Mini 563 - Fish Monkey God (ROCKS FALL EVERYONE DIES)

[QuantumFruit]

@mikeburnfire: I don't find the slip especially portentous - the purple cloak, the attacks based on flawed premises - that's what bothered me. (just thought I'd address that)

@Capricious: Okay, I think I believe you. Any theories on why roffman is misled, though? Like, what would lead him to be misled? Are you saying town people have purple cloaks so if roffman's town he has a purple cloak (logically, in terms of camouflaging into scum, wouldn't really work - but who knows?...)? What is the alternate scum group called?

For now,

/uncows: Capricious

. I don't especially want this fellow to get lynched at the moment; not that he's in danger any more.

...As to roffman, perhaps he's gone somewhere? I'm in another game with him and he hasn't posted in a while (though I can't remember whether he's dead or not ).

[mikeburnfire]

I think the device's CURRENT owner is mafia.

[roffman]

i'm here, i just don't think anything cap has accused me of as being relevant, i have fully revealed my role, and now it is up to you to decide who to lynch

[Capricious]

i'm here, i just don't think anything cap has accused me of as being relevant, i have fully revealed my role, and now it is up to you to decide who to lynch

roffman, you seem to be looking at this as the lynch of the day is either you or me. You would only think this if you:

have not read my posts

have not read half the game

[Capricious]

@mikeburnfire: I don't find the slip especially portentous - the purple cloak, the attacks based on flawed premises - that's what bothered me. (just thought I'd address that)

@Capricious: Okay, I think I believe you. Any theories on why roffman is misled, though? Like, what would lead him to be misled? Are you saying town people have purple cloaks so if roffman's town he has a purple cloak (logically, in terms of camouflaging into scum, wouldn't really work - but who knows?...)? What is the alternate scum group called?

For now,

/uncows: Capricious

. I don't especially want this fellow to get lynched at the moment; not that he's in danger any more.

...As to roffman, perhaps he's gone somewhere? I'm in another game with him and he hasn't posted in a while (though I can't remember whether he's dead or not ).

I'm not saying purple cloaks are town, I am saying without any other basis, they are equally likely to be scum as any others. I have pointed out roffman's discrepancies too many times. I don't know what the alternate scum group is called.

[armlx]

i'm here, i just don't think anything cap has accused me of as being relevant, i have fully revealed my role, and now it is up to you to decide who to lynch

roffman, you seem to be looking at this as the lynch of the day is either you or me. You would only think this if you:

have not read my posts

have not read half the game

Weren't me

Fixed.[/b]

[windkirby]

After thinking about it, I think there's a big enough chance Cap is telling the truth that lynching him is probably a bad idea.

uncows

Right now I'm thinking about going after one of the other purple robies, but now that Cap's made the believable claim, I think perhaps there might be something weird going on with the colors. I'm going to think about it for a little bit more before pursuing someone else's lynch...

[armlx]

/uncows

as well. Ongoing events have caused me to rethink my stance in light of the claim.

Given this, and the mod comment that everyone has a different cloak color, I'm liable to think someone is lying. As ration was also mod told indigo, LAL may apply here. Have to think some more though, but a

FOS ration

is in order.

[Capricious]

/uncows

as well. Ongoing events have caused me to rethink my stance in light of the claim.

Given this, and the mod comment that everyone has a different cloak color, I'm liable to think someone is lying. As ration was also mod told indigo, LAL may apply here. Have to think some more though, but a

FOS ration

is in order.

What has caused the shift in your opinion? Your previous stance was basically, Cap needs to die... Cap must die... Cap should die... die... Die.. It's strange that you are willing to consider other possibilities now, namely the logic that the mod or someone is perhaps lying. Could it be that the shift was made because the general opinion became that I should not be lynched?

[armlx]

Its more the fact lynching claimed cops D1 is typically sub-par.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Hi, just posting to let people know that I've unfortunately come down with a stomach bug, so my contributions may well be sporadic for the next few days.

[QuantumFruit]

I'm not saying purple cloaks are town, I am saying without any other basis, they are equally likely to be scum as any others.

But we have some evidence, either one way or the other, but we must figure that out.

As far as the alternate scum group - how do you know it's a scum group? Does it say "You have find out who's a member of the alternate scum group?" in your role PM? That seems a bit unlikely in this game. Needs more color.

--

Also, I had an idea about Cap's claim. Don't you guys find it kind of strange that it's only an "alternate scum group" not the Dancing Squad? What if there isn't actually this alternate scum group, but we believe Cap and think there is (conveniently, Cap does not know the name of this alternate scum group). It becomes a plausible role claim and the real cop role cannot truly counterclaim if they can investigate to find Dancing Squad.

I don't know what I think of that idea yet, but I thought it was something to think about.

[armlx]

Quantam, I have thought of that. I believe it was pulled recently by Rosso in a game that is ongoing. Its worth considering he is lying, but I think we can wait on his lynch for 1 day definitely until we have more info ie. number of night kills, 2+ alignments revealed, etc.

[Capricious]

There is a town, some scum, and a group of people that can win with the town, their regualr scum group, or their alternate scum group.

Quantum, why do you not read?

[armlx]

Umm, given the mod post at the start of the game says alternate scum group, I'm very inclined to now think Cap pulled his role from there, the Cult part from MoS's role name, etc.

/cows Capricious

If he is an alt. group cop, we learn there is an alt group for sure. If he's not, which is what I'm assuming at this point, he's either a member of the alt group confirming it, or just plain scum which puts the odds of a cult a bit lower.

[windkirby]

Umm, given the mod post at the start of the game says alternate scum group, I'M Very inclined to now think Cap pulled his role from there, the Cult part from MoS's role name, etc.

/cows Capricious

if he is an alt. Group cop, we learn there is an alt group for sure. If he's not, which is what I'm assuming at this point, he's either a member of the alt group confirming it, or just plain scum which puts the odds of a cult a bit lower.

armlx, I'm pretty sure you're a lyncher or something... All you've done is go after one person, Capricious, never questioning any other player. Seriously not townie behavior.

[armlx]

I've stated this all. I believe Capricious' responses to Roffman's info were pretty desperate, he got lucky when Roffman started tripping over his soft info, and now he is claiming by pulling info from the opening post.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

/cows Capricious

I'm not exactly happy with how he's playing. It's giving me bad vibes.

[xyzzy]

if you don't post tomorrow because you're in Marathon Day I won't yell

/cows count number seven

Capricious: (armlx, andersonw, Capricious, DizzyIzzyB13)
serous: (Mikeburnfire)




Someone: (Someone else)
Someone else: (Someone)
Not voting: Tyfo, Serous, AniX, roffman, Ration, QuantumFruit, windkirby

[mikeburnfire]

/uncows /cows: Capricious

[armlx]

7 people are not voting 15 pages into D1. This should not happen.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

You are one of them. Care to put your vote where your mouth is?

[armlx]

if you don't post tomorrow because you're in Marathon Day I won't yell

/cows count number seven

Capricious: (

armlx,

andersonw, Capricious, DizzyIzzyB13)
serous: (Mikeburnfire)

I am not one of them.

Anix

is though.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

I stand corrected, though it's criminal that two people with such similar names are in the same game. :p

[armlx]

I stand corrected, though it's criminal that two people with such similar names are in the same game. :p

You are not the first member to make this mistake. Nor the member who is the most familiar with both Anix and I to make the mistake.