Nudude wrote:If you read my posts, I've been saying I am convinced that Thanatos is an SK, and presented my case, and that if people didn't agree with that, to do their own investigating.
Can you explain why he killed someone who was in the game a little over 24 hours after they entered the game, while ignoring a slew of suspicious characters?
I already explained this. I wasn't sure who to kill, so I made a stupid choice and killed a townie who appeared harmless, but had done something I had felt was scummy right before night, putting him at L-1. I didn't think we had anything to lose, so I killed him. It was rash, I know.
Can you explain how he knew he'd been roled - blocked? My understanding is that most of the time you don't told why your attempt fails. I could be a GF, there could be a back - up doc, there could be many reasons, but he was sure he'd been role - blocked....how?
I highly doubt there is a nurse in a 12 person Mini, and as far as I know, the GF isn't NK immune. Besides that, I admitted to being a power role just before night, which would mean that a mafia role blocker would block me regardless. A RB is a far smaller coincidence than a Nurse protecting you or you being NK Immune, which you aren't admitting to anyways.
Can you explain why you said that an SK is counted as a townie in an end game situation, when this thread:
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... +killer%2A
Would seem to indicate that is false? The only true way to know a win condition is by reading your role PM, but it's clear that a SK is not consdiered a townie in an end game situation....why mis - represent the facts?
My dear Nudude, you just proved me correct. You see, this situation could NOT occur unless a SK was considered as town for endgame. What I mean by endgame is the point where either all anti-town roles are eliminated (which, in this case, an SK is treated as diffrent from scum or townn) or when the scum outnumber the town, which is the situation you're talking about. Now, if there are 1 scum, 1 town, and 1 SK, and the SK is treated as scum, the town loses. However, your link PROVES that this is not the case. It's a difficult situation for the townie remaining, but it is not an automatic loss. In fact, we've learned the way around it from that link. No lynch.
Can you explain why you finished off DS yesterday before he had a chance to say anything, a stark contrast to today where your calling for calm, rational consideration. I agree that people should take their time and analyse the info.....so why did you yourself rush to the lynch yesterday? Because you were sure he was scum? How is me being sure your scum any different, except that I'm calling for people to prove me wrong, not neccesarily agree with me and rush to the lynch?
1. I dislike DS' style of playing, and thought he was scummy for a long time.
2. that day had lasted for months. This one is barely a week old.
3. I was losing intrest in playing Mafia, and wanted something to spice it up a bit. Moving along in the day was the best bet.
In summary,
1. His best guess D1 was a guy with four posts and who had replaced into the game a little over 24 hours before the lynch, despite there being more suspicious characters.
I had no reasonable suspicions, except for Liam, which I already explained, and wanted to explore a safe option. I chose him SPECIFICLY for the reasons you listed
2. He cannot possibly have known he was role - blocked.
Know for sure and being a logical conclusion are two diffrent things
3. He claimed that an SK is counted as a townie in an end game situation. This is false, unless a role PM says otherwise.
I just proved it true. Well, you did.
4. He killed DS before he had a chance to open his mouth. It turned out he was scum, but I'd hardly call that a carefully considered act. I feel if your going to ask for carefully considered acts, then you should also carefully consider how you act, but twice this game you've been quite brash with your decisions.
It wasn't carefully considered, but it was logical for my thinking, and I'm not exactly unhappy with the choice
Just so were clear, I have no problem with everyone taking their time to look things over. I'm just saying I'm pretty damned sure he is scum, and I'm presenting my case. I encourage everyone to present their own.