Open 56 - Masons and Monks (GAME OVER) before 542

[JDodge]

Then back up your claims instead of just using a blanket statement.

1. You are

Hmm.

NICE QUESTION AVOIDANCE

I've already given my reasoning.

[Draux]

Kabenon, what do you think of Oman?

[kabenon007]

Well, I'm kind of indignant that he keeps defending me. I don't think I need him to defend me, I can defend myself just fine. Now that you mention it, it kind of seems like something I would do to lead up to a false scumbuddy. Make the town think that my scum partner was a townie. He is avoiding questions, no doubt about that. I'm just inherently suspicious of people who defend me, even if it's true, cuz it seems like they are just setting me up to take a fall for them later. If that makes sense. It makes sense in my head at least.

[Oman]

Right, well, if you look back at my posts, they were less of a defence of Kabenon (I even was against his use of too townie) and more an attack of Jdodge.

[JDodge]

Then back up your claims instead of just using a blanket statement.

1. You are

Hmm.

NICE QUESTION AVOIDANCE

I've already given my reasoning.

ANSWER THE FUCKING QUESTION.

[Oman]

Then back up your claims instead of just using a blanket statement.

It isn't a question. Its a statment.

[Flameaxe]

Its actually more of a request, which funny enough, can have an answer.

[thinktank]

Then back up your claims instead of just using a blanket statement.

1. You are

Hmm.

not to defend Jdodge but your previous statement was "1.im not scum" . I'm sry but thats not exactly pulling the town in your favour and its not exactly winning you the argument that you give straight answers.

draux: what was your last comment about? i'll say the same thing to you that I did to flameaxe earlier. reading your posts, you've made 5 so far. out of those 5, 3 have been asking what other people think and i was in the early random stage. Asking for what other people think on stuff is ok if your actively hunting scum , which you are not. you are actively lurking. You are not helping the town at all.

[Flameaxe]

Unvote, vote: Thinktank

[Oman]

not to defend Jdodge

way to dodge it

but your previous statement was "1.im not scum"

you're not big on context are you?

. I'm sry but thats not exactly pulling the town in your favour and its not exactly winning you the argument that you give straight answers.

[Flameaxe]

Wha?

[Samruc]

Vote Count

LutenitPowwel: 3 (Draux, Sage, Kabenon007)
Oman: 2 (JDodge, farside22)
Kabenon007: 1 (kuribo)
Flameaxe: 1 (thinktank)
thinktank: 1(Flameaxe)
TylerJ: 1 (pwayne66)
JDodge: 1 (LutenitPowwel)

Not voting: (TylerJ, Oman)

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

[kuribo]

Well, I'm kind of indignant that he keeps defending me. I don't think I need him to defend me, I can defend myself just fine. Now that you mention it, it kind of seems like something I would do to lead up to a false scumbuddy. Make the town think that my scum partner was a townie. He is avoiding questions, no doubt about that. I'm just inherently suspicious of people who defend me, even if it's true, cuz it seems like they are just setting me up to take a fall for them later. If that makes sense. It makes sense in my head at least.

Alot of your argument is hypothetical, though, and you have no way of knowing whether Oman would defend you for whatever reason. I don't like the speculation of "If I was scum..." and it also sounds like you're trying too hard to remove a possible link later on down the line. IE, if Oman did turn out to be scum, you've already tried to raise the possibility that he's setting you up as a false scum buddy.

[kuribo]

1. You are

Vote: JDodge

You can't know that he's scum. That's pretty scummy to accuse someone of being scum without really good information.

And for the record, based on my experience playing with JDodge, he does that alot. Fun fact--- in the Baby Too Much scum game that just finished, he was right.

[pwayne66]

@flameaxe. Why thinktank?

[kabenon007]

Alot of your argument is hypothetical, though, and you have no way of knowing whether Oman would defend you for whatever reason

.

The exact same could be said of your argument that Oman is my scum buddy. You only have hypothetical thoughts of the reasons behind Oman's defense. It's exactly the same as what you said to me. Judge me by my own actions, not by the actions of others.

[Sage]

Unvote

I need to do some reading and contribute.

[kuribo]

Alot of your argument is hypothetical, though, and you have no way of knowing whether Oman would defend you for whatever reason

.

The exact same could be said of your argument that Oman is my scum buddy.

Show me where I said Oman was your scum buddy.

Now you're just making stuff up to suit your defense.

[JDodge]

Alot of your argument is hypothetical, though, and you have no way of knowing whether Oman would defend you for whatever reason

.

The exact same could be said of your argument that Oman is my scum buddy.

Show me where I said Oman was your scum buddy.

Now you're just making stuff up to suit your defense.

You said so when you were referencing the giant talking pie

[farside22]

I'm sorry all I'm getting from this conversation is a bunch of white noise.
Flamaxe why are you voting for thinktank?

[Oman]

Why isn't others? thinktank's lack of ability to understand even the most basic english is no asset to the town.

YEs, I realise I'm not voting for him.

[kabenon007]

I inferred it from post 137. You can't tell me that you weren't implying that's what you meant. You may not have said it explicitly, but it was implied. By bringing up the fact of a "possibly link" that means you yourself thought of said link. So I perhaps put a bit more emphasis on it than you, but oh well.

[Flameaxe]

@flameaxe. Why thinktank?

For being a hypocrite.

[thinktank]

Flame Axe: How am I a hypocrite? substantiate your argument so that i can pose a counter argument.

How does that justify your vote for me? Your saying that you think I am scum because you believe I am a hypocrite. I'm sorry but that does not make any sense. If you are voting for me, it must mean that I have done something to clearly convince you that I am scum, i would really like to hear your reason for your vote.

[Flameaxe]

Yes, but the thing is...it's not just you being a hypocrite, its what you are being hypocritical about. I'm gonna give someone else a chance to look over your posts to see if they find it too! It's like a game!