InuYasha Mafia (Game Over)
-
-
AngryIcerink
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
All our posts as Iecerint are listed below for future iso adventures:In post 20, Iecerint wrote:I looked at at the player list and immediately wanted to vote that monstrosity, but now it feels silly.
VOTE: ActionDanIn post 32, Iecerint wrote:Guys let's all vote for ActionDan please thanks.In post 35, Iecerint wrote:
Lost interest at the 4th vote or whatever.In post 33, Nero Cain wrote:I know you are scum iece but help me pl Abomination. You'll be furthering your wincon!In post 45, Iecerint wrote:
Who's counting?In post 37, Nero Cain wrote:
you only had 3 votes on him.In post 35, Iecerint wrote:
Lost interest at the 4th vote or whatever.In post 33, Nero Cain wrote:I know you are scum iece but help me pl Abomination. You'll be furthering your wincon!
and now 5
Well. You, I guess.In post 47, Iecerint wrote:Tbf I suspect that basically all the players in Abomination will flake out and we will deal with at most 2 people in that slot.
I am pretty sketched out by people who thought that reading difficulties would be a legit reason to vote them tbf.
lolsuchhydra is a reason that makes sense to me tho.In post 63, Iecerint wrote:For some reason that post makes me want to lynch Clyton a little.
No idea why, really, because I was curious about the same thing as him.In post 66, Iecerint wrote:Well that is a dumb reason.
I will let you have scummy reasons for wanting to lynch Abomination though because it's you.In post 85, Iecerint wrote:Majiffy can i be town?
I think you are town so that is why I am asking you.In post 98, Iecerint wrote:When I was thinking about Abomination for just a second, it occurred to me that most of them would probably flake or feel like they could rely on hydra-mates to do all the work. This has always been my experience in playing with hydras that start with more than 2 people.
Because that was my take with very minimal introspection, I decided that the particular "let's lynch this due to reading being hard" people were for one reason or another not caring to think about things very carefully (especially in a game that already has a million hydra).In post 379, Iecerint wrote:
Good lord, please at least make an effort.In post 165, Abomination wrote:Whoa, whoa whoa.
Kasuki, you come in here, make 24 posts of ABSOLUTELY FLUFFY NONSENSE over the span of two pages...and WE need to be lynched? Bullshit.
Vote: Kasuki
Bulbathing's post has dichotomies that don't make sense to me.In post 380, Iecerint wrote:Dan is town unless Katsuki is scum.In post 381, Iecerint wrote:
The fact that this is the first post of a hydra head makes me uncomfortable. I think if I were town in a hydra like this I would lurk the fuck out as long as someone else was doing things. If I were scum I would feel like I had to post.In post 208, Abomination wrote:I don't like TSO except for him questioning all that softclaiming.
Has mastin/always doneanythingworthwhile yet?
(this is another head of this hydra checking in )
~MTDIn post 382, Iecerint wrote:
Erm, possible exception is if BE was the one carrying the entire hydra and he left.In post 212, Majiffy wrote:Abom can you explain why BE left? His last few posts seemed town.In post 383, Iecerint wrote:
TownIn post 215, geists wrote:Oh shit you're right. I am mixing Majiffy-posts up with someone else because I thought he was pushing for an Abomination lynch. I have a feeling there's some kind of avatar fusion happening in my head. Rereading some stuff.In post 385, Iecerint wrote:I thought Always was town until I remembered that it was Mastin.In post 386, Iecerint wrote:
I obviously do not support it; however, if someone wants to lynch the hydra just because it is funny to run up the person with 5-8 members or whatever on page 1, I think that's a pretty standard town reaction. I think that because I thought it.Mhork wrote:I'm confused by the 'lolsuchhydra' bit though. I can't actually tell if he supports a policy lynch or not >.<
On the other hand, I think that the "rational" reasons people gave for wanting to lynch the hydra and bullshit. I think they are bullshit because I considered them and decided that they were bullshit with very very minimal effort.In post 388, Iecerint wrote:
Ongoing.In post 350, Egg wrote:I understand Actiondan's Iec vote more than Iec's Actiondan vote.
