In post 5302, PeregrineV wrote:
You replaced in for night1.
If you had a weak role, in which you would have died had you hidden behind them, why not make it so that reading your ISO after your death, we would see who you hid behind?
You had all day2 to post and let us know your suspect?
Let's get this over again:
-Maxous was not a suspect but an "easy" choice because I had no idea who to target from the more controversial ones. I expected McMenno to flip scum and then take my pick.
-Given the gamestate it would be highly improbable that I would be nightkilled by either faction (town vig or scum) and given my choice it would be improbable to suicide from the weak ability.
-This is the first time I am playing a weak role, so yes not crumbing and not choosing someone of higher profile was a mistake.
In post 5389, Creature wrote:
My townplay changes through the games depending on how motivated I am and how easy I am getting reads.
But my scumplay is likely always the same, maybe take a look there?
(Sigh)
I was going to say "fair point" but your scumplay being always the same means very little. You are a competent player. You can manipulate your meta. It is extremely easy to feign disinterest in this game. Why then follow your usual "scum meta" as scum where someone could easily spot it, point it out and lynch you?
In post 5490, Narna wrote: In post 5489, Narna wrote:And on the 200+ pages of slog to struggle through. Keep in mind the House and Gamma slots are guilty of flooding this game with nonsense and blindly agreeing with people, only to immediately 180ing on things (the latter being in Gamma's case). Neither have actually lynched shit as well.
or tried to lynch, especially post replacement.
Sure, lynch, but who? The game's a mess and for every single potential lynch candidate there is a "but" hanging above their heads. There exists your point of view, but also exists a point of view that is absolutely
convinced
to have you lynched. This is true for almost all lynch propositions today after the govern (Not Chara, Leonshade, Shiro, Creature, Giovanni, Almost50).
Then you see that 4 Townies are already dead and, whether you are town or scum (it doesn't matter) you hesitate to push for a lynch in fear of lynching another townie and subsequently getting yourself lynched by the torch-and-pitchfork logic this town has.
----------
So, right now, Leonshade 6, Creature 3
Meh. Narna is lynched tomorrow anyway, so a Leonshade lynch right now is moot. The timing of his govern was terrible, but this in and of itself isn't scummy, especially since it doesn't make sense for a townread scum to save his buddy who is gonna get lynched anyway.
VOTE: Creature