Because for a while I was
Yet the action from you seems to be that of confidence, and an attitude of "It will get better! Just hold your breath and close your eyes and count to twenty and we'll get those darned metascum!" And then you seem to lurk, and pop up to say "yeah, I'm not quite sure how to win this game" Obviously this is an exaggeration, but it appeared quite strange. You seem to connect the two easily, but reading the thread, I'm having a hard time seeing this flow.
Got it now: PookyTheMagicalBear, Max, kabenon007, ryan, Fiasco, Sammich, Xdaamno, Sarcastro, Adele
Yeah, I disagree on every count with this list. I'm serious, nobody seems to be in the right spot here. Why put Fiasco at number 5? Did you seriously think Sammich was the 6th person in terms of scumminess on your list?
Basically, I cannot believe anybody thought Pooky was the most scummish person, and kabs and ryan look very town to me. And I'm even more surprised you wouldn't compromise and say "well, pooky's scum, but if he's not, he could be right with his theory." You had no exposure to sarc; the only info to go on him was Pooky's theory.