Again, if you saw this on day one that be fine but your stated reasons for considering a no lynch often involved getting to use night kills that the mafia made as additional sources of information. Troll's point here be that scum had every reason never to let that come up. As for sitting at the sidelines today, if scum are pretty sure them aren't going to be lynched today it still be a somewhat viable path; if we no lynch them today then we have a decent chance of hitting a chosen on our own. If we lynched a vanilla townie today then we'd still have to try again tomorrow after no night kills and we'd be equally likely to hit a chosen as we would scum or the final vanilla townie by numbers alone.Scien wrote:Meh. I didn't really feel like telling the scum how to act. Same reason I said that the remaining scum would be feeling pressure without explaining why. If we hit a vanilla townie here today, they have no night option. Now is his time to push for something, if he was indeed just sitting on the sidelines like is being suggested as a possibility. Besides... it is pretty explicit in the rules that the town has to have the final action... that was a pretty obvious loss condition was even bolded.Zorblag wrote:Troll no saw awareness that the scum would be best served by no night killing in most situation where the town would be best served by no lynching.
The reason that Troll no be that worried about scum using that tactic now be that it would be best used if it had been the plan all along; in that case there should have been no night kills.
Papa Zito's case on MiteyMouse wasn't lurking though. It was the incorrect statement of the win conditions that she made early in the game.Scien wrote:You find it odd? The cases on them were both similar. Mostly lurking claims, followed by lynch all lurker arguments. Why would the lurker matter? I don't see how me thinking you would switch after the quote I mentioned would be a unreasonable assumption.PapaZ wrote:I find it odd that you would think so when I espoused his lynch the whole back half of the day.
-Zorblag R`Lyeh