Designer Mafia 2007 - Game Over, Final Scene Posted!

[Thyroidectomy]

why havent you answered all of the questions regarding you today?

Where were these posted?

Can you still sale tickets?

Yes.

Why did you say that the Fair (and I assume your role) had nothing to do with Shanba becoming King, then when UA called you out, you said you would not comment at this time if targetting Shanba made him kill? Why wont you comment?

No. You don't understand at all. I did target Shanba last night. The Ren Fair still has nothing to do with it.

[UltimaAvalon]

Belg - In Kingmaker, the Kingmaker can be either Scum or Town. I'm not saying he's scum or town, I'm saying he's lying

Thyroid - There's a lot of questions that you refuse to answer, I've noticed. Not today, but over the course of the game. You shot them down by saying you weren't able to answer questions about it. That seemed acceptable. Now it seems you have multiple abilities. Are you saying you're not allowed to answer any question about any of your "pro-town" abilities?

[ZONEACE]

Why didnt you tell us about the role yesterday? So far red/teal/yellow all sound Star Trek like. We all know what happens to the man in red shirt. I would like to know the other colors.

thats not a terrible thought, except there aren't 6 star trek uniform colors are there? Theres Yellow, Red, Teal/Blue and thats it.

[Thyroidectomy]

I'd prefer not to if I still don't have to. There are a lot of tricks up my sleeve, and I'd rather here a good solid reason of why this theory makes sense before I spill them.

[ZONEACE]

I'd prefer not to if I still don't have to. There are a lot of tricks up my sleeve, and I'd rather here a good solid reason of why this theory makes sense before I spill them.

EXCEPT YOU KEEP PULLING ABILITIES OUT OF YOUR ASS WITHOUT EXPLANATION


Start talking or start dying.

[Twomz]

1) I could have sworn it was UA that said something about submitting a kingmaker who was a hero... If I have time later I'll look back over Day 2 /sigh.

2)

Twomz, do you have any questions for me specificly or do you just speculate? Also, any comments on your "living dead" state?

It's probably nothing really... when I saw the "pair of pants" SK and started thinking about it I looked into your posting record... saw that this is really the only game you've ever been in, and that you didn't /in in the signup thread, just appeared a little ways down... and assumed it was similar to Pheobus/Blind Pheonix from Mafiascum mafia mafia (link). But after I looked closer, Aimee got replaced and you kept on posting... which wouldn't make sense if you were her. And you joined in June, which was a while before design roles went through.

In all honesty, I got my hopes up, but then when I went back to check I realized that it was very unlikely, so there is really nothing for you to worry about.

And I'm not living dead, I'm alive. Game kinda got dumped on a large workload though, I had just enough games going... /sigh.

3)

Belg - In Kingmaker, the Kingmaker can be either Scum or Town. I'm not saying he's scum or town, I'm saying he's lying

This is false. The kingmaker was town. The KING could be either town or scum. That's the reason it was so important the kingmaker was paying attention and wasn't a complete twit, because they had to a) chose a protown player and b) chose someone who would make a good decision.

4) While it is true that "king for a day" does sound in line with the whole "ren faire" thing, it wouldn't matter because not enough people bought tickets. I'd still prefer if Thyroid said what his role actually did instead of skirting around the subject.

5) BTW, speaking of thyroid, that's who I protected N1. I figured since he spouting off about his special ability all day, someone was going to try to take a shot at him... and I guess I was right (unless both killing groups targeted me... and if so, you bastards).

[UltimaAvalon]

Belg - In Kingmaker, the Kingmaker can be either Scum or Town. I'm not saying he's scum or town, I'm saying he's lying

This is false. The kingmaker was town. The KING could be either town or scum. That's the reason it was so important the kingmaker was paying attention and wasn't a complete twit, because they had to a) chose a protown player and b) chose someone who would make a good decision.

Forgive me, for I've never played Kingmaker, but I think I read somewhere that a scum could be chosen to be Kingmaker if the Kingmaker was killed. If I am mistaken, then meh.

[Twomz]

No, a new kingmaker was chosen by the old kingmaker amoungst the remaining townies. If there were no more townies, the game went back to normal majority lynch (cops, docs, scum, ect couldn't be kingmaker, only townies).

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

Guys Guys,

JDodge killed Nocmen.

Discuss.

[curiouskarmadog]

is that a guess?

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

No, that is an "I know so"

And I forgot

Vote: JDodge

[stark]

You want to explain, kscope?

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

I designed the Grim role carried by nocmen. The one who kills the Grim is forced to say OH THE HORROR! each time he posts.

