(er, I did vote PV, Tierce. Fairly sure I did.)
Anyways, Tierce does have a point regarding your theory/scumhunting ratio. Other than your attacks on tierce's reasonings for her reads (or lack thereof), there's barely anything there that relates to scumhunting at all.
Of course, he does explain his posts 249 and 251 were sarcastic, but then that means that he actually doesn't have any non-theory-related reads, or at least none that he's stated. Sure, 421 has reads, but that's almost 200 posts later, and every post of his in between those has practically been about nothing but theory.
(If it wasn't clear already, I think PV is scum).
Why is it that Albert signs up for games but then lurks like hell in practically every single one? It's completely ridiculous. Can't get a single damn read on him cuz unlike NS (who seems to lurk more as scum) his lurking seems to be for both town and scum. So he's a big, fat, null.
Scooby's in the same boat reads-wise, though he's not a lurker-prone as Albert is. Wish he would step it up, though.
Regarding Yos (Since Quadz asked), I still feel somewhat fine about my townread on him. I like that he was scumhunting and being aggresive in solidifying his read on Matt, and his theory work is relatively decent. Not a sold townread, but he's still town.
Kayne's ISO has been bereft of scumhunting (beyond light prodding in Matt's direction for reads and such). His theory discussion is fine-ish, but it's not really enough to sway me in any one direction, so he's null.
Xalxe's point about MattP's view on meta is rather decent given the context around it, and Matt's response to it is terrible. Frustration aside, you just don't respond to those kind of things with "Shut up, you're not important enough to deal with right now" (more or less). Gives off the wrong message no matter how you read it, and it makes Matt look scummy.
That being said, 322 is a bad question to me because IMO Matt's 321 answered either both or the first part ("This was before Zdenek had referred to me whatsoever" seems to answer the explain the townread part). Is that a good answer? Arguably not. Does it answer the question? Yes.
I'm intensely annoyed with the argument with Matt from 322 to about 334-ish, but I do like the continued drive for Matt to better explain his zdenek read. Matt's responses continue to look worse and worse, and that's compounded by the emotion that is coming off his posts in droves around this point.
Also, I agree with 442. It's almost as if once two people got onto Peregrine practically everyone else who was active at the time was like "oh, yeah, I think PV's scum, too!" It doesn't make PV any less scummier to me, but it is suspicious.
In short, Xalxe is town.
Reading through LLD and Xalxe has given me more or less enough to believe that Matt is scum. Unfortunately, as it seems he's figured out, he's more or less shot himself in the foot and is probably going to die today/tomorrow. That acceptance has got me to doubt the read enough that PV is scummier than him, but I still feel like Matt is now effectively a dead man walking.
P-EDIT: Well, yeah, you gave reads...400 posts after the game started and more or less
after
being pressured to give them. There's a difference between that and Tierce, who has actually given and changed her reads almost from the get-go.
(plus, ISO work didn't really change anything in regards to my view on you, so.)
