Empking wrote:
He has three defenses.
1. He wasn't the driving force of the Simpor lynch. This is obviously a strawman.
2. Arguing that my case against him was for the Simpor thing. Again a Strawman.
You're case against GC is based on him not helping the town. When asked you categorised this as:
Empking wrote:We know who isn't helping. The person who's only target is the (confirmed) Pro-town Simpor.
From this statement its quite obvious where people get points 1 and 2 from - so no, I don't think they're strawmen. Also, just because Simpr is GC's only target that got lynched, doesn't mean he was GC's only ever target.
Also, lets not ignore how scummy this post is, regardless of who its aimed at.
Empking wrote:3. I'm making .a case out of nothing. Completely unbacked up without evidence
Thanks for pointing that out, since I don't remember you ever coherently stating your reasons for suspecting GC.
Empking wrote:The case against me is that I had someone I thought was scummy, before December the 21st.
Some other things I don't like.
Your arguing with GC has its roots in your second post (334). You go back and forth a few times trying to actually argue your point until post 345 where you claim he "strawmanned the original argument". Generally one claims they're being strawmanned as soon as it happens. It appears to me that you took the easy out once you realised that there was no way you could out argue GC.
Originally you claimed that Ether was scum trying to convince the town that she was town. I didn't see much in your posting that explains why, but your opinion changed:
Empking wrote:I'm torn between Fuzzyman or Green Crayons. Green Crayons go to great lengths to protect Ether but I don't think Ether is scum. Fuzzyman goes to great length to protect GC and I do think he's scum. (Those were along with everything else scummy they've done.)
Vote: Fuzzyman
The abrupt, unexplained opinion change on Ether is something else I find scummy. Especially since your original opinion on Ether is where your argument with GC began, an argument which is still going.
"I can't not give mad props to the murderbot 9000 that was q21." - Spyrex, after Scummies Invitational 2010.
You know those times when you wish you could think of something really funny or interesting to say, but just can't?... Yep, this is one of those times.