I guess so, I was just thinking that without lynching we'll be basically trading an investigation for the life of a confirmed townie and won't get much info out of the day. Of course, I guess you'll eventualy hit scum but with the numbers of people left so high the scum could very well manage to get lucky and take out the doc and you before you manage to get a guilty investigation.thevampireofdusseldorf wrote:........How would a no lynch give the scum a better chance to hit the doc?
If we lynch scum (presuming there are 3 mafia) the mafia still have the same chance of hitting doc, but if we lynch a townie we narrow down the possibilities for the scum.
And if we put scum (or the doc) close to lynch they will obviously claim doc and who would lynch them then and would the real doc claim (I think not) as that would give the mafia their nk.
We risk a whole lot less with a no lynch than a lynch.
Basically, I think that you should base your investigations around any info we have, rather than doing it systematically or randomly and therefore having a longer day today might be a good idea. Whether we get enough info to decide on a lynch today is another issue, but I don't think we should completly rule out the idea of a lynch or else the discussion might not to tend to flow as easily, and any info we get probably won't be of terrible use.