Newbie 531: (Game Over)

[SlySly]

so if you consider the no lynch you have to evaluate it against the lynching option:
-lynch: 50% chance to make it to day 3
-no lynch: 8.3% chance to make it to day 3

can we let this go because you are completely off on this point.

No, my point 100% is completely right and that is...

mislynch = 0% chance of town win
no lynch > 0% chance of town win

It is indisputable.

[soupfly]

so if you consider the no lynch you have to evaluate it against the lynching option:
-lynch: 50% chance to make it to day 3
-no lynch: 8.3% chance to make it to day 3

can we let this go because you are completely off on this point.

No, my point 100% is completely right and that is...

mislynch = 0% chance of town win
no lynch > 0% chance of town win

It is indisputable.

Thanks for not reading my post

of course a no lynch is better than a mislynch.

and then ignoring the main point of what i was writing.

[bird1111]

Vote Count:
soupfly (1): Apyadg
Apyadg (1): soupfly
Superfly (1): SlySly
SlySly (1): Superfly

Not voting (1): Tlp

With 5 alive it is 3 to lynch.

[SlySly]

of course a no lynch is better than a mislynch.

and then ignoring the main point of what i was writing.

I didn't ignore this. I just commented about you saying my initial point was incorrect which is untrue.

[SlySly]

I did not quote you. I have never said I quoted you. Instead, before said summary I put in [ quote ] brackets I said this

If you want me to summarize the last post it would be

What do you think [ quote ] brackets are for? Do you think they are for pointing out stock tips or for quoting someone?

[soupfly]

bah, this game has really died down.

well i've stated my case as to why i think the cop claim needs to be resolved today. do you guys agree?

[Tlp]

aye, but for me its between slysly and apy

This game indeed died quite a bit

Vote : Slysly

[bird1111]

Prodded Superfly.

[SlySly]

bah, this game has really died down.

well i've stated my case as to why i think the cop claim needs to be resolved today. do you guys agree?

You are right Soup, we have been messing around long enough. Super is scummy in his own right but I think you are lying about being the cop.

unvote

vote:Soupfly

[soupfly]

if you guys insist on going for slysly then you'll have my vote but i still think that the most prudent action is to lynch the fake cop.

fine, if that's what you guys want to do.

unvote: apy

vote: SlySly

[Tlp]

Soup, I just haven't heared ennough from apy because he's suddenly "gone" and this game won't go anywhere then.

[soupfly]

well i believe my vote was the hammer so let's hope that we're right and slysly is scum.

[bird1111]

You string up SlySly, then check his house, to find it full of weapons and things to distract people with. This means he must have been the mafia's roleblocker.

SlySly, Mafia Roleblocker, lynched Day 2.

[bird1111]

Apyadg never picked up his prod, so I am going to replace him.

[bird1111]

YvonneSeer replaces Apyadg

[bird1111]

Tlp died. He was a townie.

Day 3 begins, with 3 alive it is 2 to lynch.

[YvonneSeer]

vote: soupfly

Guilty.

[Superfly]

Just posting to show you guys I am here.

SlySly was scum, as I thought.

Will make a longer post tonight if soupfly posts by then.

[soupfly]

vote: YvonneSeer

i am the real cop and for good measure i did use my night choice to confirm apy/yvonneseer's guilt.

just look at the post by slysly in which he slightly criticizes apy and then tries to point out how guilty i am. it was quite a blatant attempt to divert guilt towards me. you may think that it was too obvious, but considering how slysly played in this game it was consistent with his overall bad play.

i already made

my case

against apy so it applies to yvonneseer also.

its all up to you superfly.

[Superfly]

Lets end this.

I will vote Yvonne/apyadg, because of these reasons

1. Why am I still alive? I am the doc and night 1 I was roleblocked, I thought I was pretty obvious and expected to die tonight. Apyadg knew that his partner roleblocked me and I was one of the main reasons his buddy got lynched.

However apyadg got replaced by Yvonne. If one would guess the doc based on posts only, tlp would have been more likely. He was the one always trying to fit in, being careful, yet not too loud. Like a doc.

2. The 3 people that pushed towards lynching battousai were me, sly and apy. I had an excuse, they didn't.

3. The day started right after apyadg was replaced.

4. SlySly used his crappy logic against soup, who had been playing solid while he spared apyadg, who was careless and would have been easy to bandwagon

5. Apyadg's shitty claim

6. YvonneSeer's lack of content

Vote: YvonneSeer

And even if I am wrong this has still still been a very good first game for me.

[soupfly]

That's a hammer so its game over and town wins because I am the real cop!

Nicely done Superfly!

[bird1111]

You string up YvonneSeer, and then check his house, it is full of weapons and is a perfect place to discuss things. He must have been the mafia goon, which means that the town has won!

YvonneSeer, Mafia Goon, lynched Day 3

Game over, town wins!

Night 1 the Mafia killed Tamuz and blocked Superfly, night 2 YvonneSeer killed Tlp
Night 1 Superfly protected Tamuz, night 2 Superfly protected soupfly
soupfly investigated Tamuz night 1 and YvonneSeer night 2.

Final status:
Superfly, Doc
soupfly, Cop

Dead:
Battousai, Townie, lynched Day 1
Tamuz, Townie, killed Night 1
SlySly, Mafia Roleblocker, lynched Day 2
Tlp, Townie, killed Night 2
YvonneSeer, Mafia Goon, lynched Day 3

Congrats on being the first town to win a Newbie game that I've modded!

[Superfly]

[Mr. Flay]

Interesting to see a town win. How do people feel about the balance of a Pie E7 game, particularly compared to C9 if you played in one of those before?

[/listmodhijack]

::edit:: Also, bird, could the RB block and kill once the goon was dead? I couldn't tell from your role PMs...

Nevermind, I had that backwards...

[YvonneSeer]

Damn, I came back from uni too late to post my case. I didn't expect that superfly would place his vote so quickly. Oh well, it would have been tough for me anyway after some pretty bad scumplay.

But superfly, your reasoning for not being killed Night 2 doesn't make sense. There is no way scum can know that you're the doc based on the roleblock.