[curiouskarmadog]

good enough for me,

vote Jodge

[Twomz]

[quote="KaleiÐoscøpe"]I designed the Grim role carried by nocmen. The one who kills the Grim is forced to say OH THE HORROR! each time he posts.[/quote]
That's good enough for me... how many is it to lynch today?

prevote: JDodge

JDodge, what do you have to say about this?

Everyone, how do you feel about MoS mixing up the roles we sent in? Likely? Unlikely? Fair? Unfair?

[UltimaAvalon]

@JDodge - Busted

@Twomz - Define "mixing up"

[Thyroidectomy]

[quote="KaleiÐoscøpe"]Guys Guys,

JDodge killed Nocmen.

Discuss.[/quote]

The idiocy of this post is incredible. Kudos.

I'm not going to vote Jdodge for obvious reasons.

[UltimaAvalon]

Know something we don't, Thyroid?

[Thyroidectomy]

Know something we don't, Thyroid?

How many role abilities do you think I have, exactly?

I don't have to know anything about the situation to come up with a solid reason why Kscope's claim was horrendous.

[UltimaAvalon]

Well, I don't think the claim was bad, I just don't like the idea of him outing someone who's just as likely to be vig as scum.

[Belgarion]

[quote="Thyroidectomy"][quote="KaleiÐoscøpe"]Guys Guys,

JDodge killed Nocmen.

Discuss.[/quote]

The idiocy of this post is incredible. Kudos.

I'm not going to vote Jdodge for obvious reasons.[/quote]

[quote="Thyroidectomy"][quote="UltimaAvalon"]Know something we don't, Thyroid?[/quote]

How many role abilities do you think I have, exactly?

I don't have to know anything about the situation to come up with a solid reason why Kscope's claim was horrendous.[/quote]

Thro, why do you think the claim is bad? Pretend I am a common man, and spell it out for me why is it horrendous that Jododge killed nocman? If you think Kscope is lying, why? If that answer is because he is scum, why isnt your vote on him?

Jdodge, thoughts on Kscope's post?

B-

[Thyroidectomy]

Well, I don't think the claim was bad, I just don't like the idea of him outing someone who's just as likely to be vig as scum.

I didn't want to say it, but now that it has been said I might as well.

Jdodge is likely to be a vig. I cannot conceive scum Jdodge killing Nocmen. Kscope is likely to be another power role. I don't think Kscope would have claimed that if he was scum (he tends to be a rather safe scum player.) By Kscope outing himself, he's put two nightkill targets on two possible power roles when it was entirely unecessary, and made it possible for Jdodge to be lynched. (hint: he shouldn't.)

Here's an extremely obvious situation to any vig who isn't Jdodge: Shoot him tonight, as you now know that he's scum.

But I don't think that will happen, because I believe Jdodge to be a vig, if we have one.

[mneme]

The "grim" HORROR bit was clearly in the role; note that Nocmen hinted at it Day 1.

I'd vote for Jdodge, except that my intuition already lead me to vote for him today. Vote stays.

[mneme]

The argument that JDodge is as likely to be vig as scum is the one that's horrendous. No killer is-ever- as likely to be vig as scum, without an innocent cop investigation, at least. Moreover, even with JDodge's stated beliefs, vig-killing nocmen would have horrid play.

JDodge is scum who thought he could get Protown Nocmen lynched yesterday on the strength of "inconsistencies" in his meeping role. He couldn't, and fearing that Nocmen was a cop, he killed him. But unbeknownst to him, Nocmen was actually playing a poison pill role, which tries to get itself nightkilled to reveal a scum, so he's screwed. It isn't hard to figure, and kscope's reveal was exactly correct.

[Shanba]

Well, I don't think the claim was bad, I just don't like the idea of him outing someone who's just as likely to be vig as scum.

I didn't want to say it, but now that it has been said I might as well.

Jdodge is likely to be a vig. I cannot conceive scum Jdodge killing Nocmen. Kscope is likely to be another power role. I don't think Kscope would have claimed that if he was scum (he tends to be a rather safe scum player.) By Kscope outing himself, he's put two nightkill targets on two possible power roles when it was entirely unecessary, and made it possible for Jdodge to be lynched. (hint: he shouldn't.)

Here's an extremely obvious situation to any vig who isn't Jdodge: Shoot him tonight, as you now know that he's scum.

But I don't think that will happen, because I believe Jdodge to be a vig, if we have one.

I agree with the substance of this - it came as a large surprise to me that Nocmen was dead with apparently no other kills (except my fake one, and a fake of my fake). There is, however, the matter of the missing kill. If Jdodge is a vig, and twomz, who all but claimed doc, was dead that night, how was the kill stopped?