Reread of the game:
6- RoN complains about Day-starts. I find the complaint stupid, but okay.
8- SirT votes RoN.
12- DP votes RoN for complaining.
13- Alabasca votes RoN, unvotes, says it is L-1 (it isn't), then random vote someone else.
- We don't need to random vote anymore, this sounds a bit too cowardly :-/
14- GW chides RoN for the fury. I am particularly liking it at this point, many people are choosing to react (DP, SirT, Ooba), or avoiding to react (Alabasca) post 6. I don't like this post from GW for some reason.
15 - Armix votes Ala for the random vote.
16 - Ration comes for Ala's defense. (not a newb)
17 - RW jokes the whole thing.
23 - alabasca gives a reason for random votes. I think that the discussion around RoN was good enough to start the game, though.
27 - DW comes and says nothing.
30 - Gorckat votes Alabasca
32-37 - Alabasca unvotes, explains he thinks Random vote is a safe vote. Armix argues the analogy (I'm with Armix). Alabasca takes the position of "don't wanna be lynched" townie.
40-46 - Gorckat and SirT discuss Random.org. Gorckat is correct.
49 - GW cimes in. He is right that a large Random vote discussion is unfruitful.
51 - The questioning is good, but the poetry is annoying.
52 - lol.
55 - non sequitur. Armix found Al suspicious enough to VOTE him. duh.
57, 59 - why is GW answering for RoN here?
71 - spring votes DP for pushing a non-relevant case (in her opinion).
74 - ration unvotes. Why is the vote stupid? because people didn't jump on? Says will post later. Me no like, there is plenty of discussion already (DP questioning RoN, spring voting DP, armix voting ala, etc).
77 - GW lurkervotes RoN.
78 - armix lurkervotes RoN
79 - DW chimes in, says nothing.
86 - Ration says that RoN is scummy (why?) but he won't be voting now (I see).
94 - Gorkcat accuses Ala of being ambivalent towards the RoN wagon. I think Ala is looking more like a newb by now. I'm more concerned about Ration.
99 - RoN says "I'm here, will post later", armix immediately unvotes. Not earth shattering, but I would wait the "post later" part to come into being, I guess.
101 - Ala OMGUS gorkat, and admits it. :-/ don't know what to make of it.
104 - Ala backtracks.
105 - Ration gets replaced. That might explain his behavior, I guess.
107 - Armix votes Ala for backtracking.
108 - RW does not jump straight into the infant Ala bandwagon. Personal meta says that Scum-RW is more vote happy.
113,115 - Gorkcat pressures Ala
122 - Rogueben joins the game. Like his initial analysis, resonates with what I'm feeling right now.
123 - Spring says lurkers know what they risk. unfortunately, in the current meta, lurkers risk nothing. I think the town gains more than loses by taking a harder instance on lurkers.
125 - Whoa! While I agree with RW sentiment, this was unexpectedly aggressive, specially given the meekness feeling I was getting from RW.
126 - (post by ala) I'm not sure if this is wish-washiness, or failing to read the thread.
127 - Rogueben criticizes spring. I agree with spring that the meta is NOT an argument. Metas are good for shaping existing cases, but I don't like cases built entirely on metas. RoN's "speech" should be questioned by its relevance to this game, not by its relation to previous games.
131 - springs defense. I think she did a good job of defending herself, and I agree with her position on metas.
133 -
DP uses OMGUS to defend
"What have you done to hunt scum?"
Well, DP, she is attacking your case, for starters.
136 -
GW defends his RoN vote. There is a lot more going on, but he takes no part in that.
139 - Gorkcat lurkervotes me. Boohoohoo.
140 - Rogueben mirrors my current thoughts on GW
147 - Ala decides to post insightfull content, goes on a full barrage of criticism (but "Now, that being said, I don't think you had bad intentions") against rogueben, but decides to FoS gorkcat instead with an onliner...
150 - Gorkcat noted the same thing. Of course, since that implicates him a bit, he blames the difference on the lurkervote targets, not the voters. :-/
156 - If DP is going to post in annoying poems, he shouldn't be complaining when people don't answer to his questions, specially when those are posed as affirmations (like the one in the second paragraph).
I find posting in poetry like this an arrogant exercise, that does not help the town one bit. I'm not answering questions in poetry form.
163 - I wanna see GW talk about the game. You guys talk about lurkers, but this one is lurking in plain sight.
166 - RW votes DP for pushing spring too much and the poetry posting.
167, 168 - Seems nor dean nor GW are reading the game. GW, there is one vote (RW) on DP that mentions the rhyming.
169 - Alabaska defends DP. Is this the first time that he takes a firm stand?
170 - Oh, rogueben noted that as well.
Player analysis coming next.
