This cycle of the disappearing townies was growing a little old. Naturally, it was up to the Mafia to break it.
When the townspeople reconvened for the fourth morning, their expectations of one missing were not met, since the night's casualty was prominently displayed. Crushed under a house lay House.
The egg snapped its fingers at the villagers and formed finger guns.
"Sorry to keep you waiting. Let's get to it."
House was a
Town Bodyguard
.
Day 4
With 5 players alive, it takes
3
players for a lynch.
The deadline for this day is (expired on 2016-10-28 20:15:00).
I'm not sure whether there's 2 or 3. Gerry, did you look at the review topic for Mini 1832. It had a fourth PR, albeit a one shot. There could still be two.
I suggest we massclaim. I'm vanilla townie.
<Embrace The Void>
“A flipped coin doesn't always land heads or tails. Sometimes it may never land at all...”
Oh, and this really should go without saying, but just in case: Nobody vote yet.
We're down to five players. If we have two scum left, and one Townie votes for Town, then both scum can jump on that vote and force through a mislynch.
In post 2177, Gamma Emerald wrote:I'm not sure whether there's 2 or 3. Gerry, did you look at the review topic for Mini 1832. It had a fourth PR, albeit a one shot. There could still be two.
I suggest we massclaim. I'm vanilla townie.
I´m vanilla townie.
There is no way we have only 2 scum when one already flipped goon and we have 4 PRs including a BP.
For now my highest townread is Gamma. Both Huntress and House read him town. House being killed tonight isnt something i think scum!gamma would do.
CCC jumped off the wagon on Huntress and pushed on Gerry so one of them is probably scum one is town.
Malpascp is scum i am pretty sure. CCC+Gerry is not a thing after that voteswitch yesterday.
Ill Re-Iso Gamma and Malpscap/Jester again but i am pretty sure we have to lynch malpscap today.
Ill ignore the Gamma stalking for now as i think its NAI.
Okay I'm going to say what I was thinking.
I think the possibility of 2 scum still exists. In the game I was using for the potential scum count in the latter half of this game, there was an omitted one shot vigilante. That would have made towns power:
Pinger(glorified fruit vendor basically)
tracker
watcher
one shot vig
in that game. So far in this game we have
JOAT
Watcher
BG
one shot BP
looking similar, but may be stronger. I'm thinking that scum's PR may be a strongman to deal with the defensive lean I see (BG, BP, RB and maybe Doc from JOAT). I was thinking that if we had 1 PR claim, I could determine whether a) scum was fakeclaiming or b) it really is 3 scum. But with no PR claims, I'm not sure about either possibility.
<Embrace The Void>
“A flipped coin doesn't always land heads or tails. Sometimes it may never land at all...”
(a) Manuel and Gamma both voted for our single known scum on Day 1.
(b) Manuel was the target of a strong push by our single known scum, Day 1.
(c) Manuel has never yet been on the vote wagon at the end of day for Town.
(d) Due to (a), (b) and (c), there is still good reason to think that Manuel is Town. It could have been two-way bussing on Day 1, so he's not 100% cleared, but he seems likely Town.
(e) House was Town. Therefore, House did not survive Night 2 by virtue of being scum; scum decided to kill Grendel before House Night 2.
(f) Day 2, House was pushing hard for a lynch on Gamma.
(g) Day 3, House didn't see any reason for his survival is Gamma was scum
(h) Due to (a), (e), (f) and (g), Gamma seems likely Town.
(i) I know that I am Town.
--------------
This leaves only malpascp and gerryoats as the two potential scum. If there are two scum, then, I suspect that this is where they lie.
Looking back over the end-of-day vote counts, I see that gerryoats and malpascp/The_Jester were both on every single lynch of a Town player, but were not on our single lynch of a scum player.
The malpascp/The_Jester slot, despite switching players inbetween, hammered on both days; on both occasions claiming inebriation.
I doubt CCC is town because his logic is sound (even if there's a lot of WIFOMy stuff like House surviving = town!Gamma), but I know I'm town.
My highest town read right now is Manuel, due to his posting but mostly because of House's flip.
So as far as I'm concerned, scum is in CCC/Gamma/Gerry. I'll have to think about this for a while longer.
Also let's be honest here, did anyone here NOT want Huntress lynched yesterday? I'm pretty sure anyone could have been the hammer.
btw, I wasn't drunk when I hammered. I was drunk slightly before, and even so was more hungover than drunk. I'd never screw a game no matter how wasted I am. What Jester did (if true) was just stupid.
In post 2193, Gamma Emerald wrote:Wait.
If CCC is really town, which I am feeling, we're in auto win. Because we would have the same amount of lynches as potential scum.
If anyone has doubts that CCC is town, please bring them up.
I think CCC is more likely town then Gerry.
malpascp wrote:Also let's be honest here, did anyone here NOT want Huntress lynched yesterday? I'm pretty sure anyone could have been the hammer.
I didnt want her lynched. And i liked CCCs switch on Gerry. Thats actually the main reason why i think he is more likely to be town then Gerry.
i'm the only one who defended huntress and when I did, I was going to be lynched for it. please tell me as scum why I would defend PR that much to a point where I was going to be lynched for it
I think Manuel is Town for sure. I think gamma and mal are prob not a team. those are my reads, so it's possible CCC could be mafia here if there is 2 since the other two might not be teamed
Gerry is right here. He put his neck on the line to defend town, and his vote was not a plea vote. Dude's town. Meaning we have auto between CCC and mal.
<Embrace The Void>
“A flipped coin doesn't always land heads or tails. Sometimes it may never land at all...”
In post 2198, Gamma Emerald wrote:Gerry is right here. He put his neck on the line to defend town, and his vote was not a plea vote. Dude's town. Meaning we have auto between CCC and
