'm inclined to think it was a very good wagon

[roffman]

ummm, claimed cop?

[roffman]

if someone says they are a cop, and with nothing else to go on, i thought it would be a good idea to motivate them

[roffman]

cd your posts don't make sense.

If WM? is scum and got motivated but didn't use the second kill how is it that he would have known to reveal double.

If roff is scum and WM? is real then how did WM? get double results

The only possibility is that they are both scum and this is a ballsy as hell gambit.

or we both could be telling the truth

[roffman]

can someone please point me to where dahill is said to be town. I either did a misread, or missed something cause all i can see is role reveal later

[roffman]

ok, thanks for that

[roffman]

vote:chaotic_diablo

like Jdodge said, we only have a day left.

[roffman]

damn, i thought motivating scum would give 2 kills, never thought that scum had another ability. very well played

[roffman]

it really depends. If you know there is a motivator out there, letting a cop claim go uncontested is essentially giving that person a free motivation, possibly 2NK's if they are scum.

[roffman]

gives someone 2 night actions?

[roffman]

i asked, PEG said it gave the ability for 2 night actions