In post 1022, Thor665 wrote:In post 1012, PeregrineV wrote:I therefore conclude thatpart of your case on my is me calling you out for saying multiball is a safe assumption.
Is this conclusion inccorect?
No, I would agree that you calling me out is part of my case on you - I have said so on numerous occasions.
In post 1012, PeregrineV wrote:I think I said, should there be 2 scumteams, I will be pushing strongly for a Thor lynch. Given that 25% of 21-player large games have 2 scumteams, it seems the single-scum reponse would be to ignore or say "good luck with that" and the town response would be to ignore or say "good luck with that."
What I did not expect was "Well they said it it too!" defense.
Axle done detailed it, there is a difference in how it was said in in the context and conviction.
Which takes me back to , "if there are 2 scumteams, I'llbe looking at Thor."
It's actually setting a future condition which may or may not come true, and was but a single read of 20 other players.
This fails, yet again, to actually justify the tell nor to justify how what I did qualifies it as a tell and is not an explanation of the tell.
Though I will admit you did expand somewhat into 'Thor reacting negatively to a unexplained and nonsensical case equates to him being scummier' which *is* something new, but is also nothing about the original tell.
In post 1012, PeregrineV wrote:Considering I have little idea on where you stand on the other 19 players, you could be not-lazy and tell us who is scum with me.
Aeronaut - lurksack
Boonskiies - lurksack, begrudingly shifting to town due to Dave, but still a useless slot.
Cho - Lurksack.
GrayFoxxxx - Lurksack.
Egg - Townish
hephaestus - burning newb - no real vibe yet, still trying to even get him to commit to opinions.
Scripten - I can remember having an opinion on him but can't recall what it is. If I was asked about him I'd ISO myself and repeat whatever I said last (townish?)
TobyLoby - Lurksack.
I want to talk about these.
Aeronaut- Yes. Not sure if alt or hydra or neither, but admittedly higher expectations
Boon- How does Dave make Boon more town?
Cho- what about early content as opposed to current lurking?
Grayfoxx- What did you think about Csar?
Egg- Is that more for in-thread play or the neighborhood posting?
hephaestus- to my memory he has like 5 posts. Why is he not a lurkersack?
Scripten- Yes, my Scripten vote caused the PeregrineV vote. You townread him because:
Considering the quality and content level of his other 26 posts, it really feels like your reaching to give a townread on him. Because it seems based on 362, which has not been repeated, reiterated, investigated, etc. since that post.In post 376, Thor665 wrote:My read on him is more one of gut and 'I agree with that' but I like how he singled out Tier as looking town and didn't mention GM - which is where I'm at and feels a logical town place to be rather than a scum looking to toss out some easy town reads.
TobyLoby- had some posting before lurk/replace. Thoughts based on those posts?