KoC:
Knight of Cydonia [304] wrote:How do I seem "awfully sure" EmpTyger? I'm saying he might not have submitted the kill. That's all.
Not what I’m asking. I’m asking why you seem so sure there are 3 mafia.
Lowell:
Lowell [310] wrote:emp, I explained this. I didn't want to target my biggest suspect, because I figured it would be stopped somehow (either by me dying or him--RBT-- not making the kill).
Not what I’m asking. I’m asking why, if Kieraen was your second biggest suspect, why you didn’t indicate in any way this suspicion beforehand? In particular yesterday, when there were a RBT and a Kieraen bandwagons, you said a
Kieraen:
Kieraen [305] wrote:If a townie is constantly a lynch target then he may as well get out the limelight and be lynched.
RBT is not a lynch target just because you keep repeating it. RBT does not have to be inevitably lynched at some point. Therefore anyone who isn’t for it immediately isn’t suspicious, and the town isn’t wasting a day lynching him today instead of yesterday. I myself will not be voting RBT today just as much- in fact, moreso- than I wasn’t voting him yesterday.
Kieraen [cont] wrote:At very least it gives the town one extra confirmed townie in which to anlysys his posts.
Show me where you did this or advised it should be done after Spyre’s mislynch.
Kieraen [305] wrote:What if for instance me and RBT are both townies?
<snip>
I’m thinking this case increasingly unlikely. But, to answer your question- then obviously we don’t want to lynch either of you! And instead of having players repeat that both of you must be lynched, we should be looking at who keeps insisting that both need to die and obsessively keeping the focus on you 2. Which, ironically, includes you.
Kieraen [cont] wrote:Better I was lynched yesterday you see I'm townie and can see who's pushing the lynch.
<snip>
Um, don’t *you* already know you’re townie? (Temporarily assuming you’re innocent, of course.) Shouldn’t you at least then be able to figure out who was pushing your lynch? But instead, you’re trying to attack those who *didn’t* push your lynch!
Kieraen [309] wrote:<snip>
You are tunnelling, and I get the sincere feeling that you are tunnelling on a townie, in the role of a scummer.
<snip>
Um, you said this to KoC, who was tunneling on *you*. Why “get the sincere feeling”? (Again, with the same increasingly unlikely assumption.) Shouldn’t you *know* for certain whether KoC is “tunneling on a townie” or not, because you would know that you’re innocent?