Open 56 - Masons and Monks (GAME OVER) before 542

[Oman]

Vote Kuribo

wagon jumping, No?

[kuribo]

Vote Kuribo

wagon jumping, No?

Hardly. And that's a stretch.

I didn't think you were scum, before, but now I'm not so sure.

[Oman]

OMGUS! Nice work there.

Can we please do this right this time?

Vote: Kabenon007

Vote: Thinktank

You know, the fact that both scumgroups went after JDodge makes me think he was on to something and they had to shut him up.

Unvote, Vote: thinktank

Vote Kuribo

wagon jumping, No?

Hardly

You see the problem.

[Samruc]

thinktank: 2 (Flameaxe, kuribo)
TylerJ: 2 (Kabenon007, RossWilliam)
Kabenon007: 1 (farside22)
Kuribo: 1 (Oman)

Not voting: (pwayne66, thinktank, TylerJ, Draux)

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

[kuribo]

Does it really matter which wagon I'm on as long as we get one of those scum? The whole reason the mislynch went down was because we have too many strong scum suspects, and TylerJ decided to hammer. Our bandwagons have been split, with several people getting about half the votes.

I've chosen to deal with the former problem, until Tyler comes around to explain himself.

[pwayne66]

Vote: TylerJ

[farside22]

Mod: I know it is early to ask but how about a prod on Tyler, Draux and Thinktank.

[Samruc]

Done.

[pwayne66]

Just for giggles, lets review the cases for each of our pet suspects (tyler,
thinktank, Kabenon007, Kuribo) I going with Tyler, so I will say this:

1) Hasn't paid attention to the game. Several examples can be provided if need be.
2) Desperate to find anywhere to land his vote. First it was thinktank because he was sure that Flameaxe was right, and then Flameaxe himself for claiming day cop.
3) Hammers somebody that he obviously had doubts about when we were waiting for a claim, consider:

please explain the votes on LP.

Farside offers up a reason. And LP's status is elevated to L-1. TylerJ's Contribution?

holy smokes, somethings not right with this picture, well then again, we are at a deadline.

I would love to know what "wasn't right". Of course, whatever it is, he manages to not make a stand one way or another by dismissing it in that same sentence.

...but lets continue with the same post:

But before I do a hammer (which I highly doubt I will), I will have to reread.

He "highly doubts" that he will hammer but seems to think that "before I do a hammer" is an appropriate beginning to this sentence. It is as if the exact opposite were true and he knew he would hammer but wanted to make it appear that he was earnestly torn on the subject.

thirty five minutes later...

For his lame vote on thinktank and his wierd evaluation on himself I am considering it...


Arrghh... what the heck. vote:lutinetpowell

He is considering it... Somehow we are expected to believe that he posts in real time, unable to remove his, " I am considering it..." and "Arrghh... what the heck" prior to making his post to kill LP. I think it is much more likely that he is making yet another attempt to remind us that his is uncertain. That way, when LP turns up townie, he doesn't look quiet so opportunistic.

[TylerJ]

Why I did what I did....

Because of my lack of activity due to work and school starting back up and play practice, I had forgotten why LP seemed suspicious. That was why I reread.

When I reread I found that LP was infact scummy. I didn't think about letting him claim because it just wasn't on my mind. Contrary to what pwayne says, I wasn't going for the uncertain look, I wasn't going for any look. I just voted because we were on a deadline and he was scummy. Granted I thought others were scummy, but I figured I should put my vote somewhere that would do good (unfortunately we all see that it wasn't that good).

I regret making a rash decision on the vote, I realize I should have waited for a claim and thought about it a little more, but what is done is done.

[kabenon007]

I agree with pwayne. He wouldn't type argh, he would just say it if it were truly what he were feeling. He therefore has some reason to type "argh" and pwayne hit it on the head.

[TylerJ]

I wrote arghh because I had changed my mind... I could be a little set in my ways sometimes...

So I would disagree with both of you.

[RossWilliam]

If we were having this game through spoken word, the argh would be totally non-important. But the fact that you needed to type it makes it seem like you were trying to act like you really really didn't want to cast that last closing vote, when in reality you were probably overjoyed someone else was getting the boot over your scummy self. I agree 100% with pwayne. You were trying to prove a point.

[LutenitPowwel]

Mod - Edited

[Samruc]

Powwel, you are lynched. Please don't post in the game.

[Samruc]

I had obviously missed adding this to the rules, my mistake. From now on, there is a rule 15.

[15] When you are dead, don't post in the game. (A simple "Bah, go town" is ok.)

[Oman]

I thought that rule was pretty obvious, myself.

Kuribo needs more death, then again so does Tyler (Pwayne's case was good, but I've been burned before by him).

I'm considering Tyler, as his reasons (read pwayne's post) are much more scummy than Kuribo's (who is still scummy).

Unvote

Vote TylerJ, IGMEOY: Kuribo

[thinktank]

Does it really matter which wagon I'm on as long as we get one of those scum? The whole reason the mislynch went down was because we have too many strong scum suspects, and TylerJ decided to hammer. Our bandwagons have been split, with several people getting about half the votes.

I've chosen to deal with the former problem, until Tyler comes around to explain himself.

Yes it does matter. You're counteracting you're own argument. You say that you can switch between wagons as long as you nail scum but you said that the mislynch happened because there were too many strong scum suspects? LP was a strong scum scum suspect yet he turned out to be town, you can not switch bandwagons on the reasoning that all strong scum suspects are scum; you're just being flippant.

You've used entirely false logic to justify yourself; accusing others based again on faulty logic and then coming up with poor excuses with switching votes on a whim.

Vote: Kuribo

[thinktank]

P.S I don;t know why i was prodded, I just posted yesterday.

[farside22]

P.S I don;t know why i was prodded, I just posted yesterday.

Sorry that was my fault you just blended in and I didn't even notice you.

I think pwayne66 has a good point, but with Oman and kabonon both on the wagon I just think this is more then what it seems.

[kuribo]

When I reread I found that LP was infact scummy. I didn't think about letting him claim because it just wasn't on my mind.
I regret making a rash decision on the vote, I realize I should have waited for a claim and thought about it a little more, but what is done is done.

How could you have not thought about letting him claim, when he had been ASKED to claim?

And thinktank, if you go back and look, I wasn't on the LP bandwagon.

[kuribo]

And I hardly call it "bandwagon hopping" when for the duration of the game, my vote has rested on either Kabenon or (until just now) thinktank.

FoS: Oman

[Oman]

Go Go OMGUS FoSes!

[kuribo]

Go Go OMGUS FoSes!

Don't try to make it something it's not. It's suspicious when you try to toss BS on someone like you did.

[Oman]

You wagon jumped, I called you, you FoSed me?

Gotta love logic.