In post 1567, BlackVoid wrote:I have no idea who his partner is. But right now, I just want to see who fits as scum with Hawk and who is scummy in their own right.
"Hap can't be scum because no one can be his partner" creates a falsely closed lynchpool.
In Mini 1843, I did that and winded up getting screwed when I should have just lynched my top scumread. I haven't finished re-reading through but I'm not willing to just let Hap skate by here.
yes hapa is probscum. and hes got some openings for players to be on team with him also
theyd just need to be one of the other TL guys
ooo would be good scum, top tier tho -- if yall got meta that says hes bad scum player we can safely write him off, and sorry, no self-meta acceptable
rels im withholding comment on atm except to wave vaguely at softballed questions and easy-mode townreads again
theres also kidamn -- withholding comment
momo/doom is a possible, i need to see more from momo first, but doom's townie posting was all either real bad reasoning or not looking at gamesolve in the first place. again tho momo might pull it out of the fire
and fitz, eh, ok, maybe. gut/tone townpings, but yeah the contents nonexistent or waffly, i can see it.
i tend to think of withholding reads as NAI tho because sometimes you just have zero confidence in your reads and some players havent realized the best way to get more confident is to start stomping on people with your crap reads and see what happens (i get called scum for doing this /all the time/ so that sort of withholding judgement when uncertain is a p common affliction)
kop doesnt feel like scum but tbh i dont want that slot anywhere near MyLo/LyLo unless i can coerce it to produce content
bv is locktown
creature is eeeeeeh. i wish hed continue to contribute more but hes falling off again and im thinking he needs to be given a second look or get a wild hair up his ass to start playing the game again
its hard to say hes playing his scum meta though. if he /is/ scum hes massively improved
still, i want the crossed-off-lists and digs-through-most-of-the-game-to-date-post-by-post creature, not this apathetic "so what now" creature