lolEgg wrote:Iec's post 85 looks like trying too hard to appeal to an influential player (asking Majiffy if he can be town).In post 389, Iecerint wrote:@ mastin xofelf's post about being nervous because a previous game ended badly was kind of scummy I guess, but I explained it away to myself using logic that I can't remember.In post 390, Iecerint wrote:Caught up now.In post 392, Iecerint wrote:Scumhunting.In post 407, Iecerint wrote:Wow, Mastin is bad at this game.In post 411, Iecerint wrote:@ Nati or whoever that was -- I feel like anyone who knows how I play at all should think that I am town right now. I guess this isn't necessarily really true of Mastin, whom I think I've played with exactly once and it was 2009, but I find her combination of vacuity, pomposity, and verbosity grating.
However, people's reads on me have been pretty RNG early game for the last several games I've played I think. There's usually a burst of anti-Iec sentiment sometime either D1 or D2 that never goes anywhere. So I'm trying not to overinterpret it.
I don't play games as frequently anymore, and I think the meta has shifted enough that there's not much correlation between how I perceive how I'm playing in a particular game and how I'm perceived.In post 417, Iecerint wrote:I don't have any read on Clyton at all, really, but I figure he's probably town if that many people are so sure of it.In post 420, Iecerint wrote:OK.In post 426, Iecerint wrote:Don't kill Majiffy. :[In post 431, Iecerint wrote:Also usually when lots of people think someone is town with relatively little controversy ala Clyton that person is usually town. Scum feel awkward dethroning people, especially when the throning is caused by such ambiguous things.
This is also why Dan is probably town unless Katsuki flips scum (i.e., he said he didn't find Katsuki particularly town after 3-4 people called him soso town after his activity burst).In post 432, Iecerint wrote:I think Klick is town too.In post 433, Iecerint wrote:Sakura Hana literally has yet to post, so I dunno what's up with that one.In post 440, Iecerint wrote:Scum can do cheap distancing by voicing vague suspicion or uncertainty on a well-liked scumfriend without intent to follow-up on it. This is the cheapest, freest way to distance ever.
This is why Dan's behavior is no longer town if Katsuki flips scum, as his behavior could be an instance of that if Katsuki flips scum.
Tbh I might have a different take on the dan stuff if I wasn't also kinda not sure what was up with the Katsuki stuff as everyone started to praise it.In post 443, Iecerint wrote:@ Nero -- I'm replying to this:
Though I have to admit that in my head I was responding to Mastin having typed that, but I now see that it was indeed you. I brought up the Dan situation because I know that Mastin didn't really understand my thoughts on Dan earlier, so it would mean something to her and would provide extra context for how this assumption on my part has colored my reads on various players.Nero wrote:I don't agree with this. First, ad populism is stupid and is the 'cause of 95% of all mislynchs. Second, if Clyton is scum but getting town read...why would scum try to dethrone him?In post 444, Iecerint wrote:I am so bad at tense good lord.In post 446, Iecerint wrote:I'm not townreading Katsuki at all. That is part of the point of all of it.In post 448, Iecerint wrote:
Hi Bulba, this is what I was referring to ^In post 126, BulbaFenix wrote:Other scumreads are MDT, Beast, and Venmar. I think at least one of AD/Mhork is likely scum. I also think there is at least 1 scum on the Abomination wagon.
-Bulba
When I read this i was like wtf where does this AD/Mhork foolishness come from. Sounds made-up.
As for my own dichotomies, I unpack them later when Mastin doesn't understand anything and Nero thinks I am wrong but that's the way love goes.In post 451, Iecerint wrote:By the way my slot may transition into a hydra with AngryPidgeon.
We need to choose a name first.In post 453, Iecerint wrote:@ Bulba OK. I was thrown off because you first listed MDT/Beast/Venmar in one set and then listed AD/Mhork in a separate set. I do remember the multiscum discussion, though it doesn't really follow that one of them is scum AFAICT, so that is why that didn't occur to me.In post 492, Iecerint wrote:
I am not reading you as scum, so this is a mistaken impression on your part.In post 486, Venmar wrote:Iecerint, I feel you're being passive aggressive towards me (reading me as scum passively). Why?
