With someone removed, how do you want us to do it? 1-11 with them totally removed or?
---
Once I get that cleared up, yea, I'm shoving the hacker to the back of the line.
Max's post does all those things that are just awesome.
Remove them please!SpyreX wrote:@Mod:
With someone removed, how do you want us to do it? 1-11 with them totally removed or?
Excuse me if I assumed someone who looks incredibly desperate to prove they are town was scum. You know, since scumfarside22 wrote:Shove
1. UncertainKitten 11
2. Minineko 9
3. Ellibereth 6
4. Jahudo 4
5. SpyreX 3
6. Max 2
7. farside22 1
8. HackerHuck 11
9. Super Awesome Mega Pimp! 9
10. Cobalt 8
12. Grimmy 5
I'm going back to uncertain kitten who was flipping out when pwn quoted his pm there and saying she assumed scum was giving a safe claim.
Why? Not necessarily saying he's clean, I'm just curious what the case is.Once I get that cleared up, yea, I'm shoving the hacker to the back of the line.
Because that's the tone you conveyed. That you wanted to damn Hacker no matter WHAT pwnman flipped.
Nono, where did you get that I would think Hacker was scum if pman was scum.
I said that Hacker is scum because pman is town.
^^^ Here right?Ellibereth wrote:^^^ Ridiculously Scummy post now.HackerHuck wrote:He also paraphrased your comment on me. Or if it wasn't yours, it was someone elses.Jahudo wrote:Pwnman, can you respond to post 152?
I'm not much liking Mega Pimp and SpyreX on the last couple of pages. Cobalt and pwnman seem OK to me
Who would say that pwnman looked "OK" when he was acting irrational and absolutely ridiculous? Oh yeah, that's right! Scum, who would know he was town.
Reshoving.
I actually meant your post at the bottom of page 8. And why would they bus pwnman (if he were scum) and
^^^ Here right?
Bleh, I don't see it. If pwnman flipped scum I would be thinking that his buddies would be bussing by then, not defending.
Whatevs.
No you assumed scum was given a claim by this statementExcuse me if I assumed someone who looks incredibly desperate to prove they are town was scum. You know, since scum totally don't want to actually seem town, ne?
I'd almost say that makes you scummy for ignoring that aspect.
Also, why two 11s, and why is Ellibereth, who came to the same conclusion, not number 10?
Your reasoning becomes less and less sensical given your shove order.
I made an error with posting number hacker would be towards the back of the line but you would be at the end.UncertainKitten wrote:Oh, it's certainly not proof he's town. I'm assuming DGB gave falseclaims to the scum. And "proving you are town" with a role PM quote does feel desperate.
How would you know it was quoted? Then go and say that scum was given a safe claim after the fact?UncertainKitten wrote:You just quoted your Role PM, didn't you?
Um...what are you even asking here? It was CLEARLY a role PM quote, but that doesn't necessarily mean it's a REAL PM. I don't know about YOU, but if anyone quotes ANY PMs, real or false, in my games, and I'm not allowing role PM quoting, they get modkilled.How would you know it was quoted? Then go and say that scum was given a safe claim after the fact?
^^^ Ridiculously Scummy post now.Ellibereth wrote:^^^ Ridiculously Scummy post now.HackerHuck wrote:He also paraphrased your comment on me. Or if it wasn't yours, it was someone elses.Jahudo wrote:Pwnman, can you respond to post 152?
I'm not much liking Mega Pimp and SpyreX on the last couple of pages. Cobalt and pwnman seem OK to me
Who would say that pwnman looked "OK" when he was acting irrational and absolutely ridiculous? Oh yeah, that's right! Scum, who would know he was town.
Reshoving.
I was modpoked.farside22 wrote:LOL as soon as eli makes a post about the 2 lurkers they show.
........Jahudo wrote:So any defense for why you didn't put a dash there?
not sureEllibereth wrote:He's still scummy as hell.
And he calls that "proof" he's town.
probably townUncertainKitten wrote:Oh, it's certainly not proof he's town. I'm assuming DGB gave falseclaims to the scum. And "proving you are town" with a role PM quote does feel desperate.
not sureHackerHuck wrote:He also paraphrased your comment on me. Or if it wasn't yours, it was someone elses.
I'm not much liking Mega Pimp and SpyreX on the last couple of pages. Cobalt and pwnman seem OK to me
lols prob townEllibereth wrote:The bolded is a typo right?
def townfarside22 wrote:vote: Eli
Anyone who looked at pwnman's comment with his claim and calling it scum doesn't have the same PM me thinks.
oooh, this one doesn't look greatCobalt wrote:Shove:
UncertainKitten 2
Minineko 10
Ellibereth 3
Jahudo 6
SpyreX 4
Max 7
farside22 5
HackerHuck 8
Super Awesome Mega Pimp! 11
Cobalt 1
pwnman 12
Grimmy 9
toooowwnnfarside22 wrote:So assuming means pwnman is scum.
Which includes things my own PM stated?
That's a lot of assumption. Sure DGB said not to think much of the flavor text but that assumption seems scum motivated to me.
not feeling this. attack on cobalt while interrogating pwn (with a repeated question, ironically) is oddSuper Awesome Mega Pimp! wrote: pwnman: why did you claim? Why did you copy portions of your shove reasons from Jahudo?
yeah, Eli is prob aggrotownEllibereth wrote:BS. Die.
this is just nonsenseJahudo wrote:So any defense for why you didn't put a dash there?
could go either way maybe leaning slightly town on this oneSpyreX wrote:Max still isn't doin it for me.
Pwn's combination of posting his PM at that juncture AND saying that it was a coincidence absolutely floors me.
Hacker's town read of the abovetechnicallybothers me more, but.
Elli is almost blinding with the raw amout of town oozing out.
now im less certain about farside. how does the copying imply scum? still pretty sure she's town though.farside22 wrote:Ah thanks for that spyrex I didn't understand what the paroting was about.
unvote:
vote: pwnman
It was pretty blantant copying in my view and I know scum to follow others logic and make comments that are almost exactly like those who stated the same thing before.now im less certain about farside. how does the copying imply scum?
Old Order (In order of rank) wrote:Shove:
Max 1
Jahudo 2
Super Awesome Mega Pimp! 3
Cobalt 4
farside22 5
HackerHuck 6
pwnman 7
SpyreX 8
Grimmy 9
Ellibereth 10
UncertainKitten 11
Minineko 12
There isn't a sample town role PM in the OP, so that might make a fakeclaim more likely. Also rule 3 warns against this kind of stuff, like flavor text may not correlate with alignment. So I don't think its telling one way or the other with how Elli reacted.farside22 wrote:Second there are very few times I give fake claims to the mafia. I usually have a generatic town sample pm so the scum know what the win condition is.
What do you mean by too easy? Too easy to find fault in his read, or the current suspicion on him has been flowing too easily?SpyreX wrote:I really want to give the super push to Hacker but it almost seems too easy.