InuYasha Mafia (Game Over)

[Always]

The last tubes we've played she was scum both, called me scum as town, and I read her correctly.

I played Star Wars.
We were both town.
This doesn't feel like the same you from that game.
To put it in simplest terms, the Lord Mhork I've come to expect as town is logic with a touch of emotions;
The Mhork I'm seeing looks like emotions with a touch of logic, if that makes sense.
Gut-reaction, of course, but I described you as I did for a rather specific reason.

I got this. Mastin why the 'I wanna be scum. Damn I'm town' act?

No act.
I wanted scum.
I got the role that is just about as far away from scum as can be.
(/not-remotely-subtle-softclaim.)

[Lord Mhork]

Star Wars doesn't count. I was killed night one. ._.
Also I'm good at scum hunting. I promise <3

Psh mhork is all emotions all day errday, except when I try really hard to put things in logic. But then, logic don't have a place in mafia, now does it?

[Klick]

I agree with, like, three of those.

I'm certainly no scumhunting god, even though I happen to think I'm more right than wrong, but could you tell me which ones you agree/disagree with and if you can, why?

Well, to start, I'm voting for one of your town-reads.

I think xof's probably scum. kdowns could be scum. Other than that, either I'm still null on everyone you've mentioned, or I have an opposite read. In particular, Iece is probably town, and Abomination is scum.

[xofelf]

How am I probably scum, Kleeck?
I know you aren't all that great at giving words to your reads, but try would you?

[Majiffy]

you should really be getting that clarified.

When I can. It might be a while.

Also your hydra needs an avatar.

Also also your read on Nero Cain is poop. He looks like scum.
VOTE: Nero Cain
Join me.

[Majiffy]

I like Klick for town.

[beastcharizard]

VOTE: Nero Cain
Join Beast with me.

FTFY

Why do you think Nero is scum?

[Majiffy]

Same post you pointed out. Although I never actually saw you point it out until I saw Always highlight it.

You need a more eye-catching avatar, I think.

[Venmar]

beast why are you voting nero exactly?

[ActionDan]

Town.
Just...town.

I dunno, the herp is strong here.

At least if you somehow turn out to be scum than he'll be not your faction (of which there are 2 btw. fyi.)

[Iecerint]

Majiffy can i be town?

I think you are town so that is why I am asking you.

[beastcharizard]

Same post you pointed out. Although I never actually saw you point it out until I saw Always highlight it.

You need a more eye-catching avatar, I think.

Charizard is eye catching.

beast why are you voting nero exactly?

Because he just said that someone was scum and that lynching obomination would further their wincon. It was pretty obvious since I quoted the post and gave my reason.

[Always]

At least if you somehow turn out to be scum than he'll be not your faction (of which there are 2 btw. fyi.)

You mean even if I WAS scum I'd have to deal with multiscum BS?!?
(Actually, I love being scum in multiball.
Buuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuut,
What I really need to say is this. Normally, I'd just leave this comment as be. But it's actually

really, REALLY important

that I get an answer from you, Dan, if this is confirmed knowledge or just speculation. It makes a huge difference in something that could be a massive advantage to the town, but I need to know for sure.)

I like Klick for town.

That goes without saying.

Also also your read on Nero Cain is poop. He looks like scum.

It's not impossible, but I have a fairly-decent track record for reading Nero. It's too early to tell one way or the other, so you could be right, but what I do see does vaguely point to town. Soooooooooooooo, best answer I can give ya there is "maybe later; talk to me when there's more". (Basically, I'm not exactly inclined to sheep things right now. I'm more of a predator.)

How am I probably scum, Kleeck?
I know you aren't all that great at giving words to your reads, but try would you?

Screw it, Iece's posting might convince me to move back, but...
VOTE: xofelf.
Can't not-vote this.

[beastcharizard]

What? How is Nero's post that I quoted town motivated?

[Klick]

How am I probably scum, Kleeck?
I know you aren't all that great at giving words to your reads, but try would you?

Thought I answered this, sorry. The main thing is that I don't like your early defense of Abomination. I don't think anyone here is dumb enough to actually go through with an Abomination PL Day 1, but you seemed to be seriously defending them. It feels like either a chainsaw defense or white-knighting (and I'm leaning the former).

[shos]

Inuyasha with Tessaiga!!! lovely; this raises so many long lost memories.
I am pretttttty sure this can be an awesome game
The theme won't quite help us differentiate between alignments and roles though~ unless of course something really obvious comes like Kagome who *truly* can't be scum -_-;

anyway, haven't read anything yet. tomorrow, or after the weekend(ends on Sat for me). nighty!

[xofelf]

How am I probably scum, Kleeck?
I know you aren't all that great at giving words to your reads, but try would you?

Thought I answered this, sorry. The main thing is that I don't like your early defense of Abomination. I don't think anyone here is dumb enough to actually go through with an Abomination PL Day 1, but you seemed to be seriously defending them. It feels like either a chainsaw defense or white-knighting (and I'm leaning the former).

I guess I didn't see it as defense so much as it seemed like people were serious about voting them, and that's really stupid. Yes I'm excited to play with some of the people in that hydra, but if they're scum then sure lynch them.
What do you mean by chainsaw defense? I'm unfamiliar with that term.

[Nero Cain]

vote:Clyton

[Klick]

Ah, okay. False alarm, xof's town.

I screwed up the meaning of that apparently after looking at it on the Wiki. Chainsaw defense is defending your scum buddy by attacking the person who attacked them. But that's not really what I meant to say, it was more of just defending a buddy in general.

[Always]

you should really be getting that clarified.

When I can. It might be a while.

Also your hydra needs an avatar.

Also also your read on Nero Cain is poop. He looks like scum.
VOTE: Nero Cain
Join me.

ARE YOU HAPPY NOA JIFFY?

<3

[Nero Cain]

I screwed up the meaning of that apparently after looking at it on the Wiki. Chainsaw defense is defending your scum buddy by attacking the person who attacked them. But that's not really what I meant to say, it was more of just defending a buddy in general.

scum defend town all the time, imo that's just as much as a "chainsaw" as the traditional meaning.

[ActionDan]

What I really need to say is this. Normally, I'd just leave this comment as be. But it's actually really, REALLY important that I get an answer from you, Dan, if this is confirmed knowledge or just speculation. It makes a huge difference in something that could be a massive advantage to the town, but I need to know for sure.)

Well if it's important to you Mastin-sama:

A 28 player game would suggest two factions or more since a 7p scum team in a 28 player base is rather unwieldy imo, but it happens to be the case that I have role info that very much suggests two factions. You should work with that assumption.

[Nero Cain]

I think scum like to defend policy lynchee's for cheap town cred, so I'd bet big money on there being a scummer or two in the "don't lynch abomination!" camp.

Also Jiffy's shepping of Beast is super scummy.

[Iecerint]

When I was thinking about Abomination for just a second, it occurred to me that most of them would probably flake or feel like they could rely on hydra-mates to do all the work. This has always been my experience in playing with hydras that start with more than 2 people.

Because that was my take with very minimal introspection, I decided that the particular "let's lynch this due to reading being hard" people were for one reason or another not caring to think about things very carefully (especially in a game that already has a million hydra).

[ActionDan]

Unvote; Vote: kdowns

I see you have folded.

Don't mess with the best.