You know what.
I just started reading this game and Fire just claimed sock. Sock, this game, we've been pretending is scum. Fire claimed scum in DEFCON. He was scum. COINCIDENCE? >____>
It reminds me of a similar trust tell I had for the longest time as scum.
FB early scum?
gerryoat early scum.
Desp is scum b/c miller.
Oh hey. Completely forgot Pine is Hated. Relevant information. Pine still town.
Why the hell would you test a Hated claim?
And like, Hated going away in My/LyLo kind of defeats the point.
I really don't see [SAD, Maria] as scum here.
In post 81, Pine wrote:Also,
addendum to partial claim: I have an unusual role, one I am familiar with, but I don't recall ever seeing actually used before.
Hated is a modifier to it. So if you see me claiming Doctor or Jailkeeper or even something obscure like Motion Detector that I've played with before, lynch me. It's *possible* I saw it in a game many years ago, but definitely nothing recent.
Also, I absolutely
love
my role, and will likely use it in a future modded setup.
Given your propensity towards lying in STRAHD, don't mind me if I don't necessarily take this at face value.
In post 89, Fro99er wrote:WHY THE FUCK ARE WE ALL TALKING SO WEEEEEIRD I HATE IT WAAAAHHHHH
EP THIS GAME STINKS SO MUCH I NEED NOSE JAMMER
I'm starting to wonder if this is a schtick.
Nosferatu continues to be scummy.
He claimed scum.
I'm seeing double.
I'm super concerned.
That's really not Creature.
In post 149, Firebringer wrote: In post 147, Pine wrote:Yeah, I totally plan for this to be a FUN game, not a TRYHARD game. That will probably fall apart when shit gets real, but right now it's towel time.
TRY HARD SOCK MATES!
We gonna wreck this game. These towels won't see it coming!
Like seriously.
Why do you claim scum like this?
I don't get it. I really don't.
Fire all I want is this game to be great and maybe just maybe we can be something uniquely amazing.
But if you're a scumbucket then you need death.
In post 158, Andrius wrote:SAD is scum.
Desp is scum.
THE STRAHD KILLERS are all town.
Solid start.
In post 159, Andrius wrote:Maria is town.
Fire is town.
Fro99er is town.
Creature is town.
Would like to see more Gerry and Aero.
SAD town. Liking his vote-shrugging off and the testing the Hated thing even if its not something I'd do.
Desperado somewhat in the middle here. Slot will self-sort itself a Miller. The up-front claiming thing is town, but, again, miller play is so standardized its easy for scum to sneak in. As Strahdians know. Kind of waiting for him to do things unrelated to claiming at this juncture.
Pine is town. This is all heart. I mean, yeah, there's no reason for scum to not claim Hated if they're Hated, and if they're fakeclaiming it they get NOTHING since it matters little, has no established procedure, and can be tested and he dies. Town.
Sly is town. Consistency is the name of the game. I've seen you in one,
no, two
games and you're consistently town. Glad you're here, brother.
FB might actually be scum here. The claiming sock thing is concerning given I've only ever seen him claim scum as scum (DEFCON) and he's not really doing much at present.
Fro99er isn't as strong of a read as it was the first go-round, but I think he's town. Less namely because I can't remember why I shoved him in the town group so hard.
Outright saying Creature is town this early was yeah, probably a mistake. But I think I'd wind up at the same conclusion after 50 pages and having him come into his skin again. Right now, hasn't done much so probably should sit at ?? or some middle ground throwaway category that's going to see some usage here.
Gerry likely scum.
Aero likely scum.
Moving along.
SAD is super town for the conversation with Desp regarding Commuting.
Hey Toog.
Before I forget.
I would be very interested to hear your thoughts on the Tammy/Nacho/Andrius slots. Since you townread Tammy from Page 1 and were voting me for REACTIONS. ARE YOU NOT ENTERTAINED?
garry useless.
Creature's doing his thing. At his own pace.
Everything is fine.
In post 262, Pine wrote:Hold up. Before the flavor train leaves the station, my flavor is also an obstacle to getting the laundry done, and I'm Town. EP actually tells me to fuck myself in my role PM. So let's not rush to a conclusion here.
I am considering the utility of a mass flavorclaim here. I would like to invite discussion on the topic. I see pros and cons.
You're also Hated though.
So thus enjoy some of the many 'benefits' of Miller-itude.
In post 271, drealmerz7 wrote:and this entire site needs to get the fuck off of miller's claiming out of the gate
it's fucking dumb and boring
Yeah but would you prefer it go undone and then an investigative role gets a guilty on them. And THEN the miller goes 'Yeah oh I'm a Miller'.
You may not like this but its far superior to the alternative.
I would enjoy some words about what to expect from fro99er.
Because I'm looking at 303 going why.
In post 303, Fro99er wrote: In post 284, Andrius wrote:You don't need to baby me. I know you went to bed. I didn't mean to be like SHES NOT HERE SHES SCUM it was a SHES NOT HERE.
What was the "wut" part for after the "She was here for pages 1-2 and is gone."
Why the interest?
In post 309, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:Okay here were go
Desperado is town
Pine is town
Frogger is town
Aeronaut is town
Maria is town
Sly is town
Gun to head, yes.
Yes.
Gun to head, yes.
No.
Yes.
Yes would bank the game on this.