My comment about your take on Abomination being scummy but it being OK meant that I did not think it was scummy specifically coming from you.In post 506, Iecerint wrote:Egg is town. No need to discredit the wagon on me otherwise.In post 518, Iecerint wrote:
No, I said Mastin was bad at the game after calling me scum after my series of catch-up posts.In post 508, Venmar wrote:
Oh yeah okay that makes sense, it's just that for some reason I thought you said Mastin was bad at this game for calling me town.In post 492, Iecerint wrote:
I am not reading you as scum, so this is a mistaken impression on your part.In post 486, Venmar wrote:Iecerint, I feel you're being passive aggressive towards me (reading me as scum passively). Why?
My comment about your take on Abomination being scummy but it being OK meant that I did not think it was scummy specifically coming from you.
Way too narcissistic to pay much attention to any other aspect of Mastin's posts given that tbh.-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
Hey mastin. So word on the street is that you are misreading Iecerint. Lets talk about that; because now you are misreading someone who won't handwave you away in frustration. Spill it. You've got like 2 posts to convince me you aren't multi-scum this game (I am correct in stating this is multiball?; for some reason I think it is but UI havent really read).-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
I hold mastin to some amount of BoP. I haven't read much of anything except some very vague description of what happened from Iec.In post 553, Lord Mhork wrote:AP why don't you care if I'm voting you?-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
I just had to be sure of your alignment, mastin, chill. I recalled thinking you were townish for that one opening post and Iec thinks you are too (I think? lol). This response is a little soothing. Apparently I came across differently than I intended to. I told Iec that I thought you were town as I replaced in and he accused me of lying in the post I made because I was hinting you were scum. Not my intention, was merely trying to interject myself into the game as fast as possible . Also I was apparently mistaken that this game is openly multifaction, there was just a post from someone saying it probably was.In post 558, Always wrote:You try pinning your scummy-ass BoP on me, I'm speedlynching you.
<3. I do swear I'm not scum though. Has all this been Natirasha or fferyllt? Actually, I guess I don't care; at first I thought that your recent posts looked town if from ffery, but I think its just town either way in all probability. I also sort of like Y&B on this page.. I need to revisit that a little, but I do like both people involved in the mastin debate. I see passion, I see hard-headedness, I see decent points being made on both sides that would be a bit ... pedantic? (not exactly, but something along those lines) for scum to be making.In post 583, geists wrote:And, the slot became far more dangerous if scum with the addition of AP.
TSO is not someone I think is town after reading the last page. Not scum either. Well ok, maybe a little bit. Everything he is doing is sidelining right now.
P-edit: Dan you are gonna have to be super obvtown for me if you wanna play that card btw.-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
AP and I have already discussed a lot of people and he's done isos and such. It's not true that he hasn't read the thread. I think he's also at least skimmed the first 10 pages or so.In post 635, Egg wrote:
The bolded looks like you've made up your mind that you are going to disagree with Iec's reads. Predetermined reads before reading the thread aren't something town has.AP wrote:I have no idea? I'm probably going to wait until after I've read everythingbefore I try and figure out who we want to compromise on.
So far our views are actually pretty similar from what I can tell, so I don't know what disagreement his compromise language is intended to reference. I suppose I'll find out soon.
Our main difference is that we have different approaches to the game. That's the only thing where syncing might be valuable from my POV. But I suppose I'll get used to it either way.
-Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
^ Oh, I just logged over to comment on that Egg quote.
That is pretty contrived there, Egg. I don't have any jarring disagreements with Iec that I can think of, but the word compromise still is an appropriate word for this situation. "Compromise" does not necessarily imply that there are strong divergences in opinion, rather...that its a joint effort to turn multiple frames of mind into a unified action.-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
Point of regard, can we nip the "No U don't have any content!!" posts in the bud? Seriously it doesn't really lead anywhere relevant. Lurkers will lurk. Some are town. Some aren't. Telling them they are lurking won't make them post more.
P-edit: I might support Nero after I get caught up and depending. What is mastin's read on Nero?-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
I find it very strange that AP posting scummy things makes people think we are town.
Oh brave new world that has such people in it.
