In post 627, Loopdan wrote:So you have no defense against my allegation that you've misconstrued my posts on this topic?
Other than the one I stated - no.
Because there isn't any misrepping.
In post 627, Loopdan wrote:I already answered your attempt to throw this back at me in post 393. I'm not writing a wall to defend the diversity of my reads on you. Anybody following the game can see I have been open to the possibility of town!Thor. I don't think the same can be said for your consideration of town!Loopdan. You can try another angle of attack on 390, but ultimately that's what this comes down to.
I don't know if everyone is like you in non-newbie games Paladin, and if I am being too pushy with asking people to lay out their reads, but I don't like your latest post. What's the problem with showing what's your stance on everything?
I understood that you are townreading Loop, not scumreading Thor and scumreading Missy. Did I miss anything?
I get that, and people have different opinions on how complete to be about given information. Mine is that if everyone gives a full ranking in the early game, scum know exactly whom to kill, and generally how to position themselves relative to others. I don't think PoE on townreads works well early in the game.
What you are saying makes sense. But I am paranoid about something else - how would the two scumpartners read each other early on? Townreading and scumreading themselves both carry risks, while nullreading each other - or even better - not reading each other at all is really safe. It doesn't let us make any associations when one of them flips. I hope that you are understanding my reasoning for suspecting Shadow because of that. And for the exact same reason, I am also suspecting you.
In post 578, Harkonnen97 wrote:If there aren't enough supporters for a Shadow lynch I'm moving to Thor.
I much prefer Shadow to Thor, but I'm still hoping for a LoopDan.
In post 584, Loopdan wrote:Just to be clear on my position: Lucca flaking out is not what I find scummy. What I found scummy were his early interactions in the part of the game when he was actively posting that looks different from his other (town) game, where he was engaged and analytical.
Which of his 10 posts were disengaged and lacking analysis up until the Sunday where he stopped and later got replaced for inactivity?
In post 659, Harkonnen97 wrote:What you are saying makes sense. But I am paranoid about something else - how would the two scumpartners read each other early on? Townreading and scumreading themselves both carry risks, while nullreading each other - or even better - not reading each other at all is really safe. It doesn't let us make any associations when one of them flips. I hope that you are understanding my reasoning for suspecting Shadow because of that. And for the exact same reason, I am also suspecting you.
Let me tell you something, this game doesn't revolve around you.
You don't tell us what optimal town play is.
You're a noob, behave like one xD
In post 578, Harkonnen97 wrote:If there aren't enough supporters for a Shadow lynch I'm moving to Thor.
I much prefer Shadow to Thor, but I'm still hoping for a LoopDan.
In post 584, Loopdan wrote:Just to be clear on my position: Lucca flaking out is not what I find scummy. What I found scummy were his early interactions in the part of the game when he was actively posting that looks different from his other (town) game, where he was engaged and analytical.
Which of his 10 posts were disengaged and lacking analysis up until the Sunday where he stopped and later got replaced for inactivity?
Serious question: You can make a meta-case based on one other game?
Dafuq what ?
When did you start scum reading me ?
Penguin and MT scum team.
I don't...you're null to me right now, but I much prefer you to Thor. That's exactly what I said. And, I much prefer LoopDan over you, hence why my vote is still on him.
I think the only truly valid point was 2. in post http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 5#p8129755. The other three are believably newbtown behaviors from my pov. Your points after that are just hard tunneling and stating people need to vote MT. So...yeah. She's a lean town for me, but not a strong one.
