Mini 570, A Small Town in Italy Mafia, Over

[Awesome Pants]

........How would a no lynch give the scum a better chance to hit the doc?
If we lynch scum (presuming there are 3 mafia) the mafia still have the same chance of hitting doc, but if we lynch a townie we narrow down the possibilities for the scum.
And if we put scum (or the doc) close to lynch they will obviously claim doc and who would lynch them then and would the real doc claim (I think not) as that would give the mafia their nk.
We risk a whole lot less with a no lynch than a lynch.

I guess so, I was just thinking that without lynching we'll be basically trading an investigation for the life of a confirmed townie and won't get much info out of the day. Of course, I guess you'll eventualy hit scum but with the numbers of people left so high the scum could very well manage to get lucky and take out the doc and you before you manage to get a guilty investigation.

Basically, I think that you should base your investigations around any info we have, rather than doing it systematically or randomly and therefore having a longer day today might be a good idea. Whether we get enough info to decide on a lynch today is another issue, but I don't think we should completly rule out the idea of a lynch or else the discussion might not to tend to flow as easily, and any info we get probably won't be of terrible use.

[thevampireofdusseldorf]

Well looks like we won't be able to get to night before the mod comes back so discussion is certainly on the agenda untill then.

[thevampireofdusseldorf]

And I apoligize for perhaps ruining this game by my cop claim so early but I am still very new to this game. And by no means do I think that scum have this game lost yet and would hope they still give it their all.

[SensFan]

And I apoligize for perhaps ruining this game by my cop claim so early but I am still very new to this game. And by no means do I think that scum have this game lost yet and would hope they still give it their all.

In all honesty, I would think any scum would be more frustrated with the Mod than you. I don't think that a Mafia RB by any means cancels out a Cop+Doc.

[Niv]

the sykedoc Replaces Ration Vote count

sykedoc - Lalmtreasteek, avinashv
mikeydaman - Erratus Apathos
No Lynch - thevampireofdusseldorf

Mod returns on mar 17. repeated apologies.

[sykedoc]

Could we retract the Ration votes (aka my votes) because he wasn't lurking, he just wasn't here.

[sykedoc]

Apologies for the doublepost but what i meant was
Unvote me if you'd be so kind =p

Also, i'll answer any questions you wanted Ration to answer, i'll try to read back on it.

[MightyFireball]

Welcome to the game, sykedoc.

I think we should at least consider a lynch today. By relying solely on cop investigations and doctor protections, the game has been given over to luck. Will the cop get a guilty result before the scum find the doctor? I really don't like it when games fall into this pattern, because it's no longer fun for anyone that doesn't have a power role.

[Erratus Apathos]

Killa I stil want answer to this

Why o you think Miscounting the votes is a scum tell?

[Prof. Guppy]

Hello skyedoc.

Ration didn't really have a lot to offer us. If you could, please read back over the thread and see what you can deduce. I think this town could use your fresh insight.

[sykedoc]

As far as i've seen, he was being not so helpful, dodgey, etc.
It looks like he was treating the game as a side thing, and just ignoring it unless he was going to be lynched.

Currently, i'm holding my vote because alot of the accusations seem a bit off kilter to me. I dont go off anything that isn't at least solid enough for me to reason a lynching.

[killa seven]

I don't think it's likly that lalm is a gf either, just that we shouldn't rule it out that there is a fgf because it there is one and we ruled it uot then we lose. Of coufrse until we are in Lylo (assumming three scum) we should consider him a Confirmed townie.

fos ap

vote hoping so far.. and hammering occult after he had been hammered. (as pointed out by the mod)[/b]

I think you that mean me here ap never change his vote or voted occult

Vote hoping is, by itself a stupd thing to use as a scum tell espicialy day one. presuring people into posting isthe Town's est weapon and voting is one way og getting that done.

Why o you think Miscounting the votes is a scum tell?

it makes you look like you jumped on the wagon just to save face, hammering someone thats allready dead doesnt look good.

[sykedoc]

Theres always a chance that hammering tailors to something role specific. I'm not implying that he shouldn't be cast with suspicion but its something to consider

[thevampireofdusseldorf]

As far as i've seen, he was being not so helpful, dodgey, etc.
It looks like he was treating the game as a side thing, and just ignoring it unless he was going to be lynched.

He made 2 post all game and was replaced in another I belive so I'm not so happy with your coment ignoring it unless he was going to be lynched as he was never a possible lynch at all, this seems a rather strange comment from a replacement could you please explain this?

[sykedoc]

I dunno, I'm just taking a guess at why he might've been antisocial in here. It isn't really good game etiquette. You know what i mean?

Im not used to replacing people so excuse me if i seem a bit weird.
=P

[Lalmtreasteek]

I will read and post my games tomorrow. Too tired tonight bahhh

[Erratus Apathos]

it makes you look like you jumped on the wagon just to save face, hammering someone thats allready dead doesnt look good.

Okay than fear enough reason to suspect someone for voting after the hammer but I'd would like to point ut that i was in fact the seveth vote.

Voted occult:
vampire
sensfan
guppy
avinash
killa
firebll
me

Didnt vote occult":
occult
lalm
mikey
ratoin
awsome

I'm pretty sure this is acurate but if this is wrong and on of the above fice voted for occult give me the post number pleas

[Lalmtreasteek]

Theres always a chance that hammering tailors to something role specific. I'm not implying that he shouldn't be cast with suspicion but its something to consider

I don't think hammering counts if the person is already dead. I just want to say that.

I'm still think about vampire's no lynch plan. I don't think I have ever thought of this kind of situation.

Definitely it's good to try to make information so that the cop can find scum more easily, though I think that if vampire uses his "gut" even now he would have a good chance of finding a scum.

I still need to think about my suspicion now. If I'm voting Ration-sykedoc I will not unvote at this moment.

[sykedoc]

-_-

Its annoying coming in under someone who acts like a jerk and casts suspicion on himself.

Anyway. If theres anything that will help you change your mind, you can ask me questions.

[Lalmtreasteek]

So, that says that I act like a jerk? Or Ration is a jerk?

I am sorry I brought suspicion to myself. But I think I also had some GOOD reason to be frustrated also.

[thevampireofdusseldorf]

I dont see the whole point of reading into two post of someone who quickly got replaced (in other games as well).

But I do find it strange sykedoc seems to be drawing the most conclusions from these two posts.

Its annoying coming in under someone who acts like a jerk and casts suspicion on himself.

[sykedoc]

So, that says that I act like a jerk? Or Ration is a jerk?

I am sorry I brought suspicion to myself. But I think I also had some GOOD reason to be frustrated also.

Sorry I was talking about Ration. I apoligize if you thought i was reffering to you.

[MightyFireball]

I'm going to be away for the weekend, and I won't be able to post until Sunday night. Sorry, all.

[Prof. Guppy]

chrrip, chrrip, chrrip, chrrip.

Somebody want to get rid of those freaking crickets?

[sykedoc]

*whips out a handgun and shoots the crickets*

Happy?