AP thought Nero's page 2 stuff was pretty unnatural almost immediately upon replacing in, particularly re: Abomination. I found his list ala what abom just mentioned above had funky people on it, but I have some irrational affection for Nero, so I don't like lynching him til later. /iecnerofeelings
-Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
Venmar, mastin, your slot, off the top of my head.In post 664, geists wrote:
Who are you referring to?In post 661, AngryIcerink wrote:I find it very strange that AP posting scummy things makes people think we are town.
Oh brave new world that has such people in it.-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
You are on the right track as-is.In post 683, geists wrote:Someone talk me through where I should be looking.
Because I'm looking at Rhaego.-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
Nero, posting scummy things and then having people get town reads on you only works if you are us.In post 703, Nero Cain wrote:'cause its a 28 player game so there's going to be a butt load of scum and there's no traction for lynching abomination but just LOOK at Shos and he's really doing nothing. Why do you have a town read on him?
Unvote; Vote: Nero Cain
I'm going to assume that AP would be fine with this for right now. We may alter things after we touch base.
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
Yes, nothing is a surefire lolomng scumtell. Town is capable of doing things that scum often do. In this case, I think it was scummy because you went out of your way to bring up Another Awesome Alliteration Adventure for no real reason. Instead of trying to figure out what Egg was seeing about you that felt weird, you throw up some scum meta and imply that you must be town here because of Egg's feeling. Which makes it scummy. Also your defense that town is also capable of saying this is scummy and kind of stripping the context away and focusing on defending the case on you.In post 733, T S O wrote:"Subtly implying you're Town, scum!" is terrible. I can quote at least 10 examples where I've seen town say it.
\o/
~Kazooie-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
The only overreaction I see is you ignoring SG's main point (it was odd that you didn't acknowledge Abom when Iec asked you who was scum on your wagon) and misrepping the rest of her post by use of the word 'impossible'.In post 761, Nero Cain wrote:overreaction....-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
In the post I quoted you literally said that you unvoted Abomination because you couldn't get him lynched and you switched to shos because you were lurker hunting.
Tbf I more voted you because of the stuff AP and I had already discussed (your early push for Abomination, questionable reads and pushes in general), but that post was so egregious that I couldn't help myself. (I had been in favor of holding off on any push on you today before that on the belief that you would be hard to lynch and that you were such a cutie, so I figured he wouldn't object if I went ahead and voted you.)
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
And I was asking if you were talking about me as the "scum who loves trying to mislynch you." I didn't think you had a scumread on us at the time particularly, so I was even more O.o at the quick turnaround. But your iso does have bits where you had suspected me, so I suppose they just didn't stand out to me, probably because you engaged with me throughout the early game, which come to think of it is relatively consistent with you being scum and knowing my alignment (vs. actually thinking I am scum).-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
That is literally what you said. You are embarrassed scum or have extremely poor language skills.
1. Your stated rationale for no longer voted for Abomination is that there's "no traction" for lynching him -- nevermind that that in no way makes him more likely to be town.In post 703, Nero Cain wrote:'cause its a 28 player game so there's going to be a butt load of scum and there's no traction for lynching abomination but just LOOK at Shos and he's really doing nothing. Why do you have a town read on him?
2. Your emotional appeal to lynching Shos is that Shos has "really do[ne] nothing" and OMG YOU MUST HAVE A TOWN READ ON HIM IF YOU DONT' WANT TO LYNCH THIS DO-NOTHINGER [AKA LURKER]
I mean I [departing from AP, who was more meh] had more of a scumread on Shos anyway and I found this bad.
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
Other people can judge whether AP really "blatantly misrepresented" you. I requoted everything.
You are correct that sometimes it is OK to not vote a scumread simply because they are unlikely to be lynched. This is why I didn't really want to push you, after all. You are also correct that sometimes scum can active-lurk, though that isn't actually what you accused shos of, even if that was your intent. Though even if you had done that/did intend to do that, it reads like you're indicating behaviors rather than alignments. Like, THIS MAN VIOLATED THE LAWS OF PLAYING MAFIA GOOD. LET'S LYNCH HIM! vs. LET'S LYNCH THIS PERSON WHO IS SCUM DUE TO X.
