Mafia 125: Khan's Game of Mafia (Game Over)

[curiouskarmadog]

Vote: Gorrad.

Sorry I replied a little bit late, I live in a different time-zone and because my computer is broke (he will be replaced in a few days) I couldn't post earlier.

@Gorrad, I'm new here at this website but this is already my 5th large game, so I'm not a newbie. And I know what RVS is (usually I'm the only one who uses it and I always have a discussion about it), but you are all using it really quick. I didn't expect that.
And I didn't notice there were more than 3 pages in the thread, I only saw the first one, so what I said about all the votes was a reply to the first page (I can't edit it).

what do you think RVS is? What is different about this RVS than other ones you have been in..

and why the vote on Gorrad? You voted him twice (one bolded) but neither vote you mention why....not even a joke reason...explain.

[DrippingGoofball]

TOWN
inHim

I very much agree with this read.

[DrippingGoofball]

DGB, I want you to claim. I don't care if it's real or fake...

We're masons, stupid. We should be having this sort of discussion in the QT, not in public.

[curiouskarmadog]

also DGB, can you keep me off your town list this game...last time, didnt end so well for me.

[DrippingGoofball]

Unvote, Vote: Gorrad

SUMMON LOS ROPOS

I will join this wagon after I see a vote count.

NOTE TO 5!<u/\/\z:

Korlash is the unlynchable PGO.

[DrippingGoofball]

UNLYNCHABLE PGO

Korlash

TOWN

DrippingGoofball (mason fakeclaim town-tell)
InHim (town self-read town-tell)
SpyreX (every word he posts town-tell)
Runner (post restriction nagging town-tell)
nocase (reckless ridiculousness town-tell)
Jerbs (random post-less NOob town-tell)

PERSONS OF INTEREST

Gorrad (buying DGB chocolates questionabletell, but Seraphimscum seems to know Gorrad is town counter-tell)
Antihero (taking Korlash literally questionable-tell)
iamausername (bus'ing Antihero in late RVS questionable-tell)
Seraphim (Seems to know that Gorrad is town questionable-tell)
Xalxe (VLA questionable-tell)
werewolf555 (hasn't posted yet for fear of early-game mental meltdown questionable-tell)
Red Coyote (IIoA questionable-tell, has not found scum yet questionable-tell)
farside (hasn't found me scum yet questionable-tell)

5!<u/\/\z

curiouskarmadog ("

Hello, I am scum

" scum-tell)
Dutch one (dog ate homework scum-tell)
Chevre (blinding us all with Shakespearian English scum-tell)
Cyberbob (heckling from peanut gallery scum-tell)
Kmd4390 (hasn't posted because working on fakeclaim scum-tell)
Katsuki (Katsuki is Katsuki scum-tell)

[Xalxe]

Deadline added to OP (5 weeks).

Also, Xalxe PMed me that he will be V/LA until 1/23 (Sunday).

But since I have no school today, I'm here for a bit.

So, thoughts on the 4 pages so far:

nocase and InHim: WTF? Don't fakeclaim post restrictions. Had I been around, I'd have voted nocase instantly. I still haven't really seen reasoning behind the fakeclaims.
DGB: DEAR GOD NOT AGAIN--er, hey there, how you doin?
Korlash: Nice to see you again. I really mean that I knew you existed and then disappeared, so hi.
Dutch one: I really, for your sake, hope you can keep up with this shit. It gets crazy fast.
Chevre: is there anywhere better your vote could be right now?
SpyreX: could you explain the Gorrad vote?

P-EDIT: DGB, I'm camping 2 hours away, hence v/la.

[inHimshallibe]

UNLYNCHABLE PGO

Korlash

TOWN

DrippingGoofball (mason fakeclaim town-tell)
InHim (town self-read town-tell)
SpyreX (every word he posts town-tell)
Runner (post restriction nagging town-tell)
nocase (reckless ridiculousness town-tell)
Jerbs (random post-less NOob town-tell)

PERSONS OF INTEREST

Gorrad (buying DGB chocolates questionabletell, but Seraphimscum seems to know Gorrad is town counter-tell)
Antihero (taking Korlash literally questionable-tell)
iamausername (bus'ing Antihero in late RVS questionable-tell)
Seraphim (Seems to know that Gorrad is town questionable-tell)
Xalxe (VLA questionable-tell)
werewolf555 (hasn't posted yet for fear of early-game mental meltdown questionable-tell)
Red Coyote (IIoA questionable-tell, has not found scum yet questionable-tell)
farside (hasn't found me scum yet questionable-tell)

5!<u/\/\z

curiouskarmadog ("

Hello, I am scum

" scum-tell)
Dutch one (dog ate homework scum-tell)
Chevre (blinding us all with Shakespearian English scum-tell)
Cyberbob (heckling from peanut gallery scum-tell)
Kmd4390 (hasn't posted because working on fakeclaim scum-tell)
Katsuki (Katsuki is Katsuki scum-tell)

[Xalxe]

InHim, I can't see one of those pics.

[inHimshallibe]

InHim, I can't see one of those pics.

You know what... no one but me may be able to.

I'll try again:

@DGB:

[iamausername]

Xalxe is also scum.

[Xalxe]

Ah, that's better.

iam: Based upon what precisely?

[DrippingGoofball]

Xalxe is also scum.

K, so you're scum with Xalxe and Antihero? Is it just the three of you, or are there more?

[Xalxe]

DGB, do you enjoy tunnelling me? Because I'd really like to see a case this time.

