Okay, let's start with ThAdmiral. These are the entries into my earlier analysis for him.
MBL
thinks pablito,
ubertimmy/Nightfall
and ChannelDelibird/StallingChamp are scum.
PJ,
Twomz
and ChannelDelibird/SC attack cbox.
Pablito defends cbox and attacks CDB/SC for voting him.
CDB/SC FoSes PJ and votes Mert (for tying two people together).
MoS thinks PJ is Town.
Ubertimmy/Nightfall
agrees.
Pablito votes CDB/SC for not attacking
Thok
for binding two people together.
Thok
pushes pablito for voting CDB.
PJ posts his LoE, containing bird, Phoebus, CDB/SC and pablito. However, he doesn't think pablito is scum.
Cbox unvotes bird and votes pablito. He's not suspicious of CDB, but he is suspicious of Phoebus.
MBL
thinks CDB/SC is being awkward.
PJ threw CDB/SC on the LoE to incite reactions (this was also vibe from the original LoE).
Mert's list of suspicions regarding the LoE is Phoebus-bird-pablito-CDB.
PJ executes
Rosso
.
CTD
votes PJ, SC,
Twomz
and
timmy/Nightfall
.
Spectrumvoid
votes
timmy/Nightfall
and SC for the same reasoning as 557.
Pablito votes SC for no reason and is losing confidence in cbox.
Pablito thinks SC is scummy, cbox is townish,
spectrumvoid
is scummy.
SC votes
Pooky
, Fritz and MoS.
Glork
posts a LoE containing
MBL
, Mert,
Pooky
, Yos, tentative Pablito,
CTD
and SC.
It's interesting to note that Voidybuns jumped on CTD's Post 557 (a move I characterised as scummy before) to vote both Skruffs/Nightfall/Timmy (now dead Kingmaker) and ThAdmiral/StallingChamp/Olio/ChannelDelibird.
I'll go back in time on this one and take a closer look at 557. In Post 557, CTD votes the following four people over the following reasons:
PJ: The way the Rosso execution played out.
SC: Lurking and supporting PJ's execution plan.
Twomz: Burden of proof, over-eagerness on the birdwagon.
Ubertimmy: Lurking.
The link between SC and PJ here is worth pointing out.
In Post 558, pablito votes both timmy and CTD, saying CTD's reason for voting PJ is very weak. Pablito is buddying up to PJ like there's no tomorrow. Voidy votes for Timmy and SC, citing 557 as her exact source. Another interesting defense of PJ in that post. Upon a closer re-read (I'm getting the feeling I'm digressing slightly now...) I also found two posts that look like PJ-defenses from Pooky, namely 211 and 999. However, in 211, it seems his defense of PJ is more of an attack on Glork, and in 999, one can only help but wonder what Pooky's thoughts were, coming in. After all, at that point, Pooky was on the LoE and a quite probable execution. It's a real shame Pooky never finished his analysis, so we don't know what he said about voidybuns.
But, for comparison, we'll take a look at Pooky's list of opinions:
Scum: bird.
Suspicious: CTD (Town), Mert.
Town: Cbox, LuckayLuck (Town), MoS, MBL (Town), Nightson, pablito, PJ.
Interesting to note here is his Dead Rikimaru section, in which he says there will be more about Dead Riki in the pablito section, but, as far as I can see, there's nothing there. I definitely think that that is a scum-tell for Dead Rikimaru, now mnowax.
I think I've digressed way too much now, so back to ThAdmiral.
CdB is the first person to have played that role. He votes cbox in his second post, though his point is reasonably strong. Then we get his next post, which is in response to a pablito post which I really don't like (95), as pablito stresses how much risk he's taking by defending cbox, something which looks an awful lot like scum defending town to me. Doesn't want to out the Kingmaker, meh, next post is more interesting.
The next post is 186, Delly's supposed major post. Attacks cbox for giving up. Agrees with Yos over MoS, but doesn't vote. FoSes Jelly for stating he's town. Thinks Phoebus is strange. Votes Mert for tying two people together (Phoebus and MoS), something with which I personally disagree.
This really isn't a very strong post. I'm seeing attacks, however minor, here on Cbox, MoS, Jelly and Mert. All those are alive, so we can't really say anything solid about it, but I think Cbox and MoS are town.
Next up is a request for an LoE. Apology for falling behind. His last post is a defense against Jelly, explaining his votes for cbox and Mert. I think the vote against Mert there is very poor. The case against Cbox is stronger there, but I don't really like the weight he puts on the tells (as he ignores Cbox's newbishness) and it's fairly 'wagonish.
