Open 56 - Masons and Monks (GAME OVER) before 542

[Oman]

Aye, but I felt him voting the way he did was incorrect.

[kabenon007]

That's fine if it sucks, but can you at least explain why you think it sucks, so I can either agree or disagree?

[TylerJ]

Crap is there any scumhunting whatsoever? Sorry for being a hypcrite for not doing so myself, but honestly I could care less about asophoguses and asshates and all that other junk.

The only scummy things I saw in this game so far were these. Oman voting for himself. Two times I have seen that, and both times the people were scum. However, in the context given, I honestly think he was playing around. The too towny argument seemed like scum was fishing for a reason to accuse someone too... but it isn't enough for a vote.

So for now I will suffice it to say

unvote, FOS Oman and whoever made that too towny argument

not good with names if you hadn't noticed.

[JDodge]

I'm back live.

Unvote Vote Jdodge

This guy seems pretty newbie, and you jump on him for his fallacy rather than explaining it to him.

Bullshit. Don't feed me that "OH HE'S A NEWBIE HE DOESN'T KNOW ANY BETTER" crap. This is an

open

game. Not a

newbie

game. If you're going to seriously go after me for not acting as a mentor in a game where I have no obligation to do so, you need to have your head checked. Furthermore, he is

not

a newbie, he has numerous completed games, so get your facts straight. The fact that you go after me for something, realize our mistake and yet still have your vote in the same place and try to explain it with "HIS VOTES SUCKZ" severely casts doubt upon your alignment.

[Oman]

Unvote

I have no obligation to do so,

Thats a good point.

[JDodge]

Unvote

I have no obligation to do so,

Thats a good point.

Really? Because last time someone pointed it out...

I'm back live.

Unvote Vote Jdodge

This guy seems pretty newbie, and you jump on him for his fallacy rather than explaining it to him.

True, except this isn't a newbie game, and thus JD doesn't need to be that IC figure to help lead the way. A wiki link (such as there was) seemed like plenty of explanation to me.

...you responded with this:

Sorry, I didn't mean the newb comment, for some reasons I put your join date about 4 months in the future.

Still, the too townie fallacy sucks.

Hi scum.

Oman and kabenon are scum together, guys. I'm even more certain of Oman than I am of kabenon.

Unvote, vote: Oman

diescumdie

[Oman]

You lose on both accounts. 1 I am not scum and 2. that post was not in response to flameaxes.

[JDodge]

You lose on both accounts. 1 I am not scum and 2. that post was not in response to flameaxes.

1. You are

2. It still shows that you knew it was wrong before I pointed it out.

[Oman]

Yeah? You don't think BBM defending you has a little less weight than your defence of yourself?

[JDodge]

Yeah? You don't think BBM defending you has a little less weight than your defence of yourself?

THAT'S ENTIRELY IRRELEVANT.

Regardless of who said it, it was

said

. Either you A.) Willfully ignored the words of someone to continue pushing after me, or B.) Didn't want to listen to it because you were trying to push me.

[pwayne66]

@kabenon007- Too townie is fine for your own personal scumhunting. To convince a town you need something more easy to digest... like voting for yourself and failing to read correctly. These are very well established scumtells with a high degree of accuracy, thus more likely to earn the praise of your fellow townies.

[kabenon007]

As is evidenced with our current situation.

[Flameaxe]

Unvote: Vote: Ouman

Seriously man? Come on. This is stupid.

[Samruc]

Vote Count

Kabenon007: 2 (kuribo, farside22)
LutenitPowwel: 2 (Draux, Sage)
Oman: 2 (JDodge, Flameaxe)
Flameaxe: 1 (thinktank)
TylerJ: 1 (pwayne66)
kuribo: 1 (Kabenon007)

Not voting: (LutenitPowwel, TylerJ, Oman)

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

[TylerJ]

I still don't think were going anywhere. We may be pushing on a rock but we need to push a little harder. I am completely lost in Jdodges and Omans argument. None of the points make either of them look scummy. Perhaps I should read it a few more times to see their points.

[farside22]

JDodge brings up a good point against Oman. This isn't a newb game and the too town comment sent people going against Kabenon007 for the comment. I didn't read the article, but I don't think there is a such thing as too town. It's been my expierence that scum duck and cover where as town people are trying to uncover them underneath all the crap reasoning. Oman should know better then to give someone a hard time in an open game and seems he is trying to protect Kabenon007.

unvote: vote: Oman

[Flameaxe]

There was no article (I didn't bother clicking it because I knew what it is). It works in theory, but is just not reliable to tell whether or not its just a townie really trying to be a townie, or scum.

I still don't think were going anywhere. We may be pushing on a rock but we need to push a little harder. I am completely lost in Jdodges and Omans argument. None of the points make either of them look scummy. Perhaps I should read it a few more times to see their points.

Plenty going on here. I suggest you do go over it, as there as been plenty of progress made in the last 3 pages.

[LutenitPowwel]

1. You are

Vote: JDodge

You can't know that he's scum. That's pretty scummy to accuse someone of being scum without really good information.

[JDodge]

1. You are

Vote: JDodge

You can't know that he's scum. That's pretty scummy to accuse someone of being scum without really good information.

This is terrible basis for vote.

[kabenon007]

Um, I agree with JDodge here. The only way one can possibly know if someone is scum is if they are that person's scum partner. I found a good place for my vote to go.

unvote vote:LutenitPowwel

[Oman]

It's been my expierence that scum duck and cover where as town people are trying to uncover them underneath all the crap reasoning.

Wow, how is this relevant to my actions?

Jdodge, you are, as usual, using horrible logic to come to the wrong conclusion.

[JDodge]

It's been my expierence that scum duck and cover where as town people are trying to uncover them underneath all the crap reasoning.

Wow, how is this relevant to my actions?

Jdodge, you are, as usual, using horrible logic to come to the wrong conclusion.

Then back up your claims instead of just using a blanket statement. A blanket statement that you always use when you know you can't win a debate.

[thinktank]

LPowell, how can you vote someone with good information? everything in this game is pure speculation unless information is given by a power role so that is pretty shotty logic. Oman, you have not presented a case at all, to Jdodge's accusations one of your remarks was "I am not scum". Going back to my previous statement, your statement holds no weight, Its like me saying I own a ferrari, yes, it could be true, but theres no evidence on either side of the argument.

FoS: Oman

Considering all your actions from the beginning this is not a far stretch.

[Flameaxe]

And what exactly are your opinions on Oman?

[Oman]

Then back up your claims instead of just using a blanket statement.

1. You are

Hmm.