any reason you jumped on the bandwagon without commenting?
ChronX wrote:unvote
vote Mr. Pigg
I had too, you would have lynched him...hell, if I didnt know he was a mason I would have voted for him. we are against a wall and I knew there was no time to either a.) convince this town to vote for someone else or b.) convince you he was town.Sonicpulsar wrote:I'm not entirely sure I've ever read or participated in a game where a power role blatantly claimed on Day 1. I'll have to analyze the implications to the game (which is different than what I'm experienced in due to the "speed" factor). Overall, I'm a sad panda. Seems like we (read: CKD) has set up the first couple of NKs for the mafia.
For now, remember LAL.
Unvote
I'm curious why you think we'll have a strong night game. Could you please elaborate?Atticus wrote:I think we are likely to have a strong night game. Speed robs the town of information. Deadlines are good for scum, not town. However, I do not think no lynching is a good idea.
I just wanted to repost this so it wouldn't get lost in all the craziness. BM, your analysis of d3sisted did not contain any mention of his purposely going silent right before the deadline when he was a potential lynchee and was going out of town. To me, his blatant avoidance was the single scummiest thing I've seen from anyone in this game so far. BM, since you excluded that from your analysis I'm guessing you disagree with me, so I'd like to hear your take on his actions.Hang 'em High wrote:@Battle Mage: What do you think of d3sisted going silent when he received 3 votes?
hey maybe Pigg and I will be lucky and the mafia will just pass right over us Night 1....remember mafia, there is nothing sketcher than a mason claim not followed up by a night kill...Hang 'em High wrote:
As for the Mason claim, the big question is whether or not we believe it. I'm leaning toward "yes", since I don't see why CKD would make the claim if it wasn't true. The only reason I could see him lying was if he and Mr.PiGG were both scum and he was trying to save Piggy's neck. But if they were scum together I think it would be a bad play for CKD to tie himself to Mr.PiGG -- I think he would be more inclined to bus his buddy. For now I'm going under the assumption that the claim is legit.
I wrestled through this exact thing last night, also. My thought was that CKD would be crazy to totally expose himself. Without a doctor (probably), it would be straightforward to assume that one of them would be NK'd after that, and if they were both scum, neither would be. The focus of tomorrow would return to them and then when one was lynched, the other would be an EASY play for the following day. I can't see it as worth it.Hang 'em High wrote:As for the Mason claim, the big question is whether or not we believe it. I'm leaning toward "yes", since I don't see why CKD would make the claim if it wasn't true. The only reason I could see him lying was if he and Mr.PiGG were both scum and he was trying to save Piggy's neck. But if they were scum together I think it would be a bad play for CKD to tie himself to Mr.PiGG -- I think he would be more inclined to bus his buddy. For now I'm going under the assumption that the claim is legit.
And I'll be posting from work for the next 8. Then I'll check again a few hours later from home. No worries, eh?curiouskarmadog wrote:well you got less than 24 hours to do sodistad wrote:I have to spend some time on this.
I understand CKD's comment/vote on ChronX. I still think d3 is the play for today (in my best JDodge impression), but I have to sit and think for a bit.
you have to agree, distad. I feel that if someone claims mason and he or his mason buddy were not NK then much suspicion should be placed on them Day 2.distad wrote:Guh!curiouskarmadog wrote: hey maybe Pigg and I will be lucky and the mafia will just pass right over us Night 1....remember mafia, there is nothing sketcher than a mason claim not followed up by a night kill...
I have GOT to read all of the new posts before I respond to one!
How does everyone feel about CKD's claim after this gem of a post?distad wrote:Guh!curiouskarmadog wrote: hey maybe Pigg and I will be lucky and the mafia will just pass right over us Night 1....remember mafia, there is nothing sketcher than a mason claim not followed up by a night kill...
I have GOT to read all of the new posts before I respond to one!
I dislike this post. It makes it look like your claim was part of a mafia gambit and you're laying the groundwork for a WIFOM discussion if you aren't NKed tonight. At the very least you're giving ideas to the mafia. Granted this is a pretty obvious tactic but at least make them do their own work. Yucky.curiouskarmadog wrote:hey maybe Pigg and I will be lucky and the mafia will just pass right over us Night 1....remember mafia, there is nothing sketcher than a mason claim not followed up by a night kill...
so let me get this straight?ChronX wrote:How does everyone feel about CKD's claim after this gem of a post?distad wrote:Guh!curiouskarmadog wrote: hey maybe Pigg and I will be lucky and the mafia will just pass right over us Night 1....remember mafia, there is nothing sketcher than a mason claim not followed up by a night kill...
I have GOT to read all of the new posts before I respond to one!
I'll leave my vote on Pigg. Did it really need to be explained? We were looking to wagon an absentee and Pigg showed up and, as Atticus said very well immediately before my post, casually voted D3sisted.
Sorry, CKD, that I didn't feel the need to say "parroting what the three posters ahead of me said".
(rolling eyes)..jesus, I hoped the town would understand why I posted this...Hang 'em High wrote:I dislike this post. It makes it look like your claim was part of a mafia gambit and you're laying the groundwork for a WIFOM discussion if you aren't NKed tonight. At the very least you're giving ideas to the mafia. Granted this is a pretty obvious tactic but at least make them do their own work. Yucky.curiouskarmadog wrote:hey maybe Pigg and I will be lucky and the mafia will just pass right over us Night 1....remember mafia, there is nothing sketcher than a mason claim not followed up by a night kill...
Anyone town would think that you are setting up a WIFOM argument if neither of you are killed tonight. That's what I think.curiouskarmadog wrote:I think anyone town would understand what I am doing when I posted that "gem"...interesting your perspective on this game pervents that...
my vote on you is a good one.
your lack fo game tactics and/or scumminess is astounding.ChronX wrote:Anyone town would think that you are setting up a WIFOM argument if neither of you are killed tonight. That's what I think.curiouskarmadog wrote:I think anyone town would understand what I am doing when I posted that "gem"...interesting your perspective on this game pervents that...
my vote on you is a good one.
In a small game, a false claim (like yours appears to be) is gold if you can sell it to the town.