I had/have scummy feelings from Shos because I've only played one game with him before, and IIRC he was scum and pretty similar to this. I don't remember the game, though; I only remember because I recognize his avatar. Nice deflection. :p
I'm wary of voting/lynching shos mainly because his wagon was disproportionately easy.
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
You are scummy for indicating "basically doing nothing" as the reason for voting him. That is a scummy reason to select a target to vote (or at best a very poor way to express yourself). Full stop.
Your decision to recontextualize this as active lurker hunting -- subsequent to taking exception to being called a lurker hunter, which makes me pretty skeptical that your original reasoning was as you now claim -- is just that.
I think town Nero or town anyone would have a different reaction to this kind of pressure. You would still take exception to being scrutinized like any normal person, but you would also acknowledge that your language is absolutely inviting an interpretation at odds with how you're claiming you're intending it.
I have already indicated that the difference between Shos and others today is that Shos's wagon was very low-resistance, which is correlated with a town alignment. You know -- basically, the opposite of the reason you unvoted Abomination. EDIT: You even explicitly indicate that you understand the difference. Please attempt to deflect to Shos more, btw.
PS: Please never say "multiball" ever again good lord. (Yes, I'm aware that AP used it earlier.) But it doesn't really change things if present, as there would still be half as many scum opposed to scum.
lol @ "yelling and screaming"
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
I think you're voting for shos because you think he is mislynch bait based upon how you responded when you were asked about it. That's what I find scummy.
OK @ the second/third. It sounds like you think that scum are different from townies in that they vote for scum more than town do, which I find to be a little bit bogus! But OK!
Contrary to how you characterized it, the Abomination wagon actually had plenty of traction up until several pages in. By then I had a little bit of a town read on Abomination already, due in part to the number of sketchy people pushing his wagon. But I know AP has a scum read on Abomination for some reason, I think because he thinks your interaction with him on page 2 was suggestive of early distancing (i.e., because the wagon was so dumb that it would obviously dissipate). But I think it's on the unlikely case and not worth considering until several days from now.
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
1. I am showing the scumNero interpretation of your words to make my perspective as clear as possible, though, since you feigned not being able to understand why I found it scummy in your previous post. It goes without saying that I think the scumNero interpretation is valid.
2. You attempted to argue that because the Abomination wagon had poor traction, by my logic, he would be more likely to be scum. (Again, a super curious deflection, and an irrelevant one, as lack of consistency, even if applicable here, isn't a scumtell, blahblah etc.) My response explained why his wagon was different -- there was great traction that dissipated, which is very different from the converse of Shos's wagon.
3. I explained why I didn't vote for Abomination at the start in literally my very first post in this game. It's basically the same reason as I've just articulated above.
4. I already addressed the Shos thing multiple times and I will not repeat myself. Please rephrase the question if I am somehow answering a different one.
5. @789, for the first sentence, thinking someone is town has nothing to do with mislynches. So that part sentence is kind of non sequitur and irrelevant to what I am talking about. For the second sentence, that is the perfect time to distance, as it is distancing that will be forgotten until isos come into play late game. Distancing doesn't entail "dethroning;" it just means something like the AD->Katsuki interaction I explained earlier.
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
@ NC - No, I think that AD is town unless Kat is scum, in which case AD may or may not have been distancing from Kat (hence the word "unless"). This was clearly articulated.
I do not think Abomination is scum. AP does, though, so I can understand this point being confusing for you, which is why I spelled out that AP was the one who had this thought and that I did not think it very plausible in a previous post to you.
We may be using the word "traction" differently. What I mean is that the wagon was extremely comfortable to people early on and it got uncharacteristically big pretty quickly (similar to shos's wagon, but much quicker). This sort of comfort-wagon occurs more often on town I think.
Clyton and AD-Kat are different things. They're only similar in that Clyton and Kats both had lots of posts that made players reflect on their townieness afterward. I think they were linked together in my mind because I used one case to contextualize my thinking about the other at some point a long time ago -- I think with mastin maybe.
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
I don't have any thoughts, really, but literally the first two things AP texted me when he started reading the thread were "lol nero is so scum" and "i can tell that clyton is town from just like two posts." (At least, those were the first things he said that I hadn't already said to him first.)
