Open 671: Greater Idea - OVER

[-Grey-]

Gamma, how familiar are you with RC's play?

[Gamma Emerald]

Not super familiar (all ongoing) but regardless of meta, RC's actions are

extremely

scummy.

[-Grey-]

Not super familiar (all ongoing) but regardless of meta, RC's actions are

extremely

scummy.

Do you think a cunning manipulator gets caught out on a superficial scumread on d1?

[Gamma Emerald]

Charles is a bit towny imo, mostly by reactions to RC

[Gamma Emerald]

Not super familiar (all ongoing) but regardless of meta, RC's actions are

extremely

scummy.

Do you think a cunning manipulator gets caught out on a superficial scumread on d1?

1) people have off games. I had a VERY off towngame in Smackdown. Who's to say RC isn't having an off scumgame?
2) The large amount of 3P spec, discard, and interactions all give me a scum feel. It's not just a superficial read.

[-Grey-]

Fair enough.

[Gamma Emerald]

While the table is cool, I miss the ability to copy/paste, so here's the playerlist as of now. If I can remember to iso myself then this will help, otherwise perhaps not...

alban
bangthemafia
Charloux
culted
davesaz
-Grey-
Kop
Not_Mafia
RadiantCowbells replaced KainTepes
Secret Agent Jin
Spade_Ace
Vaxkiller replaced DiamondSentinel

Probably the slowest starting game I've seen in a while. What's up with that?

Game started 2 days ago at this point. I've seen significant activity from I think most people
Inactives are Kop, SAJ iirc

[Gamma Emerald]

Dave is a bit towny too

[-Grey-]

Fun fact: last time Grey claimed masons with someone he was scum with them (Titus in Smackdown, and I know Titus claimed it but he didn't refute it).

How am I supposed to fakeclaim Masons in the future if you're going around tracking my shenanigans?!

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm mostly trying to give way to new perspectives. I'm not going to police your fakeclaims, who knows what a pain that would be.

[Gamma Emerald]

NM is towny
prob a tier higher than Charles/Dave

[Gamma Emerald]

bit curious about SAJ getting two prods without posting

[davesaz]

What makes NM towny?

[Aristodog]

VC 1.4

RadiantCowbells

(3): Not_Mafia 13, bangthemafia 15, Gamma Emerald 293

-Grey-

(2): Davesaz 102, alban 213

bangthemafia

(1): -Grey- 236

Not_Mafia

(1): RadiantCowbells 20

Kop

(1): Vaxkiller 268

Not Voting

(4): Charloux, Kop, Secret Agent Jin, Spade_Ace 185

With 12 Alive, it takes 7 to lynch

The day will end on February 5th, 2017 at 12 AM EST.
(expired on 2017-02-04 22:00:00)

Mod Notes:

Checking prods. I'm sure someone is due.

[Aristodog]

Searching for a Replacement for SAJ

[RadiantCowbells]

Town is shit.

VOTE: RC

Lynch NM tomorrow. bye.

[bangthemafia]

mmmm Alban feels like he's backpedaling on page 7

Sorry but can you explain what is backpedalling?

All caught up.
Questions/FOSes (questions because some of these feel like misunderstandings)
RC - Why are you determined to lynch Not Mafia?
alban - can you explain your thought process on page 7?
bang - what were you trying to accomplish with your Grey interaction?
Vax - explain your unvote in the post I quoted.

I didnt have any thought out motive that I wanted to accomplish. I am just not used to roleclaims in people's first posts on the 1st page. And this guy comes out with not only his own but 2 others' roleclaims. SO my intuitive reaction was WTF!

Not super familiar (all ongoing) but regardless of meta, RC's actions are

extremely

scummy.

NM is towny
prob a tier higher than Charles/Dave

Dave is a bit towny too

Walk me through your cases please. Whats scummy about RC, and whats towny about NM, Dave, Charl? I remember my Scumpartner!Charl from 657 and his style was the same there. Mostly posting stuff just to stay in picture and not get called a lurker. Fair enough that you have a scum lean on me. But would also appreciate some reasons for scumreading me apart from my reaction to Grey's fake roleclaim. Initially I got surprised that someone is claiming on page 1. Also his aggressive style and tunneling on spade for wildcard. Good for him maybe, but usually such aggression leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Even then, after he turned down RC's seemingly logical suggestion to lynch NM (I would, maybe, have fallen for that), I started getting town vibes from him. NM, on the other hand, has not explained much. Town would initially start getting agitated for being suspected before they give up and get frustrated, in my opinion. Still, he was the only one who openly said that Grey's push on me was shitty and acknowledged my newness. You may call it buddying but I give him some town points for that!

So as of now, my llist is-
Strong town read- Grey, Gamma
Null to town read- Vaxkiller
Null- Alban, Kop, Charl, SAJ, Spade, NM (upgraded here from below)
Null to scum lean- Culted, RC

[bangthemafia]

RC is at L-3

[-Grey-]

Null to scum lean- Culted, RC

Explain these, please.

[alban]

mmmm Alban feels like he's backpedaling on page 7

Town
-Grey-, Spade_Ace
Gap
Charloux, Kop, Secret Agent Jin, Not_Mafia, davesaz - Null/unsorted line here
Vaxkiller
Bangthemafia, Alban
RadiantCowbells
Scum
Charles and Dave might be sorted at some time soon.

Please sum up reasons for your hierarchy, especially on me, Grey, Spade, Bang and RC.

I believe you must have mentioned these as you were posting, but it will be good to see them together in one post.

[alban]

First quote unnecessary.

[Spade_Ace]

Town is shit.

VOTE: RC

Lynch NM tomorrow. bye.

I doubt town!RC would vote herself so early in the game and that too with just 3 previous votes.
So. Bye

VOTE: RC

[Spade_Ace]

RC is at L-3

How come you didnt comment on the selfvote?

[Spade_Ace]

Null to scum lean- Culted, RC

Explain these, please.

^^This

[Spade_Ace]

@gamma i meant the role