Delly's overall posting was...insufficient. Not a whole lot to analyze. Has mostly discussed Cbox. The overall vibe I'm getting from his posts are scummy.
Next up is StallingChamp. The beginning here is interesting. As CTD said, he apparently thought PJ made a good decision under the circumstanced, but also didn't think Rosso was a good execution, which is quite the contradiction. A really interesting post is
Post 661. It's a very odd post. On one hand, there's the fact that he's voting a scumbuddy here. On the other hand, I really don't know what to think of this post. It could be distancing. Overall, it gives me a good gut feel, but I suggest everyone look at it for themselves. After this, SC flakes and is replaced.
SC only posted one "big" content-post, namely 661. There's an interesting possible link with Jelly to remember. Overall, though, the feeling I get from SC is a lot better than the feeling I got from CDB.
Next up in the replacement train is Olio. He starts off the game with this
post, voting pablito, LuckayLuck and Nightson. Now, I think his vote for LuckayLuck is rather weak and based more on Luckay's playstyle than anything else. Nightson because he sees things in 808, things I really don't see. The case for pablito is a bit stronger, but I also don't really see it. Then we get a little debate with pablito over the case, something I find rather insignificant, to be honest.
This is a more interesting post, as we finally get off the pablito-argument. His main suspicions are still pablito-Luckay-Nightson, for the same reasons, but now voidybuns and Mossy are thrown into the mix. Voidybuns especially seems a bit fabricated here, very possible distancing. Votes MoS for not responding to his posts, unvotes later when there is response. A wee bit aggressive against Dead Riki (which, I believe, was during Riki's Kingship), which is a bit of a plus. Aggressive against Luckay, semi-prodding him
here. I actually rather like
this post. I like the questions in there. Follow-up
here. A bit of a debate with Yossy afterwards. Thinks Luckay is gambiting with his "Lynch me" attitude. Then asks to be replaced.
Olio started out horribly. I really don't like the way he added Voidy to his scumlist and completely ignored her afterwards. I liked a couple of the posts he made later, which overall gave me a good gut feeling. I'm fifty-fifty on him.
ThAdmiral is the last in line. Votes pablito, Smashy and Fritzler early on, no explanations given. Votes mnowax over an OMGUS-vote and unvotes pablito because "we need him to get discussion". I really do not agree with that kind of argument. If he's valuable, he's just being valuable for the scum, not for the town. Possible link with Der Hammer
here. Next post is an LoE-post. I'll quote it for quotey goodness.
MoS: no, mainly because the summary posts were so god-damned helpful.
VitaminR: i don't know. Yes, but I think he deserves a bit of time to state his case.
SV: maybe, leaning towards no. There are better plays at the moment in my opinion.
Smashy: obv yes, as I'm voting for him.
Defense of voidy. Clearly pushing for Smashy.
Doesn't mind a mnowax-hammer. This post gives me awful vibes. It's pretty much the first time he even mentions mnowax. Then there's a contentless month. His back post contains three things. He's not against another mnowax-kill, but he wants to give him a day. He wants Thesp to better outline his case against MoS because Thesp seems pretty positive, and he wants me to say who I'm going to execute. I'm seeing quite a link between him and Yos in the following posts, that's not a good thing either. Next post is in response to my LoE, makes for another interesting quote:
ThAdmiral wrote:I haven't done a full read-through yet, but I seem to remember that zindies play didn't strike me as overly scummy, just...unusual. He has his own style, and thats fine with me.
In my opinion, this looks a wee bit like he's trying to buddy up to me.
My thoughts on the loe:
SV - I wouldn't.
Vit - I've been coming round to this one, but I think...
Fritz - is probably the best option today.
His position on Voidy has become stronger. Where it was "maybe, probably not" when Yos was King, now it has become a flat-out no. Thinks Vitamin is scummy. Coming around seems like an odd choice of words, seeing how I don't think he's mentioned him before. Wants Fritz deaded. However, he's never stated any reasons for wanting Fritz dead, even in his first vote. Sees me as "good king listening to his people", which really says nothing about me. Don't like that. Reason for putting Voidy below were "gut".
Question: ThAdmiral, which posts gave you a good gut feeling?
Votes mnowax, Fritz, Vitamin. Hasn't completed his task.
Well, that's it. The overall gut feeling I got from the role was pretty bad, especially so with ThAdmiral. I'm seeing possible links between the role and Voidybuns, Yossy and Jelly, one of which is proven scum and one of which I believe is scum. Pushes Vitamin/Fritz/Mnowax1/Mnowax2. Overall, he's a pretty good lynch. I don't think I want him today, though.