In post 329, gerryoat wrote: In post 309, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:Okay here were go
Desperado is town
Pine is town
Frogger is town
Aeronaut is town
Maria is town
Sly is town
That's a lot of town reads for 14 pages. Especially when 10 of them have been trolling.
I'm more interested in your lack of reads.
You should talk about the game more.
In post 350, gerryoat wrote:gonna be honest, guys. i have no clue who mafia is. someone give me a good case and i'll sheep the vote
The Mikujin Tell.
Outsourcing vote.
General lack of content and/or reads.
This needs to die.
Vote: gerryoat
Call it policy lynch, call it whatever. Scum dies now.
In post 351, Fro99er wrote: In post 347, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:I'm not
really
pre-empting you as a scumread I said I have you as lean scum because your early posts felt super wishy wash.
But I can get a read on you later anyway it's not like OMG TAMMY IS SCUM LYNCH HER WITH FIRE.
I don't think the word really was needed there. Like, I'm not pre-empting you as a scum read so much as I'm doing X...but I am a bit pre-empting you as a scumread.
It would have read find without the really.
This seems overly nitpicky.
Why focus on wording?
In post 360, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:The fact Tammy was focused purely on that made me feel like she wanted to look like she was doing RVS especially knowing other people had the challenge while avoiding interacting with people.
In general, this is my concern with the mechanic.
Doesn't add value to the game besides for more dreck which we surely don't need.
But apparently people are TOUCHY about this so whatever it doesn't really matter.
In post 400, drealmerz7 wrote:and you decided to share that speculation outloud for no particular reason
when it's a 17p theme game and an experienced playerlist where we all know SKs potentially exist in the game
hmmm
Why does this matter?
Its not baseless and its not a detraction.
In post 402, Desperado wrote: In post 391, Tammy wrote:I have no idea how to read Maria. The affect in the posts pings, but that could just be how she types, and I got worried about that wording, but IDK.
I don't like her at all, nothing to do with the modifier thing tho.
Reasons would be great.
You literally just called him town tho.
In post 488, gerryoat wrote:I'd vote SAD just for saying he has like 7 TRs after 10 troll pages and maybe only 3 legit content pages. but i'll wait
Meanwhile you have 0 reads in total and 0 legit content pages.
Why do you even play this game?
You could be scum again.
Ugh.
Then again there's a certain air of IDGAF about you that makes me think of UT.
Well to be fair you've done 0 to convince other people she's scum.
In post 545, Tammy wrote:This is not town frogger by the way and if it is I'm disappointed as all hell. i was like yay frogger's playing we worked together really well in mafiaception maybe that will happen again if he's town.
In mafiaception he helped the town worked together and was careful about his reads. He wasn't this lynch happy oh let's lynch someone 24 hours into the game with really lame and not solid reasoning. In fact when he was scum reading ABR, he listened to my read there and when he was discounting it was like Tammy can't listen to you anymore.
This is not that Frogger. i can't imagine a town frogger going let's lynch fast so I can see how tammy reacts let's battle tammy.
If this is what town frogger looks like now color me disappointed as shit.
But you feel more like Bees.
This feels familiar.
Fro99er is still in the leaning town category.
Nacho is town. This is town Nacho.
SAD is still strong town.
In post 577, Nachomamma8 wrote: In post 509, Fro99er wrote:Can we L-1 and derphammer SAD. I want to see tammy's reaction to that.
generally when i'm trying to encourage an early hammer I don't refer to it as a derphammer.
if he was trying to bait impatient town then I think he would have gone about it differently.
Right.
I think of RECK LOLHAMMERs and this ain't one.
Zack is unremarkable.
Having a hard time discerning on Toog.
In post 670, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:
Oh the side defense on me it was something Spiffeh (scum) did in DEFCON when I was being wagoned on Day 2 and he was halfheartedly defending the wagon saying it was bad etc.
You just have a lot to gain from it and very little to lose knowing I'll flip town. Also it's extremely similar to Spiffeh because you're not actively trying to stop the wagon just sitting there saying that you think it's bad.
This makes sense.
Though your wagon was no longer going anywhere but burning down.
In post 692, Tammy wrote:Has nobody else noticed that nosferstu keeps posting and responding to the most irrelevant stuff?
(That one post to me was like the only actual game related post she's made.)
He's scum.
Like Gerry.
Nothing new here.
Will gladly lynch either of them.
In post 732, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:Ser Arthur Dayne (7): Aeronaut, Pine, Andrius, drealmerz7, SlySly, gerryoat, Fro99er + (Firebringer) + (Toogeloo).
Sure.
Aero's likely scum.
Gerry's scum.
FB's leaning scum.
Toog's up in the air atm.
In post 750, Toogeloo wrote:I'd totally support an Andrius wagon for great pressure, but he's V/LA, so any push there isn't going to amount to anything currently.
Great pressure didn't happen.
How disappointed are you?
Sort of.
What do you stand to gain from pointing this out?
I'm so confused.
Like, here's my issue with Toog.
There's enough voting and doing things to be busy, but the gif thing is distracting and kind of feels like a schtick for the sake of being a schtick. I don't like it.
In post 1239, Toogeloo wrote:I honestly just glazed over the last two pages. drealmerz probably at least earned himself a "No need to worry about being lynched today," pass, but I didn't really see anything rather important stick out from that ridiculous terrible back and forth.
Can you elaborate on the drealmerz thing?
Because free passes are scummy.
Vote: Gerryoat
I'm out for the night.