[DrippingGoofball]

It's not my fault this time, iamausername is insisting on selling out his buddies.

[Xalxe]

Okay, rephrase:

Why is iamausername scum?

[DrippingGoofball]

Okay, rephrase:

Why is iamausername scum?

Because he's bus'ing his buddies!

He voted Antihero with much flourish and panache, with a contrived random vote (he beat us over the head with his random-vote flavor), when the RVS was over. That's something you do when you're scum, writing a loudly non-committal post when the time to commit was NOW. The manner in which it was done suggested that he felt so intensely that he had to get his RVS distancing done, that he didn't notice his post was completely out of place.

[iamausername]

Ah, that's better.

iam: Based upon what precisely?

Have a guess.

[Antihero]

What would the response have been? And talking to Chevre about what? You made this craptacular post that didn't say anything but was disguised as content.

It wasn't disguised as content, it's a simple question directed at Chevre surrounded by the special korlash sauce. And if you want to get anal about stuff like that your vote didn't have a shred of "content" backing it up either. Also the response would have been one of those killer laugh out loud and have all of your workplace look at you funny jokes, but sadly I've never been able to do one of those...

Do I sense irritation? There's no reason for that; nitpicking early on is how I roll. Nothing personal.

Xalxe is obviously town. As is Chevre. If you want reasons for these, you're just SOL. P. Edit: Actually, Seraphims poo fling at Chevre is probably the reason for me thinking she's town. As for Xalxe, diction of his posts.

Seraphim, on the other hand, is scum. If you don't believe me, read post 69; it's a doozy.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Seraphim

Another P. Edit: I now hate IAUN, too.

[DrippingGoofball]

Let's ignore iamausername's guilty result on Xalxe.

DISTRACTION!

VOTE: Seraphim

[nocase]

i would appreciate it if you would refrain from distracting from the more urgent pursuit of a gorrad lynch.

[Cyberbob]

heckling from the peanut gallery is my middle name~

Still pretty leery of inHim backing up nocase's joke about having a post restriction, I mean it probably was a joke but it came right in that weird transition phase from the RVS to serious posting time. I also predict many headaches from reading Dutch one's posts; it seems like he's going to be a tricky one to get a read on with so much chaff already being thrown up in the phrasing of his posts.

Right now:
- DGB's doing that ~super confident list making self-towntelling keraaziness~ thing that she usually does, I agree with most of her points so far but I always get the feeling that this kind of playstyle is at least partly deliberate (I know players like ABR and that guy whose name escapes me right now do it as well). It's been pretty much forever since I've played with her so I forget whether she falls back into a slightly more on-point mode of posting as the game progresses.
- inHimshallibe is kind of doing the same thing as DGB to a lesser extent
- Gorrad is being really annoying. Not sure whether it's worth 4 votes (I'm disregarding his self-vote) though; probably just people voting for fear of being accused of overcautiousness during the RVS but I'd say there could plausibly be scum there
- antihero is totally town
- Korlash's Post 43 is really awkward in the way he attempts to soften his dismissal of the credibility of the list of possible roles in the OP with that super forced joke about professional dog walkers. Then he followed it up with a rambling post about I-don't-even-know-what, and then

another

half-serious half-forced humour post in defence of his initial attempt. Scummy.
- wtf @ iamausername's Post 92?
- Seraphim's Post 69 is pretty suss, Korlash is more suspicious for similar reasons though (just more of it)

Vote: Korlash

ps dgb that list of yours is upside down I would greatly appreciate it if you could amend this thanks ~~

[Xalxe]

Okay, rephrase:

Why is iamausername scum?

Because he's bus'ing his buddies!

He voted Antihero with much flourish and panache, with a contrived random vote (he beat us over the head with his random-vote flavor), when the RVS was over. That's something you do when you're scum, writing a loudly non-committal post when the time to commit was NOW. The manner in which it was done suggested that he felt so intensely that he had to get his RVS distancing done, that he didn't notice his post was completely out of place.

I disconcur with your reasoning. I do not disconcur that iamausername could still be scum. I just haven't seen enough to place a vote.

Ah, that's better.

iam: Based upon what precisely?

Have a guess.

Hmmm...because you know DGB enjois tunnels on me, so you'll align with her against me?

That being said, she's doing it less this game.

SO FAR

i would appreciate it if you would refrain from distracting from the more urgent pursuit of a gorrad lynch.

I would appreciate it if somebody would explain to me just why I should vote Gorrad.

No, seriously, I don't get it.

[farside22]

Ugh!!! I hate you people. I don't have time to say much becuase I have to get to work in 10 minutes (yes I live 5 minutes from work)
In short Cheve looks scummy and I disagree with Spyrex looking town.

farside (hasn't found me scum yet questionable-tell)

If I had a chance to log on last night I was going to vote for you as my RVS for old time sake.
But I missed RVS.

vote: Cheve

more to come when I have time tonight.

[Dutch one]

DGB, I know you are making a list like this a lot (other people say that, so I assume that is true), but it's an easy tactic to place yourself in the "town" list. With making this list you more influence in the lynching system because it makes people almost think they have to prove themself that they are townies. And because it's your list, because you are doing this often and because you placed yourself in the townie-list, you don't have to prove anyone, and you get away with it.
I'm not saying that I think you are scum (not yet), but I do think you are trying to make yourself look innocent in a sneaky way. I think you are just doing this to gain influence.
If you want to make a list like this that again (with a good intention): "Don't place yourself anywhere in the list". You look scummy if you do that. Then you are just waiting for someone to critisize it

IGMEOY: DGB