Mafia 69: noXkill - Game over!

[curiouskarmadog]

"I think the lone wolf is..."
"I think the mafia scum group is..."

I think the lone wolf is Kison, because the game is suddenly more interesting to him.

I -know- who the Mafia pairing is, but I'm only going to tell you half of it: Me. The rest, you gotta work for.

yeah yeah yeah we got it there is only two of you..do you think the more you say it, the more we will believe you?

[Dead Rikimaru]

More recently, the portrayal of werewolves has taken an even more sympathetic turn in some circles. With the rise of environmentalism and other back-to-nature ideals, the werewolf has come to be seen by some authors as a representation of humanity allied more closely with nature. Some recent fiction also discards the idea that the werewolf dominates the mind when one transforms, and instead postulates that the wolf form can be used at will, with the lycanthrope retaining its human thought processes and intelligence.

SECOND VOTECOUNT

Peers

(3) - Twomz , ZONEACE , TheHermit

Twomz

(1) - cicero

Kison

(1) - Peers

Not voting

(5): ooba , Kison , IH , curiouskarmadog , Kanaga

Needed for a lynch: 6 votes
Negotiable deadline: 30 days

If by deadline no one has 6 votes player with more votes is lynched
If two players have same number of votes lynch is decided by duel

[ZONEACE]

ZA here is a question for you

after ooba and I were not killed after we claimed you thought we had to be scum.

now that Cicero has claimed BV and the wolves did not kill him..your thoughts on cicero.

Also ZA...I would like you to finish these sentences.


"I think the lone wolf is..."
"I think the mafia scum group is..."

I admit I'm a little perplexed by Cicero still being alive. But then i thought about it. If he is wolf obviously he'd still be alive. If he is mafia obviously he'd still be alive. If he's telling the truth that's where my problem is. It seems like an obvious choice for the wolf kill. But then I considered. The wolves are pretty much done. there's only one of them left, the likely hood of them winning is very slim. So the lone wolf may be trying to screw the mafia over leaving alive the only other person they can't NK.

IF cicero is scum he's the last wolf, cause if he claimed BC as Mafia he could be exposed by an exposed wolf so i don't think thats a risk he'd take but I'm still not sure about him.


Now for the fill in the blanks. I think the lone wolf is Kison or The Hermit (I had a few suspicions that CA and DAS were aligned but CA's replacement makes me question it since there was still a Wolf Kill).
I think the unknown mafia are 2 of Kison, Kanaga, IH

[Peers]

"I think the lone wolf is..."
"I think the mafia scum group is..."

I think the lone wolf is Kison, because the game is suddenly more interesting to him.

I -know- who the Mafia pairing is, but I'm only going to tell you half of it: Me. The rest, you gotta work for.

yeah yeah yeah we got it there is only two of you..do you think the more you say it, the more we will believe you?

No, but the more I say it, the more smug I can be when it turns out I'm telling the truth.

[cicero]

For the record, Peers, I believe you. 5 bad guys is the perfect amount for this 20 person game.

[ooba]

For the record, Peers, I believe you. 5 bad guys is the perfect amount for this 20 person game.

If there are just 2 mafia , then your role claim would really unbalance it for them considering the doctor/nurse combo ...

[cicero]

For the record, Peers, I believe you. 5 bad guys is the perfect amount for this 20 person game.

If there are just 2 mafia , then your role claim would really unbalance it for them considering the doctor/nurse combo ...

Maybe. I can't read the mod totally, but in any event, maybe I'm missing the formal application of how this would affect stategy in any case. The mod will tell us when the last mafioso is dead.

Assuming Peers is lying, what strategy do you think he's trying to employ.

[curiouskarmadog]

gee, you are right, how can misinformation hurt the town.

[cicero]

gee, you are right, how can misinformation hurt the town.

Don't be snarky. We need to find the mafia. If we kill the last wolf and one other mafia besides Peers and the game doesn't happen you have your answer. My question was honest. What game do you think Peers is playing? Not knowing does not mean there isn't one. I just thought we should puzzle out what it might be.

[ooba]

Assuming Peers is lying, what strategy do you think he's trying to employ.

The anti mafia power roles seems already a bit more powerful than the anti wolf power roles - So by constantly hinting at 2 and making us believe that there are 3 mafia - maybe he's trying to avoid any discussion that there might be even 4 mafia in the game? Far fetched but possible ..

[Peers]

Or maybe I'm trying to intimate there are four anti-Wolf roles compared to three anti-Mafia roles, without tipping off the Wolves they have a high-value target hidden among the town.

Of course, if I were doing that, I wouldn't've just said that.

Would I?

I hate WIFOM... oh, well.

[cicero]

Sadly I dont have time to puzzle this out for a few days. Work and life is actually busy. But here's our homework assignment: Find the last wolf. With two wolves dead that shouldnt be all that impossible. We need to look at how other players interacted with Tarhalindur and David Angel Summers. If you get an idea that, so and so is a wolf, go back and look and see if you can see patterns that support or don't support that idea from their play.

Sorry to be hypocritical about it. It's just that weighing bandwagons and all that stuff isnt something I have time to do for the next few days.

[Twomz]

ZONEACE (YogurtBandit)
TheHermit (ChocolateAttack)
Kison
IH (thinktank)
Kanaga (FeRnAnDo)

These are the 5 suspects (in my eyes, since there I have not role claimed or been cleared, everyone else should be looking at me as well) imho. I think the most likely wolf out of the group is TheHermit... because of the incidents earlier in the game between him and DAS and just... well, a gut feeling. IH is the least likely wolf, but could very well be mafia still. In fact, I suspect all of the of being mafia, and all but IH of being wolves for now.


I do agree with what was said earlier about if we can lynch the last wolf today, that would be the best play. But a mislynch would be horrible, so Peers is the best option (guaranteed hit).

[Peers]

Hello, McFly, anybody home?

[Kison]

That is MY line.

More later.

[Kanaga]

We need to look at how other players interacted with Tarhalindur and David Angel Summers

Looking through their posts, neither seemed to warm up to anyone. I think I might look at some of thinktank's posts soon.

[Peers]

Interesting choice. Why thinktank in particular?

[cicero]

Maybe we should all vote curiouskarmadog again. That seems to yield excellent mafia uncovering results.

p.s. that was a joke.

[ZONEACE]

lol

[curiouskarmadog]

vote zoneace

yeah, im sure

[cicero]

Why are you sure? Gimme a case so I might be able to justify a vote.

[ZONEACE]

indeed, why is a good question.

I'd also like to hear a case so i can so CKD that he is wrong.

[Dead Rikimaru]

Sikario8 replaces IH, effective as soon as he posts.

[Sikario8]

I'm guessing the town has chosen Peers to be lynched?

[cicero]

No. We are using him as a wolf hunter. Your thoughts on the matter?