In post 1244, serrapaladin wrote:As town, that reads entirely too confident about your read of thor. Short of a guilty, you should always want to hear thor defend himself rather than me do it. The most any one of us should have responded was "I would like to hear thor's response to this", and I'm a bit annoyed at myself for not having done that, but I guess I was sick of arguing play style...
I am usually cautious with reads. I agree that there should always be room for doubt. Town should always be second-guessing and attempting to falsify their reads. But I've been through all that all game with Thor and its time to take the strongest read I've had all game and go with it.
In post 1247, serrapaladin wrote:Peng has been much more reachy today than yesterday, and I think it's because he feels the need to strongly shift the current narrative.
I wouldn't be so blatant if I was trying to shift off of my scumbuddy. Lynch Thor, but then lynch Loop when he flips town.
p-edit
Paladin: Great way to enter the game in terms of starting a distancing feud. What interactions did they have after that sequence of events?
Loop: Stop dodging. What do you think? About his posts? About his votes? Not your feeling, not his avatar. Try to put your finger on why.
You jusy proved it even further? You first think to comment on the read on YOU.
Town's biggest job is to find scum. Scum's biggest job is to look town.
Instead of disagreeing with my townread on your scumread (Loop), the first think that comes to mind for you is to defend yourself
In post 1247, serrapaladin wrote:Peng has been much more reachy today than yesterday, and I think it's because he feels the need to strongly shift the current narrative.
I wouldn't be so blatant if I was trying to shift off of my scumbuddy. Lynch Thor, but then lynch Loop when he flips town.
p-edit
Paladin: Great way to enter the game in terms of starting a distancing feud. What interactions did they have after that sequence of events?
Loop: Stop dodging. What do you think? About his posts? About his votes? Not your feeling, not his avatar. Try to put your finger on why.
Why loop over shadow? Setting up thor -> loop is exactly what you would want as scum with shadow.
In post 1255, Harkonnen97 wrote:You jusy proved it even further? You first think to comment on the read on YOU.
Town's biggest job is to find scum. Scum's biggest job is to look town.
Instead of disagreeing with my townread on your scumread (Loop), the first think that comes to mind for you is to defend yourself
I've expressed my disagreement on Loop already. Look forward to your comment on his and Shadow's ISO.
In post 1247, serrapaladin wrote:Peng has been much more reachy today than yesterday, and I think it's because he feels the need to strongly shift the current narrative.
I wouldn't be so blatant if I was trying to shift off of my scumbuddy. Lynch Thor, but then lynch Loop when he flips town.
p-edit
Paladin: Great way to enter the game in terms of starting a distancing feud. What interactions did they have after that sequence of events?
Loop: Stop dodging. What do you think? About his posts? About his votes? Not your feeling, not his avatar. Try to put your finger on why.
Why loop over shadow? Setting up thor -> loop is exactly what you would want as scum with shadow.
I'd be happy with either. Loop is pushing Thor harder right now.
Lynch Thor, but then lynch Loop when he flips town
If this isn't a scumslip, put a skirt on me and call me Mary.
Why are you okay with one of your townreads lynched?
Why are you not only okay, but you are asking for it to happen?
You really want to provide me with some good sig material, Mary.
Wow, take that out of context why don't you. I don't want Thor to be lynched, but if it results in scum getting lynched I'm fine with it. We don't make the right decision today, we damn well better tomorrow.
In post 1235, Loopdan wrote:We still have a lot of time Day 2. I think we should use it, so I am not encouraging a Thor hammer yet.
Here is where I am at on each slot:
Hark
- Towny town. If he's scum he deserves to win for playing an outstanding game.
MT
- Taking her at her word that she's doc, as nobody counterclaimed.
serrapaladin
- Was very skeptical about this slot, but the more he posts the more town he looks. Wouldn't totally surprise me if he turned out scum, but it doesn't seem likely.
Shadow
- My gut says "scum," but I can't put my finger on why. It could be the red profile pic, or it could be how he disappeared at the end of Day 1 after the MT wagon got going.
Penguin
- Is scumreading MT and Hark (I think), which I find odd. I'll admit I haven't paid enough attention or thought a whole lot about this slot Day 2, but everyone else seems to find Penguin scummy. I am very interested in Penguin's response to the Thor wagon.
Thor
- Our Day 2 lynch.
Requesting all players post something like this. No need for walls or even linked posts. Just tell us where you are on all players. Transparency helps town.
My time zone is GMT +5.30, I am never online during that time as I'm sleeping. If I was I would never have blank get lynched.
In post 1262, Shadow_step wrote:My time zone is GMT +5.30, I am never online during that time as I'm sleeping. If I was I would never have blank get lynched.
This is bad - when Blank was actually lynched, it wasn't out of serious scumreads anymore, it was to avoid lynching a PR or no-lynch.
Hark is town. Paladin is town. MT is town. Thor is town.
Mafia Shadow and Loop.
Where in the world did this come from? Haven't you been scumreading me since I claimed doc peng? What made you change your mind? You've already commented (I guess) on Shadow and Loop but what made you change your mind on my alignment?