I had in the back of my mind to evaluate Clyton because I didn't have a read and everyone thought he was town so I figured he probably was, but wanted to confirm, etc.; but I never went back to look into it again after AP seemed so sure about it.
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
Having just read Clyton (lol), yeah, I guess people just found the second post townie. It's kind of shocking how glowing the town praise was, though. No wonder I noticed that he didn't stand out to me like he did to other people. ^^;In post 816, AngryIcerink wrote:I don't have any thoughts, really, but literally the first two things AP texted me when he started reading the thread were "lol nero is so scum" and "i can tell that clyton is town from just like two posts." (At least, those were the first things he said that I hadn't already said to him first.)
I had in the back of my mind to evaluate Clyton because I didn't have a read and everyone thought he was town so I figured he probably was, but wanted to confirm, etc.; but I never went back to look into it again after AP seemed so sure about it.
- Iec
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
I understand why you think this (I think). I also think you wouldn't feel the same if you considered the entirety of what we've done.In post 852, ProHawk wrote:Read where AngryPidgeon come in and how he interacts with Mastin.
Why is your read on Nero whatever it is?
Also, Rhaego, really? Skimpy posts isn't a scum tell.-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
FWIW, I totally facepalmed when AP replaced in and did that and can understand why anyone would find it objectionable. To me it looked way disproportionately defensive at pressure from a player whose posts people will mostly not read.In post 852, ProHawk wrote:Read where AngryPidgeon come in and how he interacts with Mastin.
Apparently, AP likes to engage Mastin near the start of the game and get an idea of her alignment that way in all the games they play together.
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
@Egg, will have to agree to disagree. I thought that post was so terrible that it overwrote my thinking that Nero was not a wise push even if somewhat scummy.
I would like to emphasize that part of it is how he expressed the idea rather than the idea itself. The idea that you would apply pressure somewhere new or supplement existing pressure to make it do something where you had suspicion is fine, but his language was really just egregious. YMMV I suppose.
I think it's relevant because scum and town can take the same kind of action for different reasons, and language can be relevant to the actual reasons for why they do whatever.
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
The only undead person I know of in the flavor is Kikyo, though I don't know the flavor very well. I don't think Kikyo really has enough people associated with her to make a scumteam, and she's as likely to be neutral or town as scum I think.
I point this out because it may be that the undead stuff may be a characteristic of particular players regardless of alignment. Or there may be an undead faction I'm not familiar with in the flavor.
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
You would naturally tend to say "one scumteam" or "the scumteam" rather than "other scumteam." Town shos had to read AD's inference and believe it and trust in it and refer back to it without and explicit re-reference 20+ pages later.
In other words, he never made a reference to the Naraku team in the vicinity of saying "other scumteam," so I think it's less likely that he was contrasting waaaaay back to AD's claim.
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
Nothing you've described here makes Rhaego likely scum; it makes him a lurker who replaced out. Who else is scum?In post 950, beastcharizard wrote:This is why I think Rhaego is scum.
Fascinating. I can't believe you are trying to pass a townread on Iec with "he thinks like I do" and then also talk about how you dislike me but not enough for that to swithc your read. Welcome to the special position of "Undesirable #1" on my shortlist. That isn't natural thinking; that is a fabricated read made to look like natural thinking. Klick was scum; you are scum.In post 952, HighShroomish wrote:Also I'm 100% sure we have a cop.
Wrong. Shos is being open and honest. Hes town, leave him alone. Can I interest you in High Shroomish or Mist?In post 955, Majiffy wrote:this is not the reasoning of someone with a legitimately town inuyasha role pm. You shouldnt have to imo your alignment. Shos doesnt believe his own claim.
This is pretty much the definition of active lurking.In post 958, Venmar wrote:Can confirm, made Walter White a fake claim in Breaking Bad Mafia, and a lot of Main-ish characters in TWD Mafia.
Still cheeky and scum.In post 963, HighShroomish wrote:No. It's a 27-Shot Vig unlimited BP Unlychable claim.
No it doesn't, its a very good inquiry into beastcharizards really bad tunnel on someone who probably isn't scum.In post 968, Birds of Prey wrote:If Rhaego is scum, so is Egg for this post. It subtly says only the worst offender at a particular transgression can be scum and searches for another player to make worse than Rhaego.
