Newbie 470: Trouble at Mount Excitement - Mafia Wins!

[Dark_Lady_Shaiann]

Why do people keep dissappearing for like days on end?

[Mastermind of Sin]

dunno...

[Happiest Sadist]

I've been disappearing because the thread has been moving very slowly. As to leaving my vote on someone, I don't change my vote unless I have a reason to. Since DLS has roleclaimed cop I think we should back off. If its accurate we don't want to lynch her. If it is inaccurate, then her investigation claims will provide us with useful data.

I actually did miss the cop claim in my lurking, and this is the first time I have seen it.

unvote Dark Lady Shiann

[BrianMcQueso]

Vote Count

Happiest Sadist (3: Dark_Lady_Shaiann, Charms86, TheSweatpantsNinja)
Joubert (1: Mastermind of Sin)
MastermindofSin (1: ShadowLurker)

Not Voting: Joubert, Happiest Sadist

7

alive,

4

to lynch

[Mastermind of Sin]

Fine.

Unvote, Vote: Happiest Sadist

Look at Joubert and TSPN tomorrow.

[BrianMcQueso]

That's a

LYNCH!

Happiest Sadist (Dark_Lady_Shaiann, Charms86, TheSweatpantsNinja, Mastermind of Sin)

The town has killed

Happiest Sadist

. After his death, you search his home and personal belongings to find that he had no criminal affiliations. He didn't have any other affiliations of any kind. Guess he was just a

Townie

.

Hmm, maybe you should have searched his stuff before stringing him up. Oh well, must have got caught up in the

excitement

, yeah?

Thus begins

Night 1

. If you have a night role, please send in your choice as soon as possible. Day 2 will begin when I receive all nightchoices or Wednesday, Nov. 7th, whichever happens first. If you have any questions, feel free to ask me privately.

[BrianMcQueso]

The sun has risen on Day 2. The town finds the body of

Mastermind of Sin

dead in the center of town. No identifying items are found with him, so he must have been a

Townie

.

There are only

5

of you left. It will take

3

votes to lynch, but be careful! The town needs to lynch a member of the mafia today in order to keep playing.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

The obvious question is can we trust Dark_Lady? I'll be curious to see what she has to say, but the fact that the mafia killed someone else is very interesting.

[ShadowLurker]

We should have all claims out in the open by the end of today.

[ShadowLurker]

Also, please keep in mind that it is

LYLO

meaning if we lynch wrong we lose. Also note that there are still two mafia alive meaning

any incorrect vote by a townie basically equals a loss for the town

so please HOLD your votes unless you are 100% sure the person you are voting is scum for now.

[Mastermind of Sin]

lolz.

[Joubert]

I second what TSPN said. If Dark Lady is trustable, she could surely bring something interesting on the table. But what intrigues me is the sudden and unexplained hammer by Mastermind of Sin. But now that he turned out to be Town (and dead), it's even more confusing...

It is possible that the Scum team got rid of MoS so we couldn't clarify anything afterwards. If Dark Lady really is the Cop, and she investigated him, then it would mean it was a complete waste for the Town...

[Charms86]

Ouch! We really need to find the scum here, but how can we be so sure?
Dark Lady's insights could be very helpful...

ShadowLurker, when you say we should all claim today do you mean that we should claim if we're just a townie or are you referring to just the doctor role?

Is there really a point in claiming when Mafia are clearly not going to admit to being Mafia?

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Well, I assume he means claims more medical in nature. I am not the doctor. I am not mafia. I will probably vote for Dark_Lady unless given a particularly good reason not to. [/i]

[Dark_Lady_Shaiann]

If Dark Lady really is the Cop, and she investigated him, then it would mean it was a complete waste for the Town...

Well.....

As hard as this is to admit, I ended up doing just that. Figuring I knew who already was scum, I just wanted to make sure, but instead of going after who everyone else probably thought I was going to go after (Joubert or TSPN) I chose some one else, hoping that MoS wasn't just siding with me to gain my trust. It honestly didn't even cross my mind that they were going to go after him, but now it makes sense.

Considering that MoS (our leader of sorts) was going to go after Joubert and TSPN today, it kind of makes sense that he got night killed, (especially since he was siding with me aswell) and I didn't.

Also keep in mind how TSPN went immediatly back to his default play of trying to get rid of me during the day.....

Vote: TheSweatpantsNinja

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

What? I

defended

you yesterday. You were sketchy then, but you claimed cop (at L-1), and I didn't want to lynch you in case you were, in fact, cop. Then you didn't die, as one might expect the cop to. So now I find you sketchy again. Its not a 'default' play, whatever that means, I'm voting for the person I find scummiest.

I'm still holding my vote, though. Unlike Dark_Lady, I am still a little concerned about scum quicklynching. She, obviously, does not have this problem.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Oh, and of course she 'investigated' the person who was conveniently dead.

[Dark_Lady_Shaiann]

Well...you came into the game trying to get rid of me, and of course whoever claims cop is going to be seen as 'sketchy', don't make it look like you have only had this problem with me. To defend me could easily be seen as a natural reaction so as to not be seen as scum, while Joubert's mad protests are suprisingly just as natural, though a bit more risky.


And no....it's not conveniant, it's extremly upsetting. MoS was basically my last line of defense. if I were mafia, why would I kill him first? He was on my side. No one openly trusted me before I claimed cop. He admitted to having a feeling I was cop before I ever did claim. Now that he's gone there is no one to really defend me but me, and we see how well that worked out before. I would have killed him accepting the fact that I would get lynched today. Who does that?

HS's lynch is regretable but he was really just not paying attention. We had been discussing my cop claim for like....ever and a day, and he just saw it right before he got lynched. It really looked like the only thing he could as a mafia at L-1 was side with every one else. Turns out he was town, but apparently you guys felt the same as me. I pushed for him, becuase he pushed so hard for me with a stupid reason. You can't deny me that much, so I don't want to hear any one say anything about him.

[Dark_Lady_Shaiann]

Oh, and.....

unvote

I'll agree, I was just a bit too hasty.....

[Joubert]

I hope you realize, Dark Lady, that your vote was not only hasty, but very dangerous. If you really are Town, it would mean that the 2 other Scum only need to vote against the same player to seal and win the game...

Your vote lasted approximately 12 hours, so it's not a big deal. But if such vote lasted longer, and nothing happened, then you would be easily suspected...

[Dark_Lady_Shaiann]

Understandable.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Come on! Let's hear from more people!

I will vote for Dark_Lady, because I no longer find her cop claim to be believable, and she has been scummy from the beginning of the game.

Dark_Lady will vote for me, because, well, I'm voting for her. (Perhaps I misrepresent her argument, but that's all I see in it).

Other people, speak!

[Charms86]

TSPN, could you tell me again why you feel so confident that Dark_Lady is scum?

Do find it likely for scum to leave a bunch of clues early on in the game of being the cop?

I think maybe Mastermind of Sin was on to something in this game and maybe that's why the Mafia killed him last night. MoS, the one you had such a good feeling about, believed Dark_Lady was truly the Cop.

You might be able to convince me that she's scum. The fact that she's not dead yet and that she so conveniently investigated MoS makes her seem a little suspicious to me, but I'd like to hear you list all your arguments again.

Also, who might she be scumbuddies with?

[ShadowLurker]

DLS: Did you not read my post at the start of the day at all?

Dark_Lady will vote for me, because, well, I'm voting for her. (Perhaps I misrepresent her argument, but that's all I see in it).

What did you mean by this statement?

[Dark_Lady_Shaiann]

Yeah...I read it and then I forgot about it when I got caught up in my post about TSPN.