Newbie 1725: Innocents, Inc. [Game Over!]

[Loopdan]

Current votes (I think):

BlankFace -- Penguin, MissTerry, Thor
MissTerry -- Shadow, serrapaladin, Loopdan
PenguinPower -- Hark
Thor -- Creature
Creature -- BlankFace

[Loopdan]

I am logging off and probably won't be back on for about five hours.

[Creature]

VOTE: MissTerry

Not voting Blank.

L-1

[MissTerry]

Would you do it if deadline is looming?

Who else would you want lynch besides me and Thor and hesitantly Blank?
Would you lynch Penguin?

[MissTerry]

Is this the part were I make a claim? Does Hark's post coins as an intent to hammer?

[Creature]

Would you do it if deadline is looming?

Yes, I would hammer you or Penguin near deadline.

Who else would you want lynch besides me and Thor and hesitantly Blank?

Shadow_step.

Would you lynch Penguin?

I am hesitant.

[MissTerry]

@MissTerry - Please explain why Blank is your top scum-read.

Blank isn't my top scum read and I never said he was. I said he was my top to lynch. He has already made a claim, given his role be it true or not. If it is true, Scum can target him and/or use him to narrow down to the PR and target him instead. If he is scum and we don't lynch him, he won't die at night, and suspicion will be away from him for the next day.

[Harkonnen97]

Is this the part were I make a claim? Does Hark's post coins as an intent to hammer?

Yes. Looks like a Pengo wagon isn't happening, and Blank is obvtown.

I intend to hammer.

[BlankFace]

@MissTerry - Please explain why Blank is your top scum-read.

Blank isn't my top scum read and I never said he was. I said he was my top to lynch. He has already made a claim, given his role be it true or not. If it is true, Scum can target him and/or use him to narrow down to the PR and target him instead. If he is scum and we don't lynch him, he won't die at night, and suspicion will be away from him for the next day.

Tl;Dr:
I'm not scum reading Blank, I'd rather lynch him as town to protect PRs.


You know we win by lynching scum, right? If you don't think I'm scum, lynching me is bad. If you do think I'm scum, even if I'm not your top scum pick, you need to make a case right now.

[Loopdan]

Phone posting.

@MT-- Dump your reads and claim, please.

@Hark-- please give some time for reactions after the claim before hammering.

[MissTerry]

I have to get all my reads together and try to make them make sense, going to write a long one, please don't hammer until then.

[Harkonnen97]

@IV I will be v/la from 26th of July to 2nd of August.

[MissTerry]

Claim: Doctor

Wrote half my post, phone reloaded and lost it all, typical -__-

These are my reads of all the players, when I flip town you can read them and know they were not scum motivated. Sorry if they don't make sense, I tried.

Blank: His arguments and ISO aren't scummy tbh, he had two main tracks, Thor then Serra. Nothing really screams scum, he voices his problems, pushes his suspicions and actually tries to explain what his reasons and reads are. Doesn't tunnel and has been willing to change his opinion if new evidence comes up.

Creature: My gut tells me he is scum, if I try to write out why it will just be rubbish.

Hark: Obvtown. Pushes game along, put pressures, asks questions, plays well.

Loop: My initial reason for voting him was rubbish, I am not too arrogant to own up to bad play. He is not high in my suspicious list anymore, his logic makes sense most of the time.

Penguin: I said previously that Penguin only suspects Hark now, reread his ISO and saw he's had him in leanscum since early on. My bad. However, I do think Penguin's dislike of Hark is very defensive. Hark called Penguin out for lack of content, and so starts the penguin Hark feud, but even when Hark corrects himself and realizes he has less posts because he replaced in he goes on not liking him.

Serra: Smells fishy, and scummy. He refuses to give reads on everyone because it apparently helps scum chose who to lynch, which I don't buy. Jumps in from the beginning and buddies with Shadow against me, because of my rubbish reason for voting Loop and being confusing, apparently not buying the excuse that I'm a newbie and am not eloquent and clear.

Shadow: Has blind tunneled me the whole game. And apparently refuses to consider the possibility that I'm town. And when he does consider it he says we should lynch me anyways because Scum would want to keep me alive. Also refuses to give his reads until super pressured. Also gets extremely emotional, I understand this could be frustrated town but it seems too severe for that. He smells like scum

Thor: I honestly have no idea. I could throw together some random reason for suspecting scum/town but they wouldn't be actual reads that I believe.

[Creature]

VOTE: Thor665

Damn, no more claims today, please.

[Creature]

Thor665
Shadow_step
PenguinPower

These should go.

[Creature]

Vote Thor, we can do it.

[Loopdan]

Everyone be careful what you say here. If you are the other PR, or MT is lying and you are doc, you do not want to say anything that lets scum find you.

[Creature]

Don't counterclaim until Day 2.

[MissTerry]

Go, as in not be wagons?

[Creature]

Loop, will you vote Thor?

[Loopdan]

I don't know what optimal town play is here.

MT, can you point to any breadcrumbs to lend evidence to your claim?

[Creature]

The optimal town play is to not lynch the doc claim and not counterclaim until tomorrow.

[Creature]

Also, if we nolynch we'll have one less mislynch available.

[Creature]

7 hours.

We need a lynch.

Vote one of the wagons that's not MT or I'll treat that as a scumclaim.

[MissTerry]

Hm, not really. And I don't really think I should, wouldn't it just make it easier for scum to kill a PR? Feel free to convince me otherwise.