This post gives me mixed emotions. Let me think about what this means for my desire to lynch you.In post 970, HighShroomish wrote:No, it doesn't explicitly say Miller but I'm a town-aligned Demon, so I'm pretty sure that means I'm a miller.
I didn't claim in my first post because the whole miller thing didn't register at first but then I realized it and was like holy fuck I'm a miller.
Wow. You are just looking for any excuse to scumread mastin and it stinks.In post 1009, T S O wrote:but if it's a hydra, why is it inactive?
A) He said it because he has reason to believe that flavor name is in the game and he sucks at phrasing things. The end. Hes actually town for it.In post 1017, Lord Mhork wrote:Guys. SHOS SAID OTHER SCUM TEAM.
Until someone can come up with a plausible reason why A) he said that and B) he has refused to acknowledge that, he's basically confirmed scum in my eyes.
You are the hero this thread deserves. But not the one it needs right now.In post 1025, ActionDan wrote:w/e. it's so spurious. I'd say 'other scumteam' anytime I'd have mentally pictured a standard scumteam, no less a scumteam containing naraku in it, the main villain. meaning I could say 'other scumteam' whenever I damn well please.
~AP-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
My guess is that he doesn't feel comfortable changing the vote without talking to me first. I know that as of a few days ago (via a phone call on the 4th actually) his position was that you were scum who legitimately believed we were otherscum. So I could imagine him kind of rotating into thinking about other things to vote (i.e., NeroScum -> NeroScumScumhunting -> NeroTown?!).In post 1034, Nero Cain wrote:
Why would you want to interest someone in a wagon that you aren't on?In post 1030, AngryIcerink wrote:Wrong. Shos is being open and honest. Hes town, leave him alone.Can I interest you in High Shroomish or Mist?
But we've only talked about Shos today. He basically said he's very sure Shos is town and will let me be angry at him if he is wrong.
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
1. Why not? I have some limited insight into AP's thoughts because we text/talk daily and talk about this game sometimes. No reason not to clarify when I have context.In post 1040, Nero Cain wrote:Could be. Just idk....you're town and you have your vote sitting on your #1 pick as scum...so you (your slot) think the #1 wagon is a mislynch but doesn't sell his #1 scumread? But the last he told you that he thinks I'm scum so I don't really get why he'd "start thinking about other things"
But here's a question to you, obviously 1030 was written by AP and you don't know AP's thoughts...why do you feel the need to respond instead of just waiting for him to reply or for him to tell you what he was doing?
2. Tbf AP sometimes has a posting style that I would find scummy if I were naive to our alignment. He was annoyed at Egg, for example, and thought his posts were disingenuous, but I would probably have raised an eyebrow at some of the same things that Egg did.
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
I think Majiffy is town for the negative town utility claim; AP may have a different perspective.In post 1047, shos wrote:Iec+AP, what do you think of majiffy and neros push. Is it worthy of a scumread? I already haveone on NC but maybe maj is tickling kagome with a sword too.
FWIW Majiffy likes to find perceived slips and stick to them when town. He did this in Teen Wolf mafia relatively recently, where I was scum and he caught a scumfriend with reasoning that I found bogus, but he stuck with it through like 3-4 days of content. I don't know whether he does this as scum, too. I know I'm more likely to do it as scum personally (cf., Dynasty Warriors mafia), but that's just me.
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
Thanks! I am sure your poisonproofness will now be a huge help!In post 1077, beastcharizard wrote:I am town human unpoisonable townie. I can do flavor too if you would like but that doesn't actually matter. This means that there is a way to poison in this game. This might be the way to kill in this game which would be the weird mechanic.
- Iec-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
^ Yes, Xofelf is scummy. I dislike her posts about Abomination. In particular, I disliked her saying they 'could possibly be town'. I mean, everyone could possibly be town. It was such a weird defense because it wasn't very forceful; it looks protown for the sake of being protown imo. I don't really see anything in her posts that look like shes pursuing things that will help her solve the game or that she thinks are interesting.-
-
AngryIcerink Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 268
- Joined: July 1, 2014